Geology 2025 Paper I 50 marks Discuss

Paper I — Q8

(a) Discuss the interrelationship amongst Porosity, Permeability and Hydraulic conductivity. How they are important in…

(a)

Discuss the interrelationship amongst Porosity, Permeability and Hydraulic conductivity. How they are important in groundwater movement ? A sediment sample with a cross section area of 0.02 m² is tested in a permeameter with a length of 30 cm. Water flows through the sample at a rate of 0.08 m³/sec with a head difference (h₁ – h₂) 20 cm. Calculate the Hydraulic conductivity. 20 marks

(b)

Describe important Lower Gondwana plant fossils with the help of neat diagrams and comment on their palaeobiogeographic significance. 15 marks

(c)

Discuss the lithology, fossil content and age of palaeozoic sequence of Spiti Basin of Himachal Pradesh. 15 marks

हिंदी में प्रश्न पढ़ें
(a)

संरंधता, पारगम्यता और जलीय चालकता के अन्तर सम्बन्धों पर चर्चा कीजिये । भूजल संचलन के लिये यह किस प्रकार महत्त्वपूर्ण है ? 0.02 वर्ग मीटर अनुप्रस्थीय क्षेत्र तथा 30 से.मी. लम्बाई वाले परमीयमीटर में अवसादी नमूने को जाँचा गया । नमूने से होकर 0.08 घनमीटर प्रति सेकंड की दर से तथा शीर्षान्तर 20 से.मी. (h₁ – h₂) के साथ जल प्रवाहित होता है । नमूने की जलीय चालकता की गणना कीजिये । (20 अंक)

(b)

स्पष्ट चित्रों की सहायता से निम्न गोंडवाना के मुख्य वनस्पति जीवाश्मों का वर्णन कीजिये तथा उनकी पुराजीव भौगोलिक महत्ता पर टिप्पणी लिखिए । (15 अंक)

(c)

हिमाचल प्रदेश की स्पिति घाटी में पैलियोजोइक अनुक्रम के शैललक्षण, जीवाश्म तथा आयु पर चर्चा कीजिये । (15 अंक)

Q8 of the 2025 UPSC Mains Geology Paper I, as printed
The question as printed in the 2025 Geology paper

Model answer

Drafted with AI by UPSC Answer Check against this question's marking rubric, to the expected length. UPSC does not publish answers for Mains — this is one way to score well, not an official key. How we build rubrics and answers.

(a)

Groundwater movement is controlled by the coupled behaviour of porosity, permeability and hydraulic conductivity. Porosity is the fraction of void space in a rock or sediment; it may be primary in sedimentary rocks or secondary in fractured and cavernous rocks, and effective porosity is the connected fraction that participates in flow. It controls storage, but not flow if pores are isolated. Permeability is the intrinsic capacity of connected pore spaces to transmit fluid, governed by grain size, sorting, cementation, anisotropy and pore connectivity. Hydraulic conductivity, K, is the permeability expressed for a particular fluid: K = k ρ g / μ, where k is intrinsic permeability, ρ fluid density, g gravity and μ viscosity. Thus a high-porosity clay may have low permeability, while a well-sorted sand or fractured limestone may have high K. In Darcy’s law, Q = K A (h₁ – h₂)/L, K links head loss, area and length to discharge. For the permeameter sample, A = 0.02 m², L = 30 cm = 0.30 m, Q = 0.08 m³/s and Δh = 20 cm = 0.20 m. Therefore K = Q L / (A Δh) = (0.08 × 0.30)/(0.02 × 0.20) = 0.024/0.004 = 6.0 m/s. (Note: the printed discharge is very large for such a small sample, so the computed K is unusually high; the exercise illustrates the calculation with the given data.) The units are dimensionally consistent: (m³/s × m)/(m² × m) = m/s. Porosity determines how much water an aquifer can hold, permeability determines how readily it moves, and K determines the rate and direction of groundwater flow, recharge, yield and contaminant transport. In Indian aquifers, K varies from very low in clay-rich alluvium and massive basalt to high in clean Gangetic sands, vesicular or fractured Deccan basalt zones and fractured crystalline rocks.

(b)

Lower Gondwana (Permo-Carboniferous to Permian) floras are best known from Glossopteris, Gangamopteris, Vertebraria and Noeggerathiopsis, with the sphenopsids Schizoneura and Phyllotheca and the conifer Buriadia. A neat diagram would show Glossopteris as a simple tongue-shaped leaf with a prominent midrib, pinnate lateral veins and reticulate areoles; Gangamopteris as a broad lanceolate to obovate leaf without a distinct midrib, with reticulate venation; Vertebraria as the segmented, vertebra-like root axis of the Glossopteris plant; and Noeggerathiopsis as a strap-shaped to spatulate leaf with parallel dichotomous venation.

``svg <svg xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" viewBox="0 0 640 356" width="640" height="356"> <title>Lower Gondwana plant fossils: Glossopteris, Gangamopteris, Vertebraria, Noeggerathiopsis</title> <style>text{font-family:Arial,Helvetica,sans-serif;font-size:13px;fill:#1f2937}.t{font-size:15px;font-weight:bold}.b{font-weight:bold}.s{font-size:12px;fill:#4b5563}.c{text-anchor:middle}.e{text-anchor:end}.i{font-style:italic}.lf{fill:#dcecd7;stroke:#2e7d32;stroke-width:1.8}.lf2{fill:#f5e9c8;stroke:#8a6d3b;stroke-width:1.8}.lf3{fill:#e2dcf2;stroke:#5b3a80;stroke-width:1.8}.rt{fill:#f2d7e0;stroke:#7f1d1d;stroke-width:1.8}.vn{fill:none;stroke:#4b5563;stroke-width:1}.vn2{fill:none;stroke:#6b7280;stroke-width:0.8}</style> <rect width="640" height="356" fill="#fff"/> <text x="320" y="20" class="t c">Important Lower Gondwana plant fossils (Permian Glossopteris flora)</text> <path d="M90,232 C42,172 44,118 90,48 C136,118 138,172 90,232 Z" class="lf"/> <line x1="90" y1="52" x2="90" y2="232" stroke="#2e7d32" stroke-width="2.6"/> <path d="M90,70 q-11.55,-6 -21.0,-16" class="vn"/> <path d="M80.55,65 l-4,-10" class="vn2"/> <path d="M90,70 q11.55,-6 21.0,-16" class="vn"/> <path d="M99.45,65 l4,-10" class="vn2"/> <path d="M90,88 q-16.5,-6 -30.0,-16" class="vn"/> <path d="M76.5,83 l-4,-10" class="vn2"/> <path d="M90,88 q16.5,-6 30.0,-16" class="vn"/> <path d="M103.5,83 l4,-10" class="vn2"/> <path d="M90,106 q-21.45,-6 -39.0,-16" class="vn"/> <path d="M72.45,101 l-4,-10" class="vn2"/> <path d="M90,106 q21.45,-6 39.0,-16" class="vn"/> <path d="M107.55,101 l4,-10" class="vn2"/> <path d="M90,124 q-22.0,-6 -40,-16" class="vn"/> <path d="M72.0,119 l-4,-10" class="vn2"/> <path d="M90,124 q22.0,-6 40,-16" class="vn"/> <path d="M108.0,119 l4,-10" class="vn2"/> <path d="M90,142 q-22.0,-6 -40,-16" class="vn"/> <path d="M72.0,137 l-4,-10" class="vn2"/> <path d="M90,142 q22.0,-6 40,-16" class="vn"/> <path d="M108.0,137 l4,-10" class="vn2"/> <path d="M90,160 q-22.0,-6 -40,-16" class="vn"/> <path d="M72.0,155 l-4,-10" class="vn2"/> <path d="M90,160 q22.0,-6 40,-16" class="vn"/> <path d="M108.0,155 l4,-10" class="vn2"/> <path d="M90,178 q-20.35,-6 -37.0,-16" class="vn"/> <path d="M73.35,173 l-4,-10" class="vn2"/> <path d="M90,178 q20.35,-6 37.0,-16" class="vn"/> <path d="M106.65,173 l4,-10" class="vn2"/> <path d="M90,196 q-15.4,-6 -28.0,-16" class="vn"/> <path d="M77.4,191 l-4,-10" class="vn2"/> <path d="M90,196 q15.4,-6 28.0,-16" class="vn"/> <path d="M102.6,191 l4,-10" class="vn2"/> <path d="M90,214 q-10.45,-6 -19.0,-16" class="vn"/> <path d="M81.45,209 l-4,-10" class="vn2"/> <path d="M90,214 q10.45,-6 19.0,-16" class="vn"/> <path d="M98.55,209 l4,-10" class="vn2"/> <text x="90" y="258" class="c b i">Glossopteris</text> <text x="90" y="275" class="c s">tongue-shaped leaf</text> <text x="90" y="290" class="c s">strong midrib</text> <text x="90" y="305" class="c s">net (reticulate) veins</text> <clipPath id="cg"><path d="M245,232 C183,182 187,108 245,54 C303,108 307,182 245,232 Z"/></clipPath> <path d="M245,232 C183,182 187,108 245,54 C303,108 307,182 245,232 Z" class="lf2"/> <g clip-path="url(#cg)"> <path d="M245,228 Q173,140.0 141,92" class="vn"/> <path d="M245,228 Q191,140.0 167,86" class="vn"/> <path d="M245,228 Q209,140.0 193,80" class="vn"/> <path d="M245,228 Q227,140.0 219,74" class="vn"/> <path d="M245,228 Q245,140.0 245,68" class="vn"/> <path d="M245,228 Q263,140.0 271,74" class="vn"/> <path d="M245,228 Q281,140.0 297,80" class="vn"/> <path d="M245,228 Q299,140.0 323,86" class="vn"/> <path d="M245,228 Q317,140.0 349,92" class="vn"/> <path d="M195,100 q25,-6 50,0 q25,6 50,0" class="vn2"/> <path d="M195,130 q25,-6 50,0 q25,6 50,0" class="vn2"/> <path d="M195,160 q25,-6 50,0 q25,6 50,0" class="vn2"/> <path d="M195,190 q25,-6 50,0 q25,6 50,0" class="vn2"/> </g> <text x="245" y="258" class="c b i">Gangamopteris</text> <text x="245" y="275" class="c s">broad obovate leaf</text> <text x="245" y="290" class="c s">no distinct midrib</text> <text x="245" y="305" class="c s">reticulate veins</text> <rect x="374" y="54" width="52" height="178" rx="8" class="rt"/> <line x1="400" y1="54" x2="400" y2="232" stroke="#7f1d1d" stroke-width="1.4"/> <line x1="374" y1="76" x2="426" y2="76" stroke="#7f1d1d" stroke-width="1.6"/> <line x1="374" y1="98" x2="426" y2="98" stroke="#7f1d1d" stroke-width="1.6"/> <line x1="374" y1="120" x2="426" y2="120" stroke="#7f1d1d" stroke-width="1.6"/> <line x1="374" y1="142" x2="426" y2="142" stroke="#7f1d1d" stroke-width="1.6"/> <line x1="374" y1="164" x2="426" y2="164" stroke="#7f1d1d" stroke-width="1.6"/> <line x1="374" y1="186" x2="426" y2="186" stroke="#7f1d1d" stroke-width="1.6"/> <line x1="374" y1="208" x2="426" y2="208" stroke="#7f1d1d" stroke-width="1.6"/> <line x1="387" y1="54" x2="387" y2="232" stroke="#b91c1c" stroke-width="1" stroke-dasharray="3 3"/> <line x1="413" y1="54" x2="413" y2="232" stroke="#b91c1c" stroke-width="1" stroke-dasharray="3 3"/> <text x="400" y="258" class="c b i">Vertebraria</text> <text x="400" y="275" class="c s">root of Glossopteris</text> <text x="400" y="290" class="c s">chambered, segmented</text> <text x="400" y="305" class="c s">vertebra-like axis</text> <clipPath id="cn"><path d="M530,232 L520,88 Q550,44 580,88 L570,232 Z"/></clipPath> <path d="M530,232 L520,88 Q550,44 580,88 L570,232 Z" class="lf3"/> <g clip-path="url(#cn)"> <path d="M535,230 L529,140.0" class="vn"/> <path d="M529,140.0 L526,78" class="vn"/><path d="M529,140.0 L532,78" class="vn"/> <path d="M540,230 L536,140.0" class="vn"/> <path d="M536,140.0 L533,78" class="vn"/><path d="M536,140.0 L539,78" class="vn"/> <path d="M545,230 L543,140.0" class="vn"/> <path d="M543,140.0 L540,78" class="vn"/><path d="M543,140.0 L546,78" class="vn"/> <path d="M550,230 L550,140.0" class="vn"/> <path d="M550,140.0 L547,78" class="vn"/><path d="M550,140.0 L553,78" class="vn"/> <path d="M555,230 L557,140.0" class="vn"/> <path d="M557,140.0 L554,78" class="vn"/><path d="M557,140.0 L560,78" class="vn"/> <path d="M560,230 L564,140.0" class="vn"/> <path d="M564,140.0 L561,78" class="vn"/><path d="M564,140.0 L567,78" class="vn"/> <path d="M565,230 L571,140.0" class="vn"/> <path d="M571,140.0 L568,78" class="vn"/><path d="M571,140.0 L574,78" class="vn"/> </g> <text x="550" y="258" class="c b i">Noeggerathiopsis</text> <text x="550" y="275" class="c s">strap-shaped leaf</text> <text x="550" y="290" class="c s">parallel veins that</text> <text x="550" y="305" class="c s">fork (dichotomise)</text> <text x="320" y="330" class="c s">Gangamopteris: Talchir–Karharbari; Glossopteris: Barakar–Raniganj coal measures (Damuda Group).</text> <text x="320" y="346" class="c s">Same flora in India, Australia, Africa, Antarctica, S. America: evidence for Gondwanaland.</text> </svg> `` Glossopteris is an index fossil for the Permian Glossopteris flora, while Gangamopteris, Vertebraria and Noeggerathiopsis indicate coal-swamp and upland environments. Gangamopteris dominates the early Talchir–Karharbari levels, while Glossopteris dominates the Barakar and Raniganj formations of the Damuda Group, which hold India's prime Lower Gondwana coal in the Damodar, Son–Mahanadi, Pranhita–Godavari and Satpura basins. Their identical occurrence in India, Australia, Africa, Antarctica and South America provides the classic palaeobiogeographic evidence for Gondwanaland reconstruction, indicating a continuous high-latitude, cold, glaciated margin with extensive coal swamps during the Permian.

(c)

The Palaeozoic succession of the Spiti Basin, on the Tethyan passive margin of northern India, is among the most complete in the Himalaya (after Srikantia's classification):

  • Haimanta Group (Neoproterozoic–Cambrian): slates, phyllites, quartzites and siltstones of the Batal and Kunzam La formations; the Middle Cambrian Parahio Formation of shales and siltstones yields trilobites such as Oryctocephalus and Redlichia and abundant trace fossils. An unconformity at the Cambrian–Ordovician transition records the Kurgiakh (Pan-African) tectonic event.
  • Thango Formation (Ordovician): red to purple conglomerates and quartzites, largely unfossiliferous, of fluvial to shallow-marine origin.
  • Takche Formation (Ordovician–Silurian): limestones, dolomites and shales with brachiopods, corals, bryozoans, crinoids and cephalopods, recording a carbonate platform.
  • Muth Quartzite (Silurian–Devonian): a thick, white, mature orthoquartzite of beach to shallow-marine origin, nearly barren of fossils.
  • Lipak Formation (Early Carboniferous): limestones and shales with brachiopods (e.g., Syringothyris), corals, bryozoans and crinoids.
  • Po Formation (Carboniferous): shales and quartzites with plant fragments and the bryozoan-rich "Fenestella shale".
  • Ganmachidam Formation (Early Permian): pebbly mudstone (diamictite) linked to Gondwana glaciation and rift-shoulder uplift.
  • Kuling Group (Permian): the Gechang sandstone overlain by the black Gungri shale ("Productus shale") with productid brachiopods such as Marginifera, passing up into the Triassic Lilang Group. Age control comes from Cambrian trilobites, Ordovician–Carboniferous brachiopod–coral assemblages, Permian productids and conodonts across the Permian–Triassic boundary, which is well studied at Guling and Mud in the Spiti and Pin valleys. The succession records repeated transgression and regression on a passive margin, a Cambro-Ordovician tectonic break, and Permian rifting that preceded the opening of Neo-Tethys.

How this answer will be evaluated

Framework: Geology Paper 1: Define > Process > Field/Petrographic Evidence > Indian Example

What earns full marks: Precise definitions, correct calculations, detailed diagrams, specific Indian examples, and clear palaeobiogeographic/lithological context.

Evaluation rubric

Each sub-part is marked on its own, against the marks and word limit printed on the paper.

  1. (a) Interrelationship of P, K, and K_h plus calculation of K_h from given data. 20 marks

    discuss— intro → 3-4 dimensions → example → balanced close

    Must cover

    • Porosity defined (total vs effective; storage control); permeability (intrinsic transmission; grain size, sorting, cement, anisotropy)
    • Hydraulic conductivity K = kρg/μ; Darcian linkage of head loss, area, length to discharge
    • Numerical: K = QL/(AΔh) = (0.08×0.30)/(0.02×0.20) = 6.0 m/s with consistent units
    • Interpretive caveat on the unusually high value; role of porosity/permeability/K in storage, flow, recharge, yield, contaminant transport

    Loses marks

    • Calculation error in Darcy's Law
    • Confusing permeability with hydraulic conductivity

    Earns more

    • Mention importance in groundwater movement
    • Distinguish intrinsic permeability from hydraulic conductivity

    Extra mark

    • Reference to specific Indian aquifer (e.g., Deccan Trap)
  2. (b) Lower Gondwana plant fossils with diagrams and palaeobiogeographic significance. 15 marks

    describe— define → structure or process in order → labelled diagram → significance

    Must cover

    • Names: Glossopteris, Gangamopteris, Vertebraria, Noeggerathiopsis
    • Neat diagrams: tongue-shaped Glossopteris (midrib, reticulate veins); broad Gangamopteris (no midrib); segmented Vertebraria; strap-shaped Noeggerathiopsis (dichotomous veins)
    • Glossopteris as Permian index fossil; Gangamopteris in Talchir–Karharbari; Barakar/Raniganj (Damuda Group) coal
    • Palaeobiogeographic significance: India–Australia–Africa–Antarctica–South America → Gondwanaland; Permian high-latitude coal swamps

    Loses marks

    • Missing diagrams
    • Generic description without Indian context

    Earns more

    • Mention of other genera (e.g., Schizoneura, Phyllotheca, Buriadia)
    • Reference to specific Indian basins (e.g., Damodar, Son–Mahanadi, Pranhita–Godavari)

    Extra mark

    • Mention specific stratigraphic age (e.g., Permian-Carboniferous)
  3. (c) Lithology, fossil content, and age of Palaeozoic sequence in Spiti Basin. 15 marks

    discuss— intro → 3-4 dimensions → example → balanced close

    Must cover

    • Haimanta Group (Neoproterozoic–Cambrian): slates-quartzites; Parahio Fm Cambrian trilobites; Kurgiakh unconformity
    • Thango (Ordovician red beds), Takche (Ordovician–Silurian carbonates with brachiopods, corals), Muth Quartzite (Silurian–Devonian)
    • Lipak (Early Carboniferous limestone, Syringothyris), Po (Fenestella shale), Ganmachidam diamictite, Kuling Group (Gechang, Gungri Productus shale)
    • Age control by fossils; P/Tr boundary sections (Guling, Mud); passive-margin evolution and Permian rifting

    Loses marks

    • Generic description without Indian example
    • Missing sections or specific formations

    Earns more

    • Mention specific formations (e.g., Parahio, Lipak, Gungri)
    • Reference to specific fossils (e.g., Oryctocephalus, Syringothyris, Marginifera)

    Extra mark

    • Mention specific stratigraphic age (e.g., Cambrian, Ordovician)
What "Discuss" is asking you to do

Lay the issue out from more than one side — how it arose, what is claimed for it, what is held against it, and where it now stands. UPSC attaches discuss to broad topics with several live dimensions, so coverage of the dimensions earns more than the strength of your opinion.

Structure that answers it

Set the issue up → the case as it is made → the case against → the dimension both sides leave out → where the balance now lies

Where marks are lost

Listing facts with no thread between them, or arguing one side throughout and calling it a discussion.

All UPSC directive words, compared →

Practice this exact question

Write your answer and it is marked point by point against the model answer above — what you covered, what you missed, what you got wrong.

Evaluate my answer →

More from Geology 2025 Paper I

Write this answer and get it marked in about 20 seconds

Free account: 5 AI evaluations a month, marked against the rubric above.

Start free

Already have an account? Log in