Paper II — Q3
(a) What are migmatites? Describe the important types of migmatites and the processes of their formation. (15 marks) (b) Draw a…
What are migmatites? Describe the important types of migmatites and the processes of their formation. 15 marks
Draw a neat labelled sketch for the albite-anorthite phase diagram (1 atm, dry). Trace the course of crystallization of an initial melt Ab₂₀-An₈₀ within this system. How can you interpret zoning in plagioclase with this system? 15 marks
Briefly write on the characteristics of I, S, M and A type granites. Elucidate the petrographic and petrogenetic attributes for each type. 12 marks
Write a brief account on the Deccan Flood Basalt Volcanism in India. 8 marks
हिंदी में प्रश्न पढ़ें
मिग्मेटाइट क्या होते हैं? मिग्मेटाइट के महत्त्वपूर्ण प्रकारों तथा उनके बनने की प्रक्रियाओं का वर्णन कीजिए। (15 अंक)
स्वच्छ नामांकित आरेख की सहायता से एल्बाइट-एनॉर्थाइट का कल्पित चित्र (1 वायुमंडलीय दाब, शुष्क) दर्शाइए। एक प्रारंभिक गलित जिसमें Ab₂₀-An₈₀ है, उसके क्रिस्टलीभवन पथ का इस पद्धति में अनुरेखण कीजिए। इस पद्धति में प्लेजियोक्लेज के मंडलन की व्याख्या कैसे की जा सकती है? (15 अंक)
I, S, M और A प्रकार के ग्रेनाइट की विशेषताओं को संक्षेप में लिखिए। प्रत्येक की पेट्रोग्राफिक व पेट्रोजेनेटिक विशेषताओं पर प्रकाश डालिए। (12 अंक)
भारत के डेक्कन फ्लड बेसाल्ट ज्वालामुखी-क्रिया का संक्षिप्त विवरण लिखिए। (8 अंक)
Model answer
Drafted with AI by UPSC Answer Check against this question's marking rubric, to the expected length. UPSC does not publish answers for Mains — this is one way to score well, not an official key. How we build rubrics and answers.
(a) Migmatites
Migmatites are common in high-grade metamorphic belts and are mixed rocks produced when a metamorphic rock is partially melted and the melt remains partly segregated. The light felsic melt is leucosome; the dark mafic residue is melanosome; together they form neosome, while the unmelted parent metamorphic rock is paleosome. The important types are metatexites, coherent rocks in which leucosome forms veins, bands or layers within paleosome, and diatexites or nebulitic migmatites, in which high melt fraction gives a granitic texture and paleosome occurs as enclaves. Mehnert's older morphological types, still widely used, include agmatic (breccia-like), stromatic (layered), ophthalmic (augen), folded, dictyonitic (net-veined), schlieric and nebulitic migmatites. Formation involves partial melting of metapelites, paragneisses or amphibolites at high temperature and pressure, metamorphic differentiation by melt segregation, and metasomatism or fluid-assisted melting that changes residual composition. The leucosome is commonly granitic to tonalitic, while the melanosome may contain biotite, garnet, amphibole or mafic restite. Indian examples include the Banded Gneissic Complex (Bhilwara) of Rajasthan, the Peninsular Gneiss of the Dharwar craton, the Chotanagpur Gneissic Complex and the Southern Granulite Terrain, where migmatites record crustal anatexis and granite genesis. They thus grade from low-melt metatexites to high-melt diatexites, preserving the transition from metamorphism to igneous melt.
(b) Albite–anorthite diagram
The dry 1 atm albite–anorthite diagram is a continuous solid-solution diagram. Sketch: x-axis composition from Ab100 (An0) on the left to An100 on the right; Ab20-An80 is plotted at 80% An, close to the An end. y-axis temperature: Ab100 melts at 1118°C and An100 at 1553°C. The upper curve is the liquidus, the lower curve the solidus, and there is no eutectic or minimum: the liquidus and solidus meet only at the pure end-members.
``svg <svg xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" viewBox="0 0 640 376" width="640" height="376"> <title>Albite–anorthite phase diagram and crystallisation of An80 melt</title> <style>text{font-family:Arial,Helvetica,sans-serif;font-size:13px;fill:#1f2937}.t{font-size:15px;font-weight:bold}.b{font-weight:bold}.s{font-size:12px;fill:#4b5563}.c{text-anchor:middle}.e{text-anchor:end}.i{font-style:italic}</style> <rect width="640" height="376" fill="#fff"/> <text x="320" y="20" class="t c">Albite–anorthite diagram (dry, 1 atm): crystallisation of Ab20–An80 melt</text> <rect x="66" y="68" width="390" height="250" fill="#fff" stroke="#1f2937" stroke-width="1.4"/> <line x1="62" y1="295" x2="66" y2="295" stroke="#1f2937"/><text x="58" y="299" class="e s">1100</text> <line x1="62" y1="250" x2="66" y2="250" stroke="#1f2937"/><text x="58" y="254" class="e s">1200</text> <line x1="62" y1="204" x2="66" y2="204" stroke="#1f2937"/><text x="58" y="208" class="e s">1300</text> <line x1="62" y1="159" x2="66" y2="159" stroke="#1f2937"/><text x="58" y="163" class="e s">1400</text> <line x1="62" y1="113" x2="66" y2="113" stroke="#1f2937"/><text x="58" y="117" class="e s">1500</text> <line x1="62" y1="68" x2="66" y2="68" stroke="#1f2937"/><text x="58" y="72" class="e s">1600</text> <line x1="66" y1="318" x2="66" y2="322" stroke="#1f2937"/><text x="66" y="336" class="c s">0</text> <line x1="144" y1="318" x2="144" y2="322" stroke="#1f2937"/><text x="144" y="336" class="c s">20</text> <line x1="222" y1="318" x2="222" y2="322" stroke="#1f2937"/><text x="222" y="336" class="c s">40</text> <line x1="300" y1="318" x2="300" y2="322" stroke="#1f2937"/><text x="300" y="336" class="c s">60</text> <line x1="378" y1="318" x2="378" y2="322" stroke="#1f2937"/><text x="378" y="336" class="c s">80</text> <line x1="456" y1="318" x2="456" y2="322" stroke="#1f2937"/><text x="456" y="336" class="c s">100</text> <text x="261" y="354" class="c">composition, wt % An (Ab at 0, An at 100)</text> <text transform="translate(20,193) rotate(-90)" class="c">temperature (°C)</text> <path d="M66.0,287.1 L85.5,267.5 L105.0,248.0 L124.5,228.5 L144.0,208.9 L163.5,196.4 L183.0,183.9 L202.5,171.4 L222.0,158.9 L241.5,151.0 L261.0,143.0 L280.5,135.0 L300.0,127.1 L319.5,121.4 L339.0,115.7 L358.5,110.0 L378.0,104.4 L397.5,100.6 L417.0,96.9 L436.5,93.1 L456.0,89.4 L456.0,89.4 L436.5,103.3 L417.0,117.3 L397.5,131.3 L378.0,145.3 L358.5,155.5 L339.0,165.7 L319.5,176.0 L300.0,186.2 L280.5,196.4 L261.0,206.6 L241.5,216.9 L222.0,227.1 L202.5,235.0 L183.0,243.0 L163.5,251.0 L144.0,258.9 L124.5,266.0 L105.0,273.0 L85.5,280.0 L66.0,287.1 Z" fill="#fde8e8" stroke="none"/> <path d="M66.0,287.1 L85.5,267.5 L105.0,248.0 L124.5,228.5 L144.0,208.9 L163.5,196.4 L183.0,183.9 L202.5,171.4 L222.0,158.9 L241.5,151.0 L261.0,143.0 L280.5,135.0 L300.0,127.1 L319.5,121.4 L339.0,115.7 L358.5,110.0 L378.0,104.4 L397.5,100.6 L417.0,96.9 L436.5,93.1 L456.0,89.4" fill="none" stroke="#b03030" stroke-width="2.2"/><path d="M66.0,287.1 L85.5,280.0 L105.0,273.0 L124.5,266.0 L144.0,258.9 L163.5,251.0 L183.0,243.0 L202.5,235.0 L222.0,227.1 L241.5,216.9 L261.0,206.6 L280.5,196.4 L300.0,186.2 L319.5,176.0 L339.0,165.7 L358.5,155.5 L378.0,145.3 L397.5,131.3 L417.0,117.3 L436.5,103.3 L456.0,89.4" fill="none" stroke="#1d4e78" stroke-width="2.2"/> <text x="152" y="118" class="b">liquid (melt)</text> <text x="175" y="229" class="b" style="fill:#7f1d1d">melt + plagioclase</text> <text x="261" y="282" class="b" style="fill:#1d4e78">plagioclase solid solution</text> <text x="113" y="186" class="s" style="fill:#b03030">liquidus</text><text x="308" y="200" class="s" style="fill:#1d4e78">solidus</text> <text x="70" y="281" class="s">1118 °C</text><text x="452" y="105" class="e s">1553 °C</text> <line x1="378" y1="73" x2="378" y2="159" stroke="#5b3a80" stroke-width="1.6" stroke-dasharray="5 4"/> <text x="378" y="69" class="c s" style="fill:#5b3a80">bulk An80</text> <line x1="378" y1="104" x2="435" y2="104" stroke="#374151" stroke-width="1.2"/> <circle cx="378" cy="104" r="3.5" fill="#b03030"/><circle cx="435" cy="104" r="3.5" fill="#1d4e78"/> <text x="372" y="108" class="e s b">1</text> <line x1="300" y1="127" x2="403" y2="127" stroke="#374151" stroke-width="1.2"/> <circle cx="300" cy="127" r="3.5" fill="#b03030"/><circle cx="403" cy="127" r="3.5" fill="#1d4e78"/> <text x="294" y="131" class="e s b">2</text> <line x1="255" y1="145" x2="378" y2="145" stroke="#374151" stroke-width="1.2"/> <circle cx="255" cy="145" r="3.5" fill="#b03030"/><circle cx="378" cy="145" r="3.5" fill="#1d4e78"/> <text x="249" y="149" class="e s b">3</text> <text x="470" y="66" class="b">Tie-lines (lever rule)</text> <text x="470" y="82" class="s">1 1520 °C: first crystals</text> <text x="470" y="98" class="s"> ≈ An95, melt An80</text> <text x="470" y="114" class="s">2 1470 °C: melt ≈ An60,</text> <text x="470" y="130" class="s"> solid ≈ An87; solid</text> <text x="470" y="146" class="s"> fraction ≈ 0.75</text> <text x="470" y="162" class="s">3 1430 °C: last melt</text> <text x="470" y="178" class="s"> ≈ An49; solid = An80</text> <text x="470" y="210" class="b">Zoning</text> <text x="470" y="226" class="s">Equilibrium: crystals</text> <text x="470" y="242" class="s">re-equilibrate to An80.</text> <text x="470" y="258" class="s">Fractional: calcic core,</text> <text x="470" y="274" class="s">sodic rim (normal zoning).</text> <text x="470" y="290" class="s">Reverse zoning: input of</text> <text x="470" y="306" class="s">new calcic melt.</text> <text x="320" y="366" class="c s">Melt path follows the liquidus toward Ab; crystal path follows the solidus. No eutectic.</text> </svg> `` For an initial melt Ab20-An80, crystallization begins at the liquidus with plagioclase richer in anorthite than the melt, about An90–An95. On cooling, the crystal follows the solidus toward lower An while the residual melt follows the liquidus toward higher Ab. Under equilibrium, crystals re-equilibrate and the final plagioclase approaches the bulk Ab20-An80 composition. Under fractional crystallization, removed crystals make the residual melt move faster toward albite, producing more strongly zoned crystals. The lever rule, fraction solid = (C0-CL)/(CS-CL), is applied using a tie-line between liquidus and solidus at any temperature. Normal zoning, An-rich cores and Ab-rich rims, records continuous cooling and melt evolution; reverse zoning, Ab-rich cores and An-rich rims, implies late addition of anorthite-rich melt, assimilation, volatile effects, or crystal reaction. If diffusion is slow, zoning is preserved; if fast, it is erased.
(c) Granites and Deccan
(i) This alphabet classification (Chappell and White, 1974, for I and S; later M and A) is based on source. I-type granites are igneous-source, usually metaluminous, with hornblende, biotite, quartz and plagioclase, and little excess aluminium; they form by melting of mafic to intermediate crust or mantle-derived material, typical of Cordilleran arcs such as the Ladakh batholith; they belong to the magnetite series, carry titanite and have an aluminium saturation index below 1.1, and may contain mafic enclaves. S-type granites are sedimentary-source, peraluminous, with muscovite, garnet, cordierite or K-feldspar, and form by anatexis of metasediments, as in Himalayan leucogranites (e.g., Badrinath, Manaslu); they belong to the ilmenite series, have an aluminium saturation index above 1.1 and high initial 87Sr/86Sr, and may contain metasedimentary xenoliths and restite. M-type granites are mantle-derived, oceanic, low in K, with calcic plagioclase, hornblende and pyroxene, and form from partial melting of mantle or ultramafic crust. M-type may be associated with ophiolites. A-type granites are anorogenic, alkaline, often high in incompatible elements, with K-feldspar, Na-plagioclase, biotite, hornblende or pyroxene, and form in rift or post-collisional extensional settings (Loiselle and Wones, 1979); they carry iron-rich mafic minerals such as annite, fayalite or sodic amphiboles (riebeckite, arfvedsonite), have high Ga/Al, Zr and REE, and are exemplified in India by the Neoproterozoic Malani granites (Siwana, Jalor) of Rajasthan. (ii) The Deccan Traps are Cretaceous–Palaeogene continental flood basalts, with the main eruptive phase at about 66.3–65.5 Ma, linked to the Réunion mantle plume as India drifted over it. Covering about 500,000 km² today and reaching about 2 km in thickness in the Western Ghats, the province is among the largest on Earth. They are tholeiitic, layered in formations such as Jawhar, Igatpuri, Poladpur and Ambenali (Kalsubai, Lonavala and Wai subgroups), with simple and compound pahoehoe and aa flows, red boles, intertrappean sediments, dyke swarms (Narmada–Tapi, Konkan) and minor picrites and alkaline–carbonatite complexes (Amba Dongar, Mundwara), and their massive volcanism is linked to environmental stress and mass-extinction effects at the K–Pg boundary. CO2 and SO2 emissions are linked to climate change and ocean acidification. The basalts weather to black cotton soil (regur) and host aquifers in vesicular and fractured zones.
How this answer will be evaluated
What earns full marks: Comprehensive, accurate, and well-structured answers with specific examples and diagrams.
Evaluation rubric
Each sub-part is marked on its own, against the marks and word limit printed on the paper.
- (a) Define migmatites and detail their types and formation processes. 15 marks
describe— define → structure or process in order → labelled diagram → significance
Must cover
- Migmatite defined as partially melted mixed rock; leucosome / melanosome / neosome / paleosome distinguished
- Main types: metatexite and diatexite/nebulitic (Sawyer); Mehnert's morphological types (agmatic, stromatic, ophthalmic, dictyonitic, schlieric, nebulitic)
- Formation: partial melting (anatexis) of metapelite/paragneiss/amphibolite; metamorphic differentiation, melt segregation, metasomatism
- Indian examples (BGC Bhilwara, Peninsular Gneiss, Chotanagpur, Southern Granulite Terrain); grading from low-melt to high-melt types
Loses marks
- Confusing migmatite with simple gneiss
- Missing the definition of leucosome/melanosome
- Generic description without specific types
Earns more
- Reference to specific Indian migmatite occurrences
- Mention of specific mineral assemblages
- Discussion of the role of volatiles
- Sketch of migmatite texture
Extra mark
- Named Indian occurrence (e.g., Aravalli)
- Stratigraphic age of the host rock
- (b) Draw the Ab-An phase diagram and trace crystallization of Ab20-An80. 15 marks
trace— start point → the stages in sequence → end point → what changed
Must cover
- Labelled Ab–An phase diagram (dry, 1 atm) provided; x-axis Ab100→An100; end-member melting points 1118 °C (Ab) and 1553 °C (An)
- Liquidus and solidus curves identified; continuous solid solution (no eutectic/minimum)
- Crystallization path for Ab20-An80 melt: first plagioclase more calcic (~An90–An95); liquid moves toward Ab; equilibrium vs fractional behaviour
- Lever rule application; interpretation of zoning (normal vs reverse; preservation vs diffusion)
Loses marks
- Missing or incorrect phase diagram
- Failing to trace the specific Ab20-An80 path
- Not explaining the zoning mechanism
Earns more
- Label liquidus, solidus and tie-lines (no eutectic in this system)
- Show temperature drop along the path
- Mention specific mineral compositions at stages
- Clear, neat sketch
Extra mark
- Mention of specific Indian plagioclase occurrences
- Reference to specific geological context
- (c)(i) Describe characteristics of I, S, M, and A type granites. 12 marks
write short notes— define → 3-4 key features → one example → one-line significance
Must cover
- I-type: igneous source, metaluminous, hornblende-bearing (Cordilleran arcs); mafic enclaves possible
- S-type: sedimentary source, peraluminous, muscovite/garnet/cordierite (Himalayan leucogranites)
- M-type: mantle-derived, oceanic, low-K, ophiolite-associated
- A-type: anorogenic, alkaline, incompatible-element-rich (high Ga/Al), Fe-rich mafics; rift/post-collision settings; Malani granites
Loses marks
- Confusing the definitions of the types
- Missing petrographic or petrogenetic attributes
- Generic description without specific characteristics
Earns more
- Mention specific petrographic attributes for each
- Mention specific petrogenetic attributes for each
- Reference to specific Indian examples
- Clear distinction between types
Extra mark
- Named Indian occurrence for a specific type
- Stratigraphic age of a specific granite
- (c)(ii) Provide a brief account of Deccan Flood Basalt Volcanism. 8 marks
account for— state the phenomenon → the causes in order of weight → conclusion
Must cover
- Deccan Traps identified as continental flood basalts; ~66 Ma; Réunion mantle plume link
- Tholeiitic; formations (Jawhar, Igatpuri, Poladpur, Ambenali); pahoehoe/aa flows, red boles, intertrappeans, dyke swarms, alkaline complexes
- K–Pg boundary environmental stress and mass-extinction linkage; CO2/SO2 and climate/acidification effects
Loses marks
- Confusing Deccan with other flood basalts
- Missing the timing or location
- Generic description without specific details
Earns more
- Mention specific geological features
- Reference to specific mineral compositions
- Discussion of the tectonic setting
- Mention of the impact on the environment
Extra mark
- Named specific formation or craton
- Stratigraphic age of the basalt
What "Describe" is asking you to do
Give a full, ordered account of the thing named — its parts, stages or mechanism — in the sequence in which it actually exists or occurs. Most describe questions come from the science optionals, where the marks sit in correct technical detail and, where the stem says so, a labelled diagram.
Structure that answers it
One-line identification of the subject → the parts or stages in their real order, each with its defining detail → labelled diagram where the subject is structural → closing line on function or significance
Where marks are lost
Loose general prose where the examiner is ticking named parts, correct terminology and their sequence; and in the General Studies papers, turning to evaluation before the description is finished.
Practice this exact question
Write your answer and it is marked point by point against the model answer above — what you covered, what you missed, what you got wrong.
Evaluate my answer →More from Geology 2025 Paper II
- Q1 Answer the following questions in about 150 words each: (a) Describe the symmetry element…
- Q2 (a) Give a detailed account related to the classification of crystals into different crys…
- Q3 (a) What are migmatites? Describe the important types of migmatites and the processes of…
- Q4 (a) Discuss the genesis of any four sedimentary structures which are helpful in palaeocur…
- Q5 Answer the following questions in about 150 words each: (a) What do you understand by met…
- Q6 (a) Give an account of geology, mode of occurrence, genesis and distribution of Pb-Zn dep…