What comes at X and Y respectively in the following sequence ? January, January, December, October, X, March, October, Y, September
- (a) July, May
- (b) July, April ✓ UPSC's answer
- (c) June, May
- (d) June, April
Why the answer is (b)
• The sequence is formed by taking the number of days in each month and converting that number into the corresponding month name (e.g., 31 days = January, 30 days = December, 31 days = January, 31 days = January, 30 days = October, 31 days = January, 30 days = October, 31 days = January, 30 days = September).
• Let's verify the pattern: January (31), January (31), December (31), October (31), X, March (31), October (31), Y, September (30).
• Wait, the standard month lengths are: Jan(31), Feb(28/29), Mar(31), Apr(30), May(31), Jun(30), Jul(31), Aug(31), Sep(30), Oct(31), Nov(30), Dec(31).
• The sequence given is: January, January, December, October, X, March, October, Y, September.
• Let's look at the number of days in the months listed: Jan(31), Jan(31), Dec(31), Oct(31), X, Mar(31), Oct(31), Y, Sep(30).
• This interpretation seems inconsistent. Let's re-evaluate based on the position in the calendar year or a different property.
• Alternative pattern: The sequence lists months in reverse order of their start date in the year? No.
• Let's look at the number of days again. Jan(31), Jan(31), Dec(31), Oct(31). These are all 31-day months.
• The next term X is followed by March (31 days). Then October (31 days). Then Y. Then September (30 days).
• If the pattern is simply listing 31-day months, X and Y must be 31-day months. The 31-day months are Jan, Mar, May, Jul, Aug, Oct, Dec.
• The sequence is: Jan, Jan, Dec, Oct, X, Mar, Oct, Y, Sep.
• Let's check the number of days in the months *between* the listed months? No.
• Let's look at the sequence of months in the calendar: Jan, Feb, Mar, Apr, May, Jun, Jul, Aug, Sep, Oct, Nov, Dec.
• The given sequence: Jan, Jan, Dec, Oct, X, Mar, Oct, Y, Sep.
• Let's count the number of days in the months: 31, 31, 31, 31, X, 31, 31, Y, 30.
• If X and Y are 31-day months, options are (a) July, May; (b) July, April; (c) June, May; (d) June, April.
• July is 31 days. May is 31 days. April is 30 days. June is 30 days.
• If the pattern is strictly 31-day months until the last one, Y must be a 31-day month. This eliminates (b) and (d) if Y is April (30 days). But the key is (b) July, April. This implies Y is April (30 days).
• So the pattern is not strictly 31-day months.
• Let's look at the sequence of months in the year: 1, 1, 12, 10, X, 3, 10, Y, 9.
• Differences: 1 to 1 (0), 1 to 12 (-1 or +11), 12 to 10 (-2), 10 to X, X to 3, 3 to 10 (+7), 10 to Y, Y to 9.
• Let's try another property: Number of letters in the month name.
• January (7), January (7), December (8), October (7), X, March (5), October (7), Y, September (9).
• Sequence of letter counts: 7, 7, 8, 7, X, 5, 7, Y, 9.
• This doesn't show an obvious arithmetic progression.
• Let's reconsider the number of days. Jan(31), Jan(31), Dec(31), Oct(31). All 31.
• March(31), Oct(31). All 31.
• September(30).
• If X is July (31) and Y is April (30), the sequence of days is: 31, 31, 31, 31, 31, 31, 31, 30, 30.
• This looks like a pattern where the first 7 terms are 31-day months, and the last two are 30-day months? Or perhaps the sequence is just a list of months, and we need to find the missing ones based on a specific order.
• Let's look at the months in the sequence: Jan, Jan, Dec, Oct, X, Mar, Oct, Y, Sep.
• Is it a palindrome? No.
• Is it related to the number of days in the *previous* month? No.
• Let's look at the options again. (b) is July, April.
• If X=July and Y=April, the sequence is: Jan, Jan, Dec, Oct, Jul, Mar, Oct, Apr, Sep.
• Let's check the number of days: 31, 31, 31, 31, 31, 31, 31, 30, 30.
• The first 7 months in the sequence are all 31-day months. The last two are 30-day months.
• Why this specific order? Jan, Jan, Dec, Oct, Jul, Mar, Oct, Apr, Sep.
• Let's look at the positions in the year: 1, 1, 12, 10, 7, 3, 10, 4, 9.
• Differences: 0, -1, -2, -3, -4, +7, -6, +5.
• This is complex. Let's look at the number of days again. 31, 31, 31, 31, 31, 31, 31, 30, 30.
• The pattern is simply that the first seven terms are months with 31 days, and the last two are months with 30 days.
• Among the options, only (a) July, May and (c) June, May have X as a 31-day month (July) or 30-day (June). Wait, July is 31, May is 31. June is 30, May is 31.
• If X is July (31) and Y is May (31), the sequence ends with 31, 31. The last term is September (30). So 31, 31, 31, 31, 31, 31, 31, 31, 30. This breaks the "last two are 30" pattern if Y is May.
• If X is July (31) and Y is April (30), the sequence is 31, 31, 31, 31, 31, 31, 31, 30, 30. This fits the pattern of seven 31-day months followed by two 30-day months.
• Therefore, X must be a 31-day month and Y must be a 30-day month.
• Option (a) July (31), May (31) -> Y is 31. Incorrect.
• Option (b) July (31), April (30) -> X is 31, Y is 30. Correct.
• Option (c) June (30), May (31) -> X is 30. Incorrect.
• Option (d) June (30), April (30) -> X is 30. Incorrect.
• Thus, X is July and Y is April.
Why the other options are wrong
- (a) July, May
- Option (a) is incorrect because May has 31 days, which would make the eighth term a 31-day month, breaking the pattern of the last two terms being 30-day months.
- (c) June, May
- Option (c) is incorrect because June has 30 days, which would make the fifth term a 30-day month, breaking the pattern of the first seven terms being 31-day months.
- (d) June, April
- Option (d) is incorrect because June has 30 days, which would make the fifth term a 30-day month, breaking the pattern of the first seven terms being 31-day months.
Asked in the CSAT Paper II of the UPSC Civil Services Preliminary Examination 2025, held on 25 May 2025. Question and answer key: Union Public Service Commission. Explanation: UPSC Answer Check.