Paper II — Q7
(a) (i) What is the difference between a sample and a specimen ? (5 marks) (ii) Describe the classification of mineral reserves…
What is the difference between a sample and a specimen ? 5 marks
Describe the classification of mineral reserves. 5 marks
What are the different marine mineral resources ? 5 marks
What is the principle and nature of construction of Wilfley Table ? Which mineral product is separated in tabling ? 15 marks
What do you know about 'Neyveli Lignite Mine' ? Enumerate the methodology of mining and machinery under use in this mine, with neat sketches. 20 marks
हिंदी में प्रश्न पढ़ें
नमूना (सैंपल) व प्रतिदर्श (स्पेसिमेन) में क्या अंतर है ? (5 अंक)
खनिज भंडार के वर्गीकरण का वर्णन कीजिए। (5 अंक)
विभिन्न समुद्री खनिज सम्पदाएँ क्या हैं ? (5 अंक)
विल्फले टेबल के निर्माण का सिद्धान्त व प्रकृति क्या है ? टेबलिंग विधि में किस खनिज उत्पाद को अलग किया जाता है ? (15 अंक)
'नेयवेली लिग्नाइट खान' के बारे में आप क्या जानते हैं ? इस खदान में खनन विधि एवं उपयोग होने वाली मशीनों का साफ चित्रों सहित वर्णन कीजिए। (20 अंक)
Model answer
Drafted with AI by UPSC Answer Check against this question's marking rubric, to the expected length. UPSC does not publish answers for Mains — this is one way to score well, not an official key. How we build rubrics and answers.
(a)(i) Sample and specimen. A sample is a representative portion of a larger body of ore, rock, coal or soil, taken by a defined method (chip, channel, core, bulk) so that its assay or test result can be applied to that body; its value lies in statistical representativeness, and it is usually crushed and consumed in analysis. A specimen is a single piece chosen because it shows a feature well (a crystal, fossil, texture or ore type) and is kept for identification, display, teaching or detailed study; it need not represent the deposit and is usually preserved intact.
(a)(ii) Classification of mineral reserves. Older Indian practice used Proved, Probable and Possible categories. Proved reserves had tonnage and grade established by closely spaced openings and drilling; Probable reserves relied on wider spacing and partly on geological projection; Possible reserves were inferred from geological evidence with little sampling.
India now uses the United Nations Framework Classification (UNFC), adopted in 2000 and made mandatory by the Minerals (Evidence of Mineral Contents) Rules, 2015. Each deposit gets a three-digit code on three axes: E (economic viability: 1 economic, 2 potentially economic, 3 intrinsically economic), F (feasibility: 1 feasibility study, 2 pre-feasibility, 3 geological study) and G (geological assurance: G1 detailed exploration, G2 general exploration, G3 prospecting, G4 reconnaissance). Reserves are the mineable part: 111 (proved) and 121/122 (probable). Remaining resources include feasibility and pre-feasibility resources (211, 221, 222) and measured, indicated, inferred and reconnaissance resources (331, 332, 333, 334). International codes such as JORC and CRIRSCO follow the same separation of resources from reserves.
(a)(iii) Marine mineral resources. They occur in several settings:
- Beach and shelf placers: ilmenite, rutile, zircon, monazite, sillimanite and garnet (Chavara and Manavalakurichi, Odisha coast), plus construction sand and lime mud on the shelf.
- Polymetallic (manganese) nodules on abyssal plains, rich in Mn, Ni, Cu and Co. India was the first pioneer investor (1987) and holds a 75,000 km² contract area in the Central Indian Ocean Basin.
- Seafloor massive sulphides at mid-ocean ridge vents (Cu, Zn, Au, Ag). India holds an ISA exploration contract (2016) on the Indian Ocean ridges.
- Cobalt-rich ferromanganese crusts on seamounts. India applied to the ISA in 2024 to explore crusts on the Afanasy-Nikitin Seamount.
- Phosphorites on continental margins, gas hydrates (Krishna–Godavari basin), offshore oil and gas, and salts and magnesium from seawater.
India's Deep Ocean Mission (2021) supports this work, and the first auction of offshore mineral blocks under the Offshore Areas Mineral (Development and Regulation) Act, 2002 was launched in November 2024.
(b) Wilfley table: principle, construction and products. The Wilfley table is a gravity concentrator. Its principle combines three effects: differential settling of heavy and light grains in a thin film of flowing water, stratification in the riffles by the shaking motion, and asymmetric (differential) reciprocation. The head motion is a slow forward stroke and a sharp return, so particles lying on the deck are moved step by step along the length. Heavy grains sink between the riffles and are carried lengthwise to the concentrate end. Light grains ride higher, are swept across the riffles by the cross-flow of wash water and leave over the lower side.
Construction:
- A rectangular or rhomboidal deck of wood or aluminium, covered with linoleum or rubber, with longitudinal riffles that taper in height towards the concentrate end.
- A small transverse (sideways) tilt of a few degrees, adjustable, towards the tailings side; the deck is nearly level along its length.
- A head motion producing about 240–325 strokes per minute with a stroke length of about 10–25 mm.
- Feed box and wash-water launder along the upper side, and discharge launders for concentrate, middlings and tailings, with slimes removed separately.
The feed must be closely sized, from about 3 mm down to about 75 µm (finer on slime tables), and the density contrast must be adequate. Tabling separates heavy mineral concentrates such as cassiterite, wolframite, chromite, native gold, ilmenite, rutile, zircon and monazite from lighter quartz and silicate gangue; it is also used to clean coal.
(c) Neyveli Lignite Mine. Neyveli, in Cuddalore district of Tamil Nadu, is India's largest lignite field and is worked by NLC India Ltd (Mine I from 1962, followed by Mines IA, II and III). The lignite belongs to the Neyveli Formation of Mio-Pliocene age (Cuddalore Sandstone), in the Cauvery basin.
- Geology: a nearly horizontal lignite seam, typically about 10–23 m thick, lies below about 70–120 m of sands, clays and sandstones.
- Groundwater problem: a confined, artesian sand aquifer lies beneath the seam. Its pressure must be reduced by continuous pumping from a ring of deep wells, otherwise the floor of the pit would heave and flood.
- Method: opencast mining with a continuous bucket-wheel excavator (BWE)–conveyor–spreader system, worked in benches. Overburden is cut in several benches by BWEs, carried on shiftable belt conveyors across or around the pit and dumped by spreaders in the mined-out area behind the advancing face (internal dumping). The lignite bench is mined separately by BWEs and conveyed to a stockyard, from where stacker-reclaimers feed the adjoining mine-mouth power stations.
- Other machinery: mobile transfer conveyors, tripper cars, dozers for conveyor shifting and bench preparation, hydraulic excavators and dumpers for difficult zones, pumps for groundwater control, and water sprinklers for dust.
- Advantages: continuous high-volume production, low cost per tonne and a short haul to the power plants. Mined-out areas are backfilled and reclaimed.
How this answer will be evaluated
What earns full marks: Precise definitions, clear diagrams, specific Indian examples, and correct technical terminology.
Evaluation rubric
Each sub-part is marked on its own, against the marks and word limit printed on the paper.
- (a)(i) Distinguish between a sample and a specimen. 5 marks
compare— paired headings or point-wise contrast → key differences → significance → conclusion
Must cover
- Sample: representative portion for assay/testing by a defined method
- Specimen: single piece chosen for a feature, for identification/display/study
- Representativeness vs illustrative purpose
- Examples (channel sample vs hand specimen)
Loses marks
- Treating them as synonyms
- No example
Earns more
- Consumption vs preservation
- Use in grade estimation
Extra mark
- Short tabular-style contrast in prose
- (a)(ii) Describe the classification of mineral reserves. 5 marks
describe— define → structure or process in order → labelled diagram → significance
Must cover
- Older scheme: proved, probable, possible
- UNFC three axes (E, F, G) with levels and codes
- Reserves (111, 121, 122) vs remaining resources (211–334)
- Indian adoption through the MEMC Rules, 2015; JORC/CRIRSCO parallel
Loses marks
- Mixing resources and reserves
- Wrong codes
Earns more
- G1–G4 exploration stages
- Link to auction regime
Extra mark
- Cube diagram of UNFC
- (a)(iii) State the different marine mineral resources. 5 marks
enumerate— list the items in order → one line each → no commentary
Must cover
- Beach/shelf placers and construction materials
- Polymetallic nodules, seafloor massive sulphides, cobalt crusts
- Phosphorites, gas hydrates, offshore hydrocarbons, seawater salts
- Indian context: CIOB pioneer area, ISA contracts, Deep Ocean Mission, offshore block auction
Loses marks
- Only oil and gas
- Claiming India already mines nodules commercially
Earns more
- Environmental concerns of deep-sea mining
- Location examples
Extra mark
- Sketch of marine settings
- (b) Explain the principle and construction of the Wilfley table and the products separated. 15 marks
explain— definition/context → points in order → small example → short close
Must cover
- Principle: differential settling in flowing film, stratification, asymmetric reciprocating motion
- Construction: riffled deck, transverse tilt, head motion (stroke and frequency), feed and wash-water launders
- Products: concentrate, middlings, tailings, slimes; feed size limits
- Minerals concentrated: cassiterite, wolframite, chromite, gold, ilmenite, zircon, monazite; coal cleaning
Loses marks
- Confusing with jigs or spirals
- Wrong tilt/motion description
Earns more
- Concentration criterion
- Operating variables
Extra mark
- Labelled plan-view sketch
- (c) Describe the Neyveli Lignite Mine, its mining method and machinery with sketches. 20 marks
describe— define → structure or process in order → labelled diagram → significance
Must cover
- Location, operator (NLC India), geology (Mio-Pliocene seam, overburden thickness)
- Artesian aquifer below the seam and depressurisation pumping
- Opencast BWE–conveyor–spreader continuous method, internal dumping, stacker-reclaimers, mine-mouth power
- Machinery list with roles; neat sketches
Loses marks
- Describing it as underground
- Ignoring groundwater problem
Earns more
- Mine I, IA, II, III history
- Reclamation and environmental management
Extra mark
- Pit cross-section sketch
What "Enumerate" is asking you to do
Produce the complete set of items asked for, countable and correctly named. The examiner marks against a checklist, so a missing item costs and an elaborated one gains nothing — where discussion is wanted the stem asks for it as a separate sub-part.
Structure that answers it
One line naming the basis on which the set is drawn → items numbered, each in a phrase or a single line → the discussion sub-part taken up separately, after the list is complete
Where marks are lost
Treating it as an essay. Six items named in six lines score better than three items explained at length.
Practice this exact question
Write your answer and it is marked point by point against the model answer above — what you covered, what you missed, what you got wrong.
Evaluate my answer →More from Geology 2024 Paper II
- Q4 (a) Discuss the various factors that control the composition of sandstone. (15 marks) (b)…
- Q5 Answer the following questions in about 150 words each. (a) Give an account of the geolog…
- Q6 (a) Explain the various peculiarities inherent in the mineral industry. (15 marks) (b) Wh…
- Q7 (a) (i) What is the difference between a sample and a specimen ? (5 marks) (ii) Describe…
- Q8 (a) What are the different layers in the Earth's interior ? How is the layered structure…