History 2023 Paper II 50 marks 150 words Compulsory Critically examine

Q1

Critically examine the following statements in about 150 words each: (a) "Colonialism had a twisted logic of its own for commercialization. It emerges on analysis to have been often an artificial and forced process." (10 marks) (b) After 1857, "the peasants emerged as the main force in agrarian movements." (10 marks) (c) "Awakened political consciousness of Indian masses, bound with dishonourable and cowardly insults of the British led to the movement of Non-Cooperation." (10 marks) (d) When Gandhiji launched the Civil Disobedience Movement he was "desperately in search of an effective formula." (10 marks) (e) "If abdication of British responsibility at the time of transfer of power was callous, the speed with which it was done made it worse." (10 marks)

हिंदी में प्रश्न पढ़ें

निम्नलिखित कथनों में से प्रत्येक का लगभग 150 शब्दों में समालोचनात्मक परीक्षण कीजिए : (a) "उपनिवेशवाद का व्यापारीकरण पर अपना ही एक विकृत तर्क था, क्योंकि विश्लेषण करने पर यह ज्ञात होता है कि व्यापारीकरण प्रायः एक कृत्रिम और जबरन प्रक्रिया रही है।" (10 अंक) (b) 1857 के उपरांत, "कृषक आंदोलनों में किसान एक प्रमुख शक्ति के रूप में उभरते हैं।" (10 अंक) (c) "भारतीय जनमानस की जागृत राजनीतिक चेतना तथा अंग्रेजों के असम्मानजनक और कायरतापूर्ण अपमान ने असहयोग आंदोलन को जन्म दिया।" (10 अंक) (d) जब गांधीजी ने सविनय अवज्ञा आंदोलन की शुरुआत की तब उन्हें "बेसब्री से एक प्रभावी सूत्र की तलाश थी।" (10 अंक) (e) "सत्ता हस्तांतरण के समय अंग्रेजों द्वारा अपनी जिम्मेदारी का त्याग करना यदि संवेदनहीन था, तो जिस गति से उसे संपादित किया गया उससे वह और भी बुरा बन गया।" (10 अंक)

Evaluate your answer to this question → See all 2023 History questions

Directive word: Critically examine

This question asks you to critically examine. The directive word signals the depth of analysis expected, the structure of your answer, and the weight of evidence you must bring.

See our UPSC directive words guide for a full breakdown of how to respond to each command word.

How this answer will be evaluated

Approach

Critically examine demands balanced evaluation with evidence for and against each statement. Allocate ~30 words per sub-part (150 total), spending roughly equal time on each since all carry 10 marks. Structure: brief contextualization, dual-sided analysis with specific examples, and a nuanced verdict on each statement's validity.

Key points expected

  • (a) Colonial commercialization: deindustrialization, forced cash crop cultivation (indigo, opium), destruction of artisanal economy, artificial market creation vs. limited infrastructure development
  • (b) Post-1857 agrarian movements: Pabna (1873), Deccan riots (1875), Champaran (1917), Kisan Sabha formation; shift from elite to peasant-led struggles with specific grievances
  • (c) Non-Cooperation causes: Rowlatt Act, Jallianwala Bagh (1919), Khilafat wrongs, Montagu-Chelmsford dissatisfaction; mass politicization through Gandhi's leadership
  • (d) Civil Disobedience context: Simon Commission boycott, Nehru Report failure, Lahore Congress (1929), Dandi March as strategic breakthrough; Gandhi's tactical evolution from Non-Cooperation
  • (e) Transfer of power: Mountbatten Plan (June 1947), rushed boundary award (Radcliffe), partition violence, princely states crisis, administrative collapse; critiques by Penderel Moon, Yasmin Khan

Evaluation rubric

DimensionWeightMax marksExcellentAveragePoor
Chronology accuracy20%10Precise dating for all sub-parts: (a) 18th-19th century commercialization phases; (b) 1873 Pabna, 1875 Deccan riots post-1857; (c) 1919-1920 Non-Cooperation launch; (d) 1929-1930 Civil Disobedience timeline; (e) June-August 1947 transfer specifics with correct sequenceBroadly correct periods mentioned but some dates imprecise or conflated (e.g., mixing 1920 and 1930 movements)Serious chronological errors like placing Non-Cooperation before 1919, or confusing Civil Disobedience with Quit India timing
Source & evidence20%10Specific evidence per part: (a) Dadabhai Naoroji's drain theory or RC Dutt data; (b) official reports on Pabna/Deccan; (c) Gandhi's Young India writings; (d) Nehru's autobiography or Congress resolutions; (e) Transfer of Power documents or Viceroy's reportsGeneral references to movements without specific documentary evidence or historian citationsVague assertions without any primary source grounding or factual backing for claims
Multi-perspective analysis20%10Critical examination with dual perspectives: (a) forced vs. market integration arguments; (b) peasant agency vs. elite manipulation; (c) mass awakening vs. elite mobilization; (d) strategic necessity vs. ideological commitment; (e) British pragmatism vs. culpable negligenceSome acknowledgment of complexity but tendency toward one-sided validation or rejection of statementsWholly affirmative or negative treatment without critical engagement; missing 'critically examine' requirement
Historiographic framing20%10Explicit historiographic awareness: (a) Bipan Chandra's colonialism debate; (b) Ranajit Guha's Subaltern Studies on peasant consciousness; (c) Judith Brown on Gandhi's mass politics; (d) David Hardiman on Gandhi's peasant strategy; (e) Anita Inder Singh or Ayesha Jalal on partition historiographyImplicit historiographic positioning without explicit scholar naming or school identificationNo historiographic context; presents events as self-evident facts without scholarly framing
Conclusion & synthesis20%10Balanced verdicts on each statement with interconnections drawn across colonial period—showing how (a)-(e) represent evolving colonial-capitalist logic, peasant politicization, nationalist strategy, and decolonization crisis as interconnected historical processSeparate conclusions per sub-part without cross-linking; adequate but fragmented closureMissing conclusions for sub-parts or repetitive summary without analytical closure; no synthesis across the five statements

Practice this exact question

Write your answer, then get a detailed evaluation from our AI trained on UPSC's answer-writing standards. Free first evaluation — no signup needed to start.

Evaluate my answer →

More from History 2023 Paper II