C is studying in
- (a) Science college
- (b) Rajasthan ✓ UPSC's answer
- (c) Gujarat
- (d) city Q
Why the answer is (b)
• From condition (ii), the Arts college is in city S, which is in Rajasthan.
• From condition (v), the Science college is in Kerala.
• From condition (i), D is studying in Assam. Since D is in Assam, D cannot be in Rajasthan (Arts/S) or Kerala (Science).
• The remaining states for the colleges are Gujarat and Assam. The remaining cities are P, Q, and R (since S is Rajasthan).
• B is in city Q (condition iv). B cannot be in Rajasthan (S) or Kerala (Science) if we assume distinct mappings, but let's map colleges to states first: Arts=Rajasthan, Science=Kerala. Remaining colleges: Commerce, Engineering. Remaining states: Gujarat, Assam.
• D is in Assam. D is not in Arts (Rajasthan) or Science (Kerala). So D is in either Commerce or Engineering.
• A is in Commerce (condition iii). A is not D. So A is in Commerce.
• If A is in Commerce, and D is in Assam, we need to place A and D.
• Let's determine the state of each college. Arts=Rajasthan, Science=Kerala. Commerce and Engineering are in Gujarat and Assam.
• D is in Assam. D is not in Arts or Science. So D is in Commerce or Engineering.
• A is in Commerce. A is not D.
• If Commerce were in Assam, A would be in Assam. But D is in Assam. Two people cannot be in the same city/state if the problem implies one student per city/state? The prompt says 'studying in four different cities' and 'four different States'. It implies a 1-to-1 mapping between Student, City, College, State.
• Therefore, D (Assam) corresponds to one college. A (Commerce) corresponds to one state.
• Since D is in Assam, the college in Assam is either Commerce or Engineering.
• If the college in Assam is Commerce, then A is in Assam. But D is in Assam. Contradiction (A != D). Thus, the college in Assam is NOT Commerce.
• Therefore, the college in Assam is Engineering. So D is in Engineering college in Assam.
• This leaves Commerce college in Gujarat.
• So, A is in Commerce college in Gujarat.
• We have: D=Engineering/Assam, A=Commerce/Gujarat.
• Remaining students: B, C. Remaining colleges: Arts, Science. Remaining states: Rajasthan, Kerala. Remaining cities: P, Q, R (S is Rajasthan).
• Arts college is in Rajasthan (City S). Science college is in Kerala.
• B is in city Q. B cannot be in City S (Rajasthan/Arts) because B is in Q. So B is not in Arts college.
• Therefore, B is in Science college (Kerala).
• This leaves C to be in Arts college (Rajasthan, City S).
• So, C is studying in Arts college in Rajasthan.
• The question asks where C is studying. C is in Rajasthan.
Why the other options are wrong
- (a) Science college
- C is studying in Arts college, not Science college (which is in Kerala and occupied by B).
- (c) Gujarat
- C is studying in Rajasthan, not Gujarat (which is occupied by A in Commerce college).
- (d) city Q
- C is studying in city S, not city Q (which is occupied by B in Science college).
Asked in the CSAT Paper II of the UPSC Civil Services Preliminary Examination 2018, held on 3 June 2018. Question and answer key: Union Public Service Commission. Explanation: UPSC Answer Check.