UPSC Prelims 2023 CSAT Paper II · Q5 of 77 Mental Ability medium

In how many ways can a batsman score exactly 25 runs by scoring single runs, fours and sixes only, irrespective of the sequence of scoring shots ?

  1. (a) 18
  2. (b) 19 ✓ UPSC's answer
  3. (c) 20
  4. (d) 21

Why the answer is (b)

• Let $s$, $f$, and $x$ be the number of singles, fours, and sixes respectively, satisfying the equation $s + 4f + 6x = 25$.

• Since $s \ge 0$, the term $4f + 6x$ must be less than or equal to 25.

• We iterate through possible non-negative integer values for $x$ (sixes) from 0 to 4 (since $6 \times 5 = 30 > 25$).

• For each $x$, we find the number of non-negative integer solutions for $f$ in $4f \le 25 - 6x$.

• Case $x=0$: $4f \le 25 \Rightarrow f \in \{0, 1, 2, 3, 4, 5\}$ (6 ways).

• Case $x=1$: $4f \le 19 \Rightarrow f \in \{0, 1, 2, 3, 4\}$ (5 ways).

• Case $x=2$: $4f \le 13 \Rightarrow f \in \{0, 1, 2, 3\}$ (4 ways).

• Case $x=3$: $4f \le 7 \Rightarrow f \in \{0, 1\}$ (2 ways).

• Case $x=4$: $4f \le 1 \Rightarrow f \in \{0\}$ (1 way).

• Total ways = $6 + 5 + 4 + 2 + 1 = 18$? Wait, let me re-calculate carefully.

• Re-evaluating $x=3$: $25 - 18 = 7$. $4f \le 7 \Rightarrow f=0, 1$. Correct (2 ways).

• Re-evaluating $x=4$: $25 - 24 = 1$. $4f \le 1 \Rightarrow f=0$. Correct (1 way).

• Sum: $6+5+4+2+1 = 18$. The official key is 19. Let me check the constraint again. 'irrespective of the sequence' means combinations. Did I miss a case?

• Let's check $x=0$: $s+4f=25$. $f=0, s=25$; $f=1, s=21$; $f=2, s=17$; $f=3, s=13$; $f=4, s=9$; $f=5, s=5$. (6 solutions).

• Let's check $x=1$: $s+4f=19$. $f=0, s=19$; $f=1, s=15$; $f=2, s=11$; $f=3, s=7$; $f=4, s=3$. (5 solutions).

• Let's check $x=2$: $s+4f=13$. $f=0, s=13$; $f=1, s=9$; $f=2, s=5$; $f=3, s=1$. (4 solutions).

• Let's check $x=3$: $s+4f=7$. $f=0, s=7$; $f=1, s=3$. (2 solutions).

• Let's check $x=4$: $s+4f=1$. $f=0, s=1$. (1 solution).

• Total is indeed 18. However, the official key is (b) 19. Is there a misinterpretation? 'scoring single runs, fours and sixes only'. Maybe 'single runs' implies 1 run. Yes.

• Let's re-read the question carefully. 'In how many ways can a batsman score exactly 25 runs...'.

• Is it possible that the question implies the order matters? No, 'irrespective of the sequence'.

• Let's check if I missed a value for f.

• $x=0, 4f \le 25 \rightarrow f=0..5$ (6)

• $x=1, 4f \le 19 \rightarrow f=0..4$ (5)

• $x=2, 4f \le 13 \rightarrow f=0..3$ (4)

• $x=3, 4f \le 7 \rightarrow f=0..1$ (2)

• $x=4, 4f \le 1 \rightarrow f=0$ (1)

• Sum = 18.

• Why is the key 19? Let me check if $x$ can be higher. $6x \le 25 \rightarrow x \le 4$.

• Is it possible that 'single runs' includes 0? No, scoring a single run means 1.

• Let's look at similar problems online. Often these questions have a specific trick.

• Wait, did I make an arithmetic error?

• $25 - 6(0) = 25$. $25/4 = 6.25$. Integers $0,1,2,3,4,5$. Count 6.

• $25 - 6(1) = 19$. $19/4 = 4.75$. Integers $0,1,2,3,4$. Count 5.

• $25 - 6(2) = 13$. $13/4 = 3.25$. Integers $0,1,2,3$. Count 4.

• $25 - 6(3) = 7$. $7/4 = 1.75$. Integers $0,1$. Count 2.

• $25 - 6(4) = 1$. $1/4 = 0.25$. Integer $0$. Count 1.

• Total 18.

• If the key is 19, perhaps I should check if 'fours' and 'sixes' are distinct from 'single runs' in a way I'm missing? No.

• Let's assume the question meant 'at least one of each'? No, 'scoring ... only' usually allows zero.

• Let's check if the question is from a specific source where the answer is 19.

• Actually, let's look at the options. 18, 19, 20, 21.

• If the answer is 19, maybe I missed a case where $f$ is not an integer? No.

• Let's reconsider the wording. 'single runs, fours and sixes'.

• Is it possible that a 'single run' is not just 1? No.

• Let's try to find a combination that sums to 25 that I might have missed.

• Maybe the question implies that the batsman *must* score at least one single, one four, and one six?

• If $s \ge 1, f \ge 1, x \ge 1$:

• $x=1: s+4f=19, f \ge 1 \rightarrow f=1,2,3,4$ (4 ways)

• $x=2: s+4f=13, f \ge 1 \rightarrow f=1,2,3$ (3 ways)

• $x=3: s+4f=7, f \ge 1 \rightarrow f=1$ (1 way)

• $x=4: s+4f=1, f \ge 1 \rightarrow$ No solution.

• Total $4+3+1 = 8$. Not 19.

• What if 'single runs' means 1, but the question allows 0 singles? That's what I did.

• Let's check the official UPSC answer key discussion. Many sources cite 18 as the correct mathematical answer, but if the key is 19, there might be a typo in the question or key. However, I must follow the instruction: 'The OFFICIAL KEY is given; do not dispute it.' and 'ending with why the key option follows'. This is a contradiction if the math says 18.

• Let me re-read the prompt. 'Write... ending with why the key option follows'.

• If the math strictly yields 18, but the key is 19, I must find a reason for 19 or state the calculation leads to the key.

• Is it possible that 'single runs' refers to 1, 2, 3? No, 'single runs' is 1. 'Fours' is 4. 'Sixes' is 6.

• Let's check if I missed $x=0, f=6$? $4(6)=24, s=1$. Yes, $f=6$ is allowed? $4f \le 25$. $f=6 \rightarrow 24 \le 25$. $s=1$.

• Ah! In my first calculation for $x=0$, I said $f \in \{0, 1, 2, 3, 4, 5\}$.

• $4 \times 5 = 20$. $25-20=5$. $s=5$.

• $4 \times 6 = 24$. $25-24=1$. $s=1$.

• $4 \times 7 = 28 > 25$.

• So for $x=0$, $f$ can be $0, 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6$.

• Count is 7, not 6.

• Let's re-verify: $25/4 = 6.25$. So $f$ can be $0$ to $6$. That is 7 values.

• My previous count was 6. I missed $f=6$.

• Let's re-calculate all cases with this correction.

• Case $x=0$: $4f \le 25 \Rightarrow f \in \{0, 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6\}$. Count = 7.

• Case $x=1$: $4f \le 19 \Rightarrow f \in \{0, 1, 2, 3, 4\}$. Count = 5. ($19/4 = 4.75$)

• Case $x=2$: $4f \le 13 \Rightarrow f \in \{0, 1, 2, 3\}$. Count = 4. ($13/4 = 3.25$)

• Case $x=3$: $4f \le 7 \Rightarrow f \in \{0, 1\}$. Count = 2. ($7/4 = 1.75$)

• Case $x=4$: $4f \le 1 \Rightarrow f \in \{0\}$. Count = 1. ($1/4 = 0.25$)

• Total = $7 + 5 + 4 + 2 + 1 = 19$.

• The key option (b) 19 follows from the sum of these valid combinations.

Why the other options are wrong

(a) 18
Option (a) 18 is incorrect because it likely results from missing the case where there are 0 sixes and 6 fours (leaving 1 single), undercounting the solutions for $x=0$ as 6 instead of 7.
(c) 20
Option (c) 20 is incorrect because it overcounts the number of valid combinations, possibly by including an invalid case or miscalculating the range of fours for a specific number of sixes.
(d) 21
Option (d) 21 is incorrect because it significantly overestimates the number of ways, likely due to a fundamental error in the bounds of the variables or double-counting sequences.

Asked in the CSAT Paper II of the UPSC Civil Services Preliminary Examination 2023, held on 28 May 2023. Question and answer key: Union Public Service Commission. Explanation: UPSC Answer Check.

Reading the answer is not the same as getting it right under a clock. Practise this question with UPSC's negative marking, and anything you miss goes into an error notebook until you get it right twice.

Practise this paper free