A class starts at 11:00 am and lasts till 2:27 pm. Four periods of equal duration are held during this interval. After every period, a rest of 5 minutes is given to the students. The exact duration of each period is :
- (a) 48 minutes ✓ UPSC's answer
- (b) 50 minutes
- (c) 51 minutes
- (d) 53 minutes
Why the answer is (a)
• The total duration of the class is calculated from 11:00 am to 2:27 pm, which equals 3 hours and 27 minutes, or 207 minutes.
• There are four periods of equal duration, denoted as 'x' minutes each.
• A rest of 5 minutes is given after every period, resulting in 4 rests totaling 20 minutes (4 * 5).
• The equation for the total time is 4x + 20 = 207.
• Solving for x gives 4x = 187, which results in x = 46.75 minutes.
• However, reviewing the standard interpretation of such problems where 'after every period' might imply breaks between periods or checking the options, let's re-evaluate the total time. 11:00 to 2:27 is 3 hours 27 mins = 207 mins. If there are 4 periods and 4 breaks, 4x + 20 = 207 -> x = 46.75. This does not match any option. Let's re-read carefully. 'After every period'. Usually, in such exams, if the answer is 48, the total time must be 4*48 + 20 = 192 + 20 = 212 mins. 212 mins is 3 hours 32 mins. The end time would be 2:32 pm. The question says 2:27 pm. Let's check option (a) 48 mins. 4*48 = 192. 192 + 20 = 212. 11:00 + 212 mins = 2:32 pm. This is a discrepancy. Let's check if 'rest' is only between periods. If 3 rests: 4x + 15 = 207 -> 4x = 192 -> x = 48. This matches option (a). The phrase 'After every period' is often loosely interpreted in these specific UPSC questions as breaks *between* the periods or the question implies the final break is not counted towards the 'class duration' or there is a typo in the question's end time vs the intended logic. Given the official key is (a), the logic used is 4 periods and 3 breaks (or the total time is treated as 212 mins in the source error, but 48 is the only integer solution close to the calculation if we assume 3 breaks). Actually, 207 - 15 (3 breaks) = 192. 192 / 4 = 48. The standard solution for this specific PYQ assumes 3 breaks between 4 periods.
Why the other options are wrong
- (b) 50 minutes
- 50 minutes would require a total class time of 215 minutes (3 hours 35 minutes), which exceeds the given 207 minutes.
- (c) 51 minutes
- 51 minutes would require a total class time of 219 minutes (3 hours 39 minutes), which is inconsistent with the 207-minute duration.
- (d) 53 minutes
- 53 minutes would require a total class time of 227 minutes (3 hours 47 minutes), which is significantly longer than the actual class duration.
Asked in the CSAT Paper II of the UPSC Civil Services Preliminary Examination 2016, held on 7 August 2016. Question and answer key: Union Public Service Commission. Explanation: UPSC Answer Check.