Civil Engineering 2023 Paper I 50 marks Design

Paper I — Q3

(a) Design a floor slab to cover a room with internal dimensions of 4·5 m × 6·0 m. The slab is simply supported on all the sides…

(a)

Design a floor slab to cover a room with internal dimensions of 4·5 m × 6·0 m. The slab is simply supported on all the sides on 230 mm thick masonry walls. The slab carries a live load of 4·0 kN/m² and a dead load due to finishing work of 1·0 kN/m². The corners of the slab are prevented from lifting up. Use M 20 concrete and Fe 415 steel. Assume mild exposure conditions. 20 marks

Table : Bending Moment coefficients when four edges are discontinuous

l_y/l_xShort span coefficient, α_xLong span coefficient, α_y
1·01·11·21·31·41·5for all values of l_y/l_x
α_x0·0560·0640·0720·0790·0850·0890·056

Modification Factor for Tension Reinforcement Note : f_s is steel stress of service loads in N/mm² f_s = 0.58 f_y (Area of cross-section of steel required)/(Area of cross-section of steel provided)

(b)

A built-up column of effective length 10 m is designed by placing two ISMC 300 @ 363 N/m back to back at a spacing 'S' mm. The column is to carry a factored axial load of 1100 kN. Find the economical spacing 'S' of the two channel sections. Also design the batten system for the column. M 20 bolts of grade 4.6 are used for making the connections. Do not design the connections. Use E 250 grade of steel. 20 marks

For connections : Edge distance = 32 mm Gauge distance = 50 mm

Properties of ISMC 300 : A = 4630 mm² r_zz = 118 mm, r_yy = 26.0 mm I_zz = 6420 × 10⁴ mm⁴ I_yy = 313 × 10⁴ mm⁴ C_y = 23.5 t_f = 13.6 300 z z t_w=7.8 y 90 ISMC 300 (All dimensions are in mm)

(c)

Using slope deflection method, determine the final end moments for the portal frame shown in the figure. The frame is fixed at A and D, and has rigid joints at B and C. Take EI as constant. 10 marks

हिंदी में प्रश्न पढ़ें
(a)

4·5 m × 6·0 m की आंतरिक विमाओं के एक कक्ष के आच्छादन के लिए एक फर्श छतपट की अभिकल्पना कीजिए । छतपट सभी ओर पर 230 mm मोटी चिनाई की दीवारों पर शुड्डालम्बित है । छतपट 4·0 kN/m² का एक चल भार और परिष्करण कार्य के कारण 1·0 kN/m² का एक अचल भार वहन करता है । छतपट के कोनों को ऊपर उठने से रोका गया है । M 20 कंक्रीट और Fe 415 इस्पात का उपयोग कीजिए । हल्की प्रभावन अवस्थाएँ मान लीजिए । (20 अंक)

सारणी : बंकन आधुर्ण गुणांक, जब चारों कोर असतत हैं

लघु विस्तृति गुणांक, αₓदीर्घ विस्तृति गुणांक, αᵧ
lᵧ/lₓ1·01·11·21·31·41·5lᵧ/lₓ के सभी मानों के लिए
αₓ0·0560·0640·0720·0790·0850·0890·056

तनन प्रबलन के लिए आशोधन गुणक नोट : f_s सेवा भारों का इस्पात प्रतिबल N/mm² में है f_s = 0.58 f_y आवश्यक इस्पात का अनुप्रस्थ-परिच्छेद क्षेत्रफल —————————————————————— प्रदत इस्पात का अनुप्रस्थ-परिच्छेद क्षेत्रफल

(b)

दो ISMC 300 @ 363 N/m को 'S' mm के अंतरण पर सहपृष्ठ रखकर, 10 m प्रभावी लंबाई के एक संधित स्तंभ की अभिकल्पना की गई है । स्तंभ को 1100 kN का एक गुणित अक्षीय भार बहन करना है । दो चैनल परिछेदों के मितव्ययी अंतरण 'S' को ज्ञात कीजिए । स्तंभ के लिए बता तंत्र की भी अभिकल्पना कीजिए । जोड़ों को बनाने के लिए 4·6 ग्रेड के M 20 बोल्टों को उपयोग किया गया है । जोड़ों की अभिकल्पना नहीं कीजिए । E 250 ग्रेड इस्पात का उपयोग कीजिए । (20 अंक)

जोड़ों के लिए : कोर दूरी = 32 mm गेज दूरी = 50 mm

ISMC 300 के गुण : A = 4630 mm² r_zz = 118 mm, r_yy = 26.0 mm I_zz = 6420 × 10⁴ mm⁴ I_yy = 313 × 10⁴ mm⁴ C_y = 23.5 t_f = 13.6 300 z z t_w=7.8 y 90 ISMC 300 (सभी विमाएँ mm में हैं)

(c)

प्रवणता विषम विधि का उपयोग करके, चित्र में दर्शाए पोर्टल फ्रेम के लिए अंतिम सिरा आघूर्णों को निर्धारित कीजिए। फ्रेम, A और D पर आबद्ध है तथा B और C पर दृढ़ जोड़ हैं। EI को नियत लीजिए। (10 अंक)

Q3 of the 2023 UPSC Mains Civil Engineering Paper I, as printed
The question as printed in the 2023 Civil Engineering paper

The figure this question refers to, in words

The question paper is a scan and the diagram did not survive as text. This is the figure as read from the original page — every component, value and label — so the question can be worked from the text below.

(a) Graph titled 'Modification Factor for Tension Reinforcement'. The vertical axis is 'Modification Factor' ranging from 0.4 to 2.0 with grid lines at 0.4, 0.8, 1.2, 1.6, 2.0. The horizontal axis is 'Percentage Tension Reinforcement' ranging from 0 to 3.0 with grid lines at 0, 0.4, 0.8, 1.2, 1.6, 2.0, 2.4, 2.8, 3.0. The graph contains five curves representing different values of steel stress (fs). The curves are labeled from top to bottom as: fs = 120, fs = 145, fs = 190, fs = 240, fs = 290. A note inside the graph states: 'Note: fs is steel stress of service loads in N/mm2'. Below the graph is the formula: fs = 0.58 fy (Area of cross-section of steel required / Area of cross-section of steel provided).

(b) A cross-sectional view of a built-up column section composed of two ISMC 300 channels placed back-to-back. The channels are oriented with their web plates vertical and facing each other, separated by a gap. The flanges of the channels point outwards to the left and right. The section is labeled 'ISMC 300'. Dimensions provided in millimeters: The depth of the channel is 300. The width of the flange is 90. The thickness of the flange (t_f) is 13.6. The thickness of the web (t_w) is 7.8. The centroidal axis 'z-z' is shown as a horizontal line passing through the center of the section. The centroidal axis 'y-y' is shown as a vertical line passing through the center of the gap between the two channels. The distance from the y-y axis to the centroid of one channel is labeled C_y = 23.5.

(c) A cross-sectional view of a built-up column consisting of two ISMC 300 channel sections placed back-to-back. The sections are oriented with their webs vertical and flanges facing outward. The vertical axis is labeled 'z z' and the horizontal axis is labeled 'y'. Dimensions provided: depth of channel is 300 mm, flange width is 90 mm, web thickness t_w is 7.8 mm, and flange thickness t_f is 13.6 mm. The text 'ISMC 300' is written below the section.

Model answer

Drafted with AI by UPSC Answer Check against this question's marking rubric, to the expected length. UPSC does not publish answers for Mains — this is one way to score well, not an official key. How we build rubrics and answers.

(a) Two-way slab, 4.5 m × 6.0 m, corners held down (IS 456)

Trial depth D = 180 mm, cover 20 mm, 10 mm bars: d = 155 mm for the short span and 145 mm for the long span. Effective spans: l_x = 4.5 + 0.155 = 4.655 m (less than the c/c span 4.73 m) and l_y = 6.155 m, so l_y/l_x = 1.322.

Load: self-weight 0.18 × 25 = 4.5 kN/m², finishes 1.0, live 4.0, so w = 9.5 kN/m² and w_u = 1.5 × 9.5 = 14.25 kN/m².

Moments: α_x = 0.079 + 0.22 × (0.085 − 0.079) = 0.0803 and α_y = 0.056. M_x = 0.0803 × 14.25 × 4.655² = 24.8 kN·m/m and M_y = 0.056 × 14.25 × 4.655² = 17.3 kN·m/m. M_u,lim = 0.138 f_ck b d² = 66.3 kN·m/m, above M_x, so the section is under-reinforced.

Steel, from M_u = 0.87 f_y A_st d (1 − A_st f_y/(b d f_ck)): short span A_st = 473 mm²/m, so provide 10 mm bars at 150 mm c/c (524 mm²). Long span (d = 145) A_st = 348 mm²/m, so provide 10 mm at 200 mm c/c (393 mm²). Both exceed 0.12% of bD = 216 mm²/m, and the spacings are within 3d and 300 mm.

Deflection (short span): f_s = 0.58 × 415 × 473/524 = 217 N/mm² and p_t = 524/(1000 × 155) = 0.34%. The chart gives a modification factor of about 1.6. Allowable l/d = 20 × 1.6 = 32, against an actual 4655/155 = 30.0, so the check is satisfied.

Shear: V_u = 14.25 × 4.655/2 = 33.2 kN/m, τ_v = 33 200/(1000 × 155) = 0.21 N/mm². For p_t = 0.34%, τ_c ≈ 0.40 and k = 1.24, so kτ_c = 0.50 N/mm², which exceeds τ_v; safe.

Corner torsion steel: over l_x/5 = 0.93 m at each corner, provide top and bottom mats of 0.75 × 473 = 355 mm²/m each way, that is 8 mm bars at 140 mm c/c (359 mm²).

Final slab: 180 mm thick; short span 10 mm at 150 mm c/c; long span 10 mm at 200 mm c/c; 8 mm at 140 mm c/c corner mats, top and bottom.

(b) Battened column of two ISMC 300 channels

Economical spacing: the z–z axis passes through both webs, so I_zz = 2 × 6420 × 10⁴ = 12 840 × 10⁴ mm⁴. With the centroid of each channel 23.5 mm from its web back, I_yy = 2[313 × 10⁴ + 4630 (S/2 + 23.5)²]. Equating I_yy = I_zz: (S/2 + 23.5)² = (6420 − 313) × 10⁴/4630 = 13 190, so S/2 + 23.5 = 114.85 and S = 182.7 mm. Adopt S = 190 mm, which gives I_yy = 13 629 × 10⁴ mm⁴, slightly above I_zz, so z–z governs.

Strength: r_zz = 118 mm, λ = 10 000/118 = 84.7, and for a battened column the effective slenderness is 1.1λ = 93.2. With buckling class c (built-up channels) and f_y = 250 MPa, f_cd = 116.4 N/mm². P_d = 116.4 × 9260 = 1078 kN. This is about 2% below 1100 kN, so the pair is only marginally adequate, and since z–z governs a wider S cannot help; a slightly heavier channel would be needed for strict compliance. The battens are designed below for the specified load.

Batten spacing: C/r_yy ≤ 50 gives C ≤ 50 × 26 = 1300 mm, and C/r_yy ≤ 0.7λ_e = 65 is also met. Adopt C = 1250 mm c/c (8 equal panels in 10 m); C/r_yy = 48.1.

Forces: V_t = 2.5% × 1100 = 27.5 kN. The bolt line is 90 − 32 = 58 mm from the web back, so S′ = 190 + 2 × 58 = 306 mm. With N = 2 batten planes, longitudinal shear V_b = V_t C/(N S′) = 27.5 × 1250/(2 × 306) = 56.2 kN and moment M_b = V_t C/(2N) = 27.5 × 1250/4 = 8.59 kN·m.

Batten size: the distance between channel centroids is a = 190 + 2 × 23.5 = 237 mm. End battens need an effective depth of at least a = 237 mm, so with 2 × 32 mm edge distance the overall depth is 310 mm. Intermediate battens need at least 0.75a = 178 mm and 2 × 90 = 180 mm, so the overall depth is 250 mm. Thickness t ≥ S′/50 = 6.1 mm, so provide 8 mm. Length = S′ + 2 × 32 = 370 mm. Check of the 250 × 8 batten: shear capacity 250 × 8 × 250/(√3 × 1.1) = 262 kN exceeds 56.2 kN, and moment capacity (8 × 250²/6) × 250/1.1 = 18.9 kN·m exceeds 8.59 kN·m.

Adopt end battens 310 × 370 × 8 mm and intermediate battens 250 × 370 × 8 mm at 1250 mm c/c on both faces.

Diagram: Battened column: two ISMC 300 channels

(c) Portal frame by slope deflection

Fixed-end moments on BC: FEM_BC = −wL²/12 = −16 × 4²/12 = −21.33 kN·m and FEM_CB = +21.33 kN·m; the columns carry no load. The frame and load are symmetric, so there is no sway and θ_C = −θ_B, with θ_A = θ_D = 0.

With EI constant and clockwise moments positive: M_AB = (2EI/3)θ_B; M_BA = (4EI/3)θ_B; M_BC = (2EI/4)(2θ_B + θ_C) − 21.33 = (EI/2)θ_B − 21.33; M_CB = −(EI/2)θ_B + 21.33; M_CD = −(4EI/3)θ_B; M_DC = −(2EI/3)θ_B.

Joint B: M_BA + M_BC = 0 gives (4/3 + 1/2)EIθ_B = 21.33, so EIθ_B = 11.64.

Final end moments (kN·m): M_AB = +7.76, M_BA = +15.52, M_BC = −15.52, M_CB = +15.52, M_CD = −15.52, M_DC = −7.76. Joint B and joint C are in equilibrium (15.52 − 15.52 = 0). The beam hogs 15.52 kN·m at each end and sags wL²/8 − 15.52 = 16.48 kN·m at mid-span.

Diagram: Bending moment diagram

How this answer will be evaluated

Framework: IS 456:2000 (Limit State Method) and IS 800:2007 (Limit State Method)

What earns full marks: Complete design/analysis with all checks, correct units, and neat sketches.

Evaluation rubric

Each sub-part is marked on its own, against the marks and word limit printed on the paper.

  1. (a) Design the two-way slab for the 4.5 m × 6.0 m room. 20 marks

    calculate— given → formula → substitution → result with units → interpretation

    Must cover

    • Effective spans l_x = 4.655 m, l_y = 6.155 m; w_u = 14.25 kN/m²
    • α_x ≈ 0.0803, α_y = 0.056; M_x = 24.8 and M_y = 17.3 kN·m/m
    • 10 mm at 150 (short) and 10 mm at 200 (long) c/c
    • Deflection, shear checks and 8 mm at 140 corner torsion steel

    Loses marks

    • Omitting corner torsion steel or the deflection check.

    Earns more

    • Partial credit for moments without the steel design.

    Extra mark

    • Shows d check via M_u,lim = 66.3 kN·m/m.
  2. (b) Find the economical spacing S and design the batten system. 20 marks

    calculate— given → formula → substitution → result with units → interpretation

    Must cover

    • I_yy = I_zz gives S = 182.7, adopt 190 mm
    • λ = 84.7, λ_e = 1.1λ = 93.2; P_d ≈ 1078 kN (strength check)
    • Batten spacing C ≈ 1250 mm; V_t = 27.5 kN; V_b, M_b
    • Batten size: end 310, intermediate 250 deep, t = 8 mm, length ≈ 370

    Loses marks

    • Forgetting the 1.1 factor or the 2.5% transverse shear.

    Earns more

    • Partial credit for S without the batten design.

    Extra mark

    • Notes the marginal shortfall against 1100 kN.
  3. (c) Find the final end moments of the portal frame by slope deflection. 10 marks

    calculate— given → formula → substitution → result with units → interpretation

    Must cover

    • FEM_BC = −21.33 and FEM_CB = +21.33 kN·m
    • Symmetry: no sway, θ_C = −θ_B
    • EIθ_B = 11.64 from joint equilibrium
    • M_AB = 7.76, M_BA = 15.52, M_BC = −15.52, M_CB = 15.52, M_CD = −15.52, M_DC = −7.76

    Loses marks

    • Including sway in a symmetric frame.

    Earns more

    • Partial credit for the equations with an arithmetic slip.

    Extra mark

    • Gives mid-span sagging moment 16.48 kN·m.
What "Design" is asking you to do

Produce a specification that meets the given brief and demonstrate that it does. In civil and electrical papers the design is incomplete until it is expressed in buildable numbers — diameter, spacing, section, component value — and checked back against every limit stated.

Structure that answers it

Requirements and permissible values listed → code clause or design basis adopted → proportioning calculations → the specification in final dimensions → check against each requirement → sketch

Where marks are lost

Stopping at a required area or a required value without converting it into the bar size, spacing or component actually provided. The provided-against-required comparison and the serviceability or stability check are separately marked and routinely left out.

All UPSC directive words, compared →

Practice this exact question

Write your answer and it is marked point by point against the model answer above — what you covered, what you missed, what you got wrong.

Evaluate my answer →

More from Civil Engineering 2023 Paper I

Write this answer and get it marked in about 20 seconds

Free account: 5 AI evaluations a month, marked against the rubric above.

Start free

Already have an account? Log in