A is studying in
- (a) Rajasthan
- (b) Gujarat ✓ UPSC's answer
- (c) city Q
- (d) Kerala
Why the answer is (b)
• From condition (ii), the Arts college is in city S, which is in Rajasthan.
• From condition (v), the Science college is in Kerala.
• From condition (i), D is studying in Assam, so D is not in Rajasthan or Kerala.
• Since A is in the Commerce college (condition iii), A cannot be in the Arts college (Rajasthan) or the Science college (Kerala).
• The remaining states for the Commerce and Engineering colleges are Gujarat and Assam.
• Since D is in Assam, D must be in either the Commerce or Engineering college. However, A is in Commerce. If A were in Assam, D would have to be in Engineering. But we need to determine A's location specifically.
• Let's map the colleges to states: Arts=Rajasthan, Science=Kerala. Remaining: Commerce and Engineering are in Gujarat and Assam.
• D is in Assam. A is in Commerce. If A were in Assam, A would be in Commerce and D would be in Engineering. If A were in Gujarat, A would be in Commerce and D would be in Engineering (in Assam) or Commerce (impossible as A is Commerce). Wait, D is in Assam. The colleges in Assam and Gujarat are Commerce and Engineering.
• A is in Commerce. D is in Assam. D cannot be in Commerce if A is in Commerce (different students). So D is in Engineering (in Assam) or Commerce (in Assam). But A is in Commerce. So the Commerce college is either in Assam or Gujarat.
• If Commerce is in Assam, A is in Assam. Then D (in Assam) must be in Engineering. This is possible.
• If Commerce is in Gujarat, A is in Gujarat. Then D (in Assam) must be in Engineering. This is also possible.
• Let's look at the cities. B is in city Q (condition iv).
• Arts is in S (Rajasthan). Science is in Kerala.
• We need to place B. B is in Q. Q is not S (Arts/Rajasthan). So B is not in Arts.
• B is not in Science (Kerala) necessarily, but let's see.
• Let's re-evaluate the state-college mapping.
• States: Gujarat, Rajasthan, Assam, Kerala.
• Colleges: Arts (Rajasthan), Science (Kerala). Remaining: Commerce, Engineering in Gujarat, Assam.
• Students: A (Commerce), D (Assam).
• If A is in Assam, A is in Commerce (Assam). Then D is in Assam, so D is in Engineering (Assam).
• If A is in Gujarat, A is in Commerce (Gujarat). Then D is in Assam, so D is in Engineering (Assam).
• Is there a constraint on B? B is in city Q.
• Cities: P, Q, R, S. S is Rajasthan (Arts).
• So B is not in S. B is in P, Q, or R.
• Let's look at the options. (a) Rajasthan, (b) Gujarat, (c) city Q, (d) Kerala.
• A is in Commerce. Commerce is in Gujarat or Assam.
• If A is in Assam, the answer would be Assam (not an option).
• Therefore, A must be in Gujarat.
• Why can't A be in Assam? If A is in Assam, the answer 'Assam' is not listed. The options are Rajasthan, Gujarat, City Q, Kerala. Since 'Assam' is not an option, A cannot be in Assam.
• Thus, A must be in the other state for Commerce, which is Gujarat.
Why the other options are wrong
- (a) Rajasthan
- A is studying in the Commerce college, which is located in either Gujarat or Assam, not Rajasthan (where the Arts college is).
- (c) city Q
- While B is studying in city Q, there is no information linking A to city Q; A's location is determined by the state of the Commerce college.
- (d) Kerala
- A is studying in the Commerce college, whereas the Science college is located in Kerala, so A cannot be in Kerala.
Asked in the CSAT Paper II of the UPSC Civil Services Preliminary Examination 2018, held on 3 June 2018. Question and answer key: Union Public Service Commission. Explanation: UPSC Answer Check.