History 2021 Paper II 50 marks Comment

Paper II — Q2

(a) India had been the world leader in the field of hand spun and hand woven yarn and cloth for many centuries. Many nationalist…

(a)

India had been the world leader in the field of hand spun and hand woven yarn and cloth for many centuries. Many nationalist and Marxist critiques considered that the British dominion deliberately shattered the traditional and world famous handicrafts of India. Comment. 20 marks

(b)

What were the various ways in which nationalism manifested itself in India during colonial rule? 20 marks

(c)

The East India Company had thought that they had found an ideal puppet in Mir Kasim. Mir Kasim, however, belied the expectation of the company. Examine critically. 10 marks

हिंदी में प्रश्न पढ़ें
(a)

अनेक शताब्दियों से हाथ से कते एवं हाथ से बुने हुए सूत तथा कपड़े के क्षेत्र में भारत विश्व में अग्रणी था । अनेक राष्ट्रवादी तथा मार्क्सवादी आलोचकों का मानना है कि अंग्रेजी आधिपत्य ने जानबूझ कर भारत के पारंपरिक तथा विश्व-प्रसिद्ध हस्तशिल्प को बर्बाद किया । टिप्पणी कीजिए । (20 अंक)

(b)

औपनिवेशिक शासन के दौरान भारत में राष्ट्रवाद ने किन विभिन्न तरीकों से अपने आप को प्रकट किया ? (20 अंक)

(c)

ईस्ट इंडिया कंपनी का मानना था कि मीर कासिम के रूप में उन्हें एक आदर्श कठपुतली मिल गई है । हालांकि मीर कासिम कंपनी की अपेक्षाओं पर खरा नहीं उतरा । समालोचनात्मक विवेचना कीजिए । (10 अंक)

Q2 of the 2021 UPSC Mains History Paper II, as printed
The question as printed in the 2021 History paper

Model answer

Drafted with AI by UPSC Answer Check against this question's marking rubric, to the expected length. UPSC does not publish answers for Mains — this is one way to score well, not an official key. How we build rubrics and answers.

(a) Colonial rule and the decline of Indian handicrafts

India's cotton textiles, such as Dacca muslin, Bengal and Coromandel cloth and Surat silks, supplied world markets till the eighteenth century. Nationalist writers such as Dadabhai Naoroji and R. C. Dutt, and Marxists such as R. P. Dutt, argued that British policy deliberately destroyed them to serve British industry, and the evidence supports a substantial part of this view.

After 1757 the Company used political power to force weavers to supply at low prices and to restrict their dealings, and took over the cloth trade in Bengal. In Britain, Indian cottons were prohibited or taxed at very high duties, while after 1813 British machine-made goods entered India almost duty-free. Indian cloth lost its overseas markets, and then its home market, as cheap Lancashire yarn and cloth arrived and railways carried them inland. The loss of princely courts and their patronage hit luxury crafts. Dacca's population fell sharply, and census data show a shift of artisans to agriculture, the ruralisation of India.

Revisionists such as Morris D. Morris and Tirthankar Roy argue that decline was uneven: handlooms survived using imported mill yarn, and Indian mills grew; changes in demand and technology, not only policy, were involved. The fair judgement is that colonial policy, including unequal tariffs, was a major cause but not the sole one.

(b) Manifestations of nationalism under colonial rule

Nationalism appeared in many forms.

Cultural and social: socio-religious reform movements such as the Brahmo Samaj and Arya Samaj, revival of history and language, the Bengal School of art, and literature such as Bankim's Anandamath.

Economic: the drain theory and swadeshi, a critique of colonial economic policy by Naoroji and Dutt, and boycott and the use of indigenous goods.

Political: associations such as the Indian Association and the Indian National Congress, a growing press, and demands for representation, using constitutional methods in the Moderate phase.

Radical and revolutionary: the Extremists, Home Rule, and groups using violence.

Mass: Gandhian movements: Non-Cooperation, Civil Disobedience and Quit India, drawing in peasants, workers, women and tribals; peasant and tribal movements, states' peoples' movements and trade unions.

Other strands included linguistic regional identities and the assertions of Dalits and others. These showed that Indian nationalism united diverse groups against a common colonial rule while retaining internal differences.

(c) Mir Qasim and the Company

The Company made Mir Qasim nawab of Bengal in 1760, replacing Mir Jafar, in return for the cession of Burdwan, Midnapore and Chittagong and large payments, expecting a pliant ruler. He did not oblige. He reorganised finances, cleared arrears, moved his capital to Monghyr, away from the Company's reach, and modernised his army under the Armenian Gurgin Khan. Above all he resisted the misuse of the dastak, the duty-free pass, by Company servants for private trade, and in 1763 abolished all internal duties, putting Indian merchants on equal footing, which meant that the Company's servants lost their advantage.

Conflict followed at Patna in 1763 and war, in which the Company won at Katwa, Giria and Udhua Nala. Mir Qasim fled and allied with Shuja-ud-Daula of Awadh and Shah Alam II, and was defeated at Buxar in 1764.

How this answer will be evaluated

Framework: Context > Thesis > Evidence > Historiography

What earns full marks: Comprehensive, analytical, and well-supported with specific historical evidence and historiographical references.

Evaluation rubric

Each sub-part is marked on its own, against the marks and word limit printed on the paper.

  1. (a) Comment on the view that British dominion deliberately shattered the traditional and world-famous handicrafts of India. 20 marks

    comment— context → arguments both sides → judgment → close

    Must cover

    • Pre-colonial strength of Indian textiles and nationalist and Marxist argument
    • Mechanisms: Company coercion, discriminatory tariffs, Lancashire competition, loss of patronage, railways
    • Revisionist qualification and a balanced verdict

    Loses marks

    • One-sided acceptance with no counterview
    • Dates of tariff policy wrong

    Earns more

    • Named craft centres such as Dacca muslin
    • Census-based evidence of ruralisation

    Extra mark

    • Named historians: Naoroji, R. C. Dutt, Morris D. Morris, Tirthankar Roy
  2. (b) Describe the various ways in which nationalism manifested itself in India during colonial rule. 20 marks

    discuss— intro → 3-4 dimensions → example → balanced close

    Must cover

    • Cultural, social and economic forms of nationalism
    • Political associations, Congress and the Moderate and Extremist phases
    • Mass and revolutionary movements and their social base

    Loses marks

    • Only the Congress timeline narrated
    • No variety of manifestations

    Earns more

    • Named movements, organisations or texts for each form
    • Regional, linguistic and marginalised group assertions

    Extra mark

    • Tension between unity and internal diversity
  3. (c) Examine critically whether Mir Qasim belied the Company's expectation of him as a puppet. 10 marks

    critique— the claim → its strengths → its weaknesses → your judgment

    Must cover

    • Installation in 1760 with concessions and Company expectations
    • Mir Qasim's reforms: finance, army, Monghyr and abolition of internal duties
    • Conflict, war and the Battle of Buxar (1764)

    Loses marks

    • Plassey narrated instead
    • Dates or battles confused

    Earns more

    • Dastak abuse by Company servants
    • Alliance with Shuja-ud-Daula and Shah Alam II

    Extra mark

    • Comparison with Mir Jafar
What "Comment" is asking you to do

Take a position on the statement and support it. Comment usually attaches to a quoted line in the short slots, so the reasoning must be compressed — an opening view, a few load-bearing reasons, and the limit of the claim.

Structure that answers it

Unpack what the statement asserts → your stance → two or three supporting reasons → the qualification that limits it

Where marks are lost

Neutral summary; a comment without a stance has not answered. Equally costly is accepting the quoted line wholesale and never testing where it fails.

All UPSC directive words, compared →

Practice this exact question

Write your answer and it is marked point by point against the model answer above — what you covered, what you missed, what you got wrong.

Evaluate my answer →

More from History 2021 Paper II

Write this answer and get it marked in about 20 seconds

Free account: 5 AI evaluations a month, marked against the rubric above.

Start free

Already have an account? Log in