History 2023 Paper II 50 marks 150 words Compulsory Critically examine

Paper II — Q5

(a) "The American War of Independence finally ended in 1783 when Britain acknowledged the independence of the United States of…

Critically examine the following statements in about 150 words each:

(a)

"The American War of Independence finally ended in 1783 when Britain acknowledged the independence of the United States of America." 10 marks

(b)

"The Chartist Movement not only fulfilled some of the demands of the middle class, but its ramifications were felt among the working class and the colonies as well." 10 marks

(c)

"The Revolutions of 1848 were shaped by the ideas of democracy and nationalism." 10 marks

(d)

"The British imperialism in South Africa from 1867 to 1902 was influenced to a large extent by the capitalist mining of diamonds." 10 marks

(e)

"The supremacy of USA after the end of Cold War had its challenges as well." 10 marks

हिंदी में प्रश्न पढ़ें

निम्नलिखित कथनों में से प्रत्येक का लगभग 150 शब्दों में समालोचनात्मक परीक्षण कीजिए :

(a)

"अमेरिकी स्वतंत्रता का युद्ध अंततोगत्वा 1783 में तब समाप्त हुआ जब ब्रिटेन ने संयुक्त राज्य अमेरिका की स्वतंत्रता को स्वीकृति प्रदान की।" (10 अंक)

(b)

"चार्टिस्ट आंदोलन ने न केवल मध्य वर्ग की कुछ मांगों को पूरा किया, अपितु इसके प्रभावों को श्रमिक वर्ग और उपनिवेशों में भी महसूस किया गया।" (10 अंक)

(c)

"1848 के आंदोलनों को प्रजातंत्र और राष्ट्रवाद के विचारों से गढ़ा गया था।" (10 अंक)

(d)

"1867 से 1902 के मध्य दक्षिण अफ्रीका में ब्रिटिश साम्राज्यवाद काफी हद तक पूंजीवादी व्यवस्था द्वारा हीरों के खनन से प्रभावित था।" (10 अंक)

(e)

"शीत युद्ध की समाप्ति के उपरांत यू.एस.ए. की प्रभुसत्ता की अपनी चुनौतियाँ भी थीं।" (10 अंक)

Q5 of the 2023 UPSC Mains History Paper II, as printed
The question as printed in the 2023 History paper

Model answer

Drafted with AI by UPSC Answer Check against this question's marking rubric, to the 150-word length. UPSC does not publish answers for Mains — this is one way to score well, not an official key. How we build rubrics and answers.

(a) The end of the American War of Independence in 1783

The statement is formally right but simplifies the story. The Treaty of Paris (3 September 1783) recognised the thirteen colonies as free and independent, fixed the western boundary at the Mississippi, and dealt with fisheries, loyalists and debts. Britain signed separate peace treaties with France and Spain at Versailles on the same day.

But the fighting had effectively ended when Cornwallis surrendered at Yorktown in October 1781 and the North ministry fell in 1782. Nor did Britain grant independence: the colonies had declared it in 1776, and the treaty acknowledged what American arms and French support had won.

Nor was the settlement final. Britain held north-western forts until the Jay Treaty (1794), the Constitution was adopted only in 1787, and the War of 1812 is sometimes called a second war of independence. The judgement is that 1783 was the legal end, not the complete end of the contest.

(b) The Chartist Movement and its ramifications

The statement is partly misleading. Chartism began in 1838 with the People's Charter of six points: universal male suffrage, secret ballot, annual Parliaments, equal electoral districts, payment of MPs and abolition of the property qualification. The petitions of 1839, 1842 and 1848 were rejected, and the movement faded after Kennington Common (1848).

It was mainly a working-class movement, since the middle class had won a share of power in the Reform Act of 1832 and then backed the Anti-Corn Law League. Five of the six points were later adopted, including the Ballot Act (1872) and the franchise Acts from 1867 to 1918, but by other parties and not as a direct result.

Its real ramifications were among workers, for whom it built organisation and a political voice that flowed into trade unionism, and in the colonies. Transported Chartists like John Frost went to Australia, the Ballarat Reform League of 1854 drew on Chartist demands, and the secret ballot reached the Australian colonies in the 1850s. Its influence was real but mainly on labour and colonial democracy.

(c) The Revolutions of 1848: democracy and nationalism

The statement is broadly right. The revolutions began in France in February 1848, which overthrew Louis Philippe and proclaimed the Second Republic with universal male suffrage, and spread to Vienna, Hungary, the Italian states and the German Confederation. The Frankfurt Parliament tried to frame a national constitution, Kossuth's Hungarians demanded autonomy in the April Laws, and Italians looked to Piedmont's Charles Albert.

Yet democracy and nationalism were not the only forces. The hunger of 1846–47 and industrial unemployment caused distress, and the French June Days showed a struggle between workers and the propertied. Nationalisms also clashed: Hungarians against Croats and Romanians, Germans against Czechs at Prague. This helped conservatives to regain control.

The judgement is that 1848 was shaped by both ideas, but social crisis and rival nationalisms decided its course, though constitutions and the abolition of serfdom in the Habsburg lands endured.

(d) British imperialism in South Africa and diamond mining

The statement contains an important truth but overstates it. Diamonds found near Hopetown (1867) and at Kimberley (1871) drew British attention: Britain annexed Griqualand West in 1871, and Cecil Rhodes built De Beers, consolidated in 1888, which funded his political expansion northward through the British South Africa Company (1889).

But diamonds do not explain the whole period. Lord Carnarvon's confederation plan and the annexation of the Transvaal in 1877 preceded the gold discoveries, and they reflected a strategic aim. The Cape guarded the sea route to India, which gained importance after the Suez Canal opened in 1869, and German rivalry grew from the 1880s. The Witwatersrand gold discovery (1886) did more than diamonds to provoke the Jameson Raid (1895–96) and the Anglo-Boer War (1899–1902), together with Milner's political aims.

Hobson and Lenin emphasised capital, while Robinson and Gallagher emphasised strategy. The judgement is that diamonds mattered for the 1870s and for Rhodes, but gold and strategic concerns were more important overall.

(e) US supremacy after the Cold War and its challenges

The statement is correct. After the Soviet collapse in 1991 the United States enjoyed what Charles Krauthammer called a unipolar moment: it led the Gulf War coalition (1991), expanded NATO and led the Kosovo intervention (1999). Yet its supremacy soon faced challenges.

The attacks of 11 September 2001 revealed its vulnerability to non-state terrorism, and the wars in Afghanistan and Iraq (2003) strained its finances and legitimacy. The 2008 financial crisis damaged confidence in its economic model. China's rapid growth and Belt and Road Initiative (2013) offered an alternative centre, Russia reasserted itself in Georgia (2008) and Crimea (2014), and India, Brazil and others sought more autonomy, expressed in groupings such as BRICS. Allies in Europe did not always follow Washington.

The judgement is that the United States remained the strongest military and financial power, but the world moved from a unipolar moment toward a more multipolar order.

How this answer will be evaluated

Framework: Context > Thesis > Evidence > Historiography

What earns full marks: Thesis-driven, cites specific sources/historians, nuanced critique of the statement.

Evaluation rubric

Each sub-part is marked on its own, against the marks and word limit printed on the paper.

  1. (a) Critically examine the claim that the American War of Independence finally ended in 1783. 10 marks · 150 words

    critique— the claim → its strengths → its weaknesses → your judgment

    Must cover

    • Treaty of Paris 1783: recognition and terms
    • Yorktown 1781 as the military end
    • Independence declared in 1776, not granted
    • Unfinished issues: forts, Constitution, War of 1812

    Loses marks

    • Only narrating the treaty.

    Earns more

    • Marks for a judgement on legal versus practical ending.

    Extra mark

    • Treaties of Versailles.
  2. (b) Critically examine the claim that Chartism fulfilled middle-class demands and had ramifications for workers and colonies. 10 marks · 150 words

    critique— the claim → its strengths → its weaknesses → your judgment

    Must cover

    • Six points of the Charter and the petitions
    • Working-class character versus middle-class role (1832, Anti-Corn Law League)
    • Later adoption of five points by other parties
    • Effects on labour and Australia

    Loses marks

    • Accepting the claim without critique.

    Earns more

    • Marks for testing the claim with evidence.

    Extra mark

    • Eureka link; John Frost.
  3. (c) Critically examine the claim that the Revolutions of 1848 were shaped by democracy and nationalism. 10 marks · 150 words

    critique— the claim → its strengths → its weaknesses → your judgment

    Must cover

    • Democratic and national demands across Europe
    • Social and economic distress, June Days
    • Conflicts between nationalisms
    • Judgement on outcomes

    Loses marks

    • Listing countries only.

    Earns more

    • Marks for balancing ideas against social causes.

    Extra mark

    • A. J. P. Taylor's remark.
  4. (d) Critically examine the claim that British imperialism in South Africa was influenced largely by diamond mining. 10 marks · 150 words

    critique— the claim → its strengths → its weaknesses → your judgment

    Must cover

    • Kimberley, Griqualand West, Rhodes and De Beers
    • Strategic concerns: Cape route, Suez, Germany
    • Gold after 1886, Jameson Raid, Boer War
    • Hobson and Lenin versus Robinson and Gallagher; judgement

    Loses marks

    • Treating diamonds as the only cause.

    Earns more

    • Marks for weighing diamonds against gold and strategy.

    Extra mark

    • Carnarvon's confederation; Milner.
  5. (e) Critically examine the claim that US supremacy after the Cold War had its challenges. 10 marks · 150 words

    critique— the claim → its strengths → its weaknesses → your judgment

    Must cover

    • Unipolar moment: Gulf War, NATO, Kosovo
    • Challenges: 9/11, Iraq and Afghanistan, 2008 crisis
    • Rise of China, Russia, BRICS
    • Judgement: from unipolar to multipolar

    Loses marks

    • One-sided account of decline.

    Earns more

    • Marks for evidence on both supremacy and challenges.

    Extra mark

    • Krauthammer; Belt and Road.
What "Critically examine" is asking you to do

Test the proposition the question puts to you and return a finding on how far it holds. Examine stems carry a claim, or ask whether something has happened, and expect evidence weighed both ways before the extent is stated — often with remedial measures attached. “Critically” is not a section added at the end: name the yardstick you are judging by — the evidence, the stated objective, a constitutional principle, a rival explanation — and let a verdict close each part of the body. Where the question quotes a claim, that verdict must land on the claim itself, accepted, qualified or rejected, and not on the theme in general.

Structure that answers it

Restate the claim as the question frames it → evidence that supports it → evidence that undercuts it → the conditions under which it holds → verdict on how far it stands

Where marks are lost

Merits in one paragraph, demerits in the next, and a conclusion calling for a balanced and holistic approach. That is a survey with the judgement left out and it holds the answer in the middle band. The opposite error is reading “critically” as permission to attack — and with the odd pairings, critically describe or critically explain, the exposition still carries most of the marks, the judgement being a layer on it rather than a substitute for it.

All UPSC directive words, compared →

Practice this exact question

Write your answer and it is marked point by point against the model answer above — what you covered, what you missed, what you got wrong.

Evaluate my answer →

More from History 2023 Paper II

Write this answer and get it marked in about 20 seconds

Free account: 5 AI evaluations a month, marked against the rubric above.

Start free

Already have an account? Log in