UPSC Prelims 2026 CSAT Paper II · Q37 of 70 Basic Numeracy hard

X and Y are two runners who run for the same duration of time on the same circular track. They started running at the same time in the same direction with uniform speeds. When X completed 7 rounds, Y did exactly 5. After completing 5 rounds, Y changed his direction and started running in the opposite direction with speed which is double of his earlier speed. On the other hand, X continued to run with the same speed. They stopped running when X completed exactly 21 rounds. How many times did X and Y meet after they had started and before they finally stopped?

  1. (a) 35 ✓ UPSC's answer
  2. (b) 34
  3. (c) 31
  4. (d) 29

Why the answer is (a)

• Let the track length be 1 unit. Since X runs 7 rounds while Y runs 5 in the same time, their speed ratio is $V_x : V_y = 7 : 5$. Let $V_x = 7u$ and $V_y = 5u$.

• The total time of the race is determined by X completing 21 rounds. Time $T = \frac{21}{7u} = \frac{3}{u}$.

• Y runs for the first 5 rounds at speed $5u$. Time taken $t_1 = \frac{5}{5u} = \frac{1}{u}$. During this time, X runs $7u \times \frac{1}{u} = 7$ rounds.

• After $t_1$, Y changes direction and doubles his speed to $10u$. The remaining time is $T - t_1 = \frac{3}{u} - \frac{1}{u} = \frac{2}{u}$.

• In this remaining time, Y runs distance $10u \times \frac{2}{u} = 20$ rounds in the opposite direction. X runs $7u \times \frac{2}{u} = 14$ rounds in the original direction.

• Total distance covered by X is 21 rounds. Total distance covered by Y is 5 (forward) + 20 (backward) = 25 rounds.

• To find the number of meetings, we consider the relative motion. In the first phase (same direction), they meet when the faster runner gains 1 full lap on the slower one. Relative speed is $7u - 5u = 2u$. Time for 1 meeting is $1/2u$. In time $1/u$, they meet $\frac{1/u}{1/2u} = 2$ times. (Note: They start together, so the first 'gain' of 1 lap is the 1st meeting, 2 laps is the 2nd meeting. At $t=1/u$, X has gained exactly 2 laps on Y, so they meet at the starting point. This counts as 2 meetings after start? No, usually 'meet' implies crossing. Let's use the standard formula: Number of meetings = Total relative distance / Track Length. But direction changes complicate this. Let's track positions.)

• Let's use the position method. Position $P_x(t) = 7t \pmod 1$. Position $P_y(t)$ depends on phase.

• Phase 1 ($0 \le t \le 1/u$): $P_x = 7t$, $P_y = 5t$. They meet when $7t - 5t = k$ (integer). $2t = k$. $t = k/2$. Since $t \le 1/u$, $k$ can be 1, 2. So 2 meetings at $t=0.5/u$ and $t=1/u$.

• Phase 2 ($1/u < t \le 3/u$): Let $t' = t - 1/u$. $P_x = 7(1/u + t') = 7/u + 7t' \equiv 7t' \pmod 1$ (since $7/u$ is integer multiple of track? No, $7/u$ is 7 rounds, so position is 0). So $P_x = 7t' \pmod 1$. $P_y$ starts at 0 (after 5 rounds) and moves opposite. $P_y = -10t' \pmod 1$. They meet when $7t' - (-10t') = m$ (integer). $17t' = m$. $t' = m/17$. Range of $t'$ is $0$ to $2/u$. So $0 < m/17 \le 2/u$. Wait, units. $t'$ is in units of $1/u$. So $0 < m/17 \le 2$. $m$ can be $1, 2, ..., 34$. So 34 meetings in Phase 2.

• Total meetings = 2 (Phase 1) + 34 (Phase 2) = 36? Wait. The question asks 'after they had started'. The meeting at $t=0$ is not counted. The meeting at $t=1/u$ is the end of Phase 1 and start of Phase 2. Is it counted twice? No, it's a single instant. In Phase 1 calculation, $k=2$ gives $t=1/u$. In Phase 2 calculation, $m=0$ would be $t'=0$, which is $t=1/u$. We excluded $m=0$ in Phase 2 ($0 < m/17$). So the meeting at $t=1/u$ is counted in Phase 1. The meetings in Phase 2 are for $m=1$ to $34$. So 34 meetings. Total = 2 + 34 = 36. This contradicts the key (35). Let's re-read carefully. 'How many times did X and Y meet after they had started and before they finally stopped?'

• Let's re-evaluate Phase 1. $2t = k$. $t=k/2$. $t$ goes from 0 to 1. $k=1, 2$. Meetings at $t=0.5$ and $t=1$. (2 meetings).

• Phase 2. $t'$ goes from 0 to 2. $17t' = m$. $m=1, ..., 34$. Meetings at $t'=1/17, ..., 34/17=2$. The meeting at $t'=2$ corresponds to $t=3/u$, which is the end of the race. The question says 'before they finally stopped'. Usually, the final stop is not a 'meeting' in the context of 'how many times did they meet' if they stop there, or is it? If they stop at the same time, do they 'meet'? They are at the same place. But the phrasing 'before they finally stopped' might exclude the final instant. If we exclude $t=3/u$, then $m$ goes up to 33. Then Phase 2 has 33 meetings. Total = 2 + 33 = 35. This matches the key.

• So, Phase 1: 2 meetings ($t=0.5/u, 1/u$). Phase 2: 33 meetings ($t'=1/17/u$ to $33/17/u$). The meeting at $t'=2/u$ (end of race) is excluded because it is not 'before' they stopped, or simply because the race ends. Total 35.

Why the other options are wrong

(b) 34
This option likely results from excluding the meeting at the end of Phase 1 ($t=1/u$) or miscounting the final instant, leading to 34.
(c) 31
This option likely results from an error in calculating the relative speed or the number of laps in the second phase, resulting in a lower count.
(d) 29
This option likely results from a significant calculation error in the relative distance or time duration, leading to a much lower count.

Asked in the CSAT Paper II of the UPSC Civil Services Preliminary Examination 2026, held on 24 May 2026. Question and answer key: Union Public Service Commission. Explanation: UPSC Answer Check.

Reading the answer is not the same as getting it right under a clock. Practise this question with UPSC's negative marking, and anything you miss goes into an error notebook until you get it right twice.

Practise this paper free