Physics 2023 Paper II 50 marks Derive

Paper II — Q6

(a) Establish the Rutherford's scattering cross section formula for α-particle by considering the standard assumptions and…

(a)

Establish the Rutherford's scattering cross section formula for α-particle by considering the standard assumptions and symbols. 20 marks

(b)

By assuming the nucleus as a cubical box of length equal to the nuclear diameter 10⁻¹² cm, calculate the kinetic energy of the highest level occupied nucleon of iron-56 nucleus. 15 marks

(c)

What do you understand by nuclear forces ? Explain meson theory of exchange forces. 5+10=15 marks

हिंदी में प्रश्न पढ़ें
(a)

मानक अभिधारणाओं एवं प्रतीकों को लेकर α-कणों के लिए रदरफोर्ड के प्रकीर्णन परिच्छेद के सूत्र को स्थापित कीजिए । 20

(b)

नाभिक को नाभिक व्यास 10⁻¹² cm के समतुल्य लम्बाई का एक घनीय बॉक्स मान कर उच्चतम स्तर पर अधिष्ठित आयरन-56 नाभिक के न्यूक्लिऑन की गतिज ऊर्जा की गणना कीजिये । 15

(c)

नाभिकीय बलों से आप क्या समझते हैं ? विनिमय बलों के मेसॉन सिद्धांत की व्याख्या कीजिये । 5+10=15

Q6 of the 2023 UPSC Mains Physics Paper II, as printed
The question as printed in the 2023 Physics paper

Model answer

Drafted with AI by UPSC Answer Check against this question's marking rubric, to the expected length. UPSC does not publish answers for Mains — this is one way to score well, not an official key. How we build rubrics and answers.

(a) Rutherford's scattering cross section for α-particles

Assumptions: the α-particle (charge ze) and the nucleus (charge Ze) interact only by the Coulomb force F = kzZe²/r², k = 1/4πε₀; the nucleus is a point charge, heavy enough to stay at rest; motion is non-relativistic; a thin foil gives single scattering; the α-particle does not penetrate the nucleus; atomic electrons are ignored. Let the α-particle have speed v and kinetic energy E = ½mv² at large distance, and let b be the impact parameter and θ the scattering angle. Angular momentum is conserved, mvb = mr²φ̇, so dt = r²dφ/(vb). Energy conservation means the speed after scattering is again v, so the momentum change has magnitude Δp = 2mv sin(θ/2), directed along the axis of symmetry of the hyperbolic path. The path is symmetric about the axis, and the asymptotes make angle φ₀ = (π − θ)/2 with it. The impulse along the axis is Δp = ∫F cosφ dt = (kzZe²/vb) ∫₋φ₀^φ₀ cosφ dφ = (2kzZe²/vb) sinφ₀ = (2kzZe²/vb) cos(θ/2). Equating the two expressions for Δp: b = (kzZe²/mv²) cot(θ/2) = (zZe²/8πε₀E) cot(θ/2). Particles with impact parameter between b and b + db scatter into angle θ to θ + dθ, so dσ = 2πb|db| = (dσ/dΩ) 2π sinθ dθ, and dσ/dΩ = (b/sinθ)|db/dθ|. With A = zZe²/8πε₀E, b = A cot(θ/2) and |db/dθ| = (A/2) csc²(θ/2): dσ/dΩ = [A cot(θ/2)/(2 sin(θ/2)cos(θ/2))] (A/2) csc²(θ/2) = (A²/4) csc⁴(θ/2). dσ/dΩ = (zZe²/16πε₀E)² / sin⁴(θ/2), and for z = 2: (Ze²/8πε₀E)² / sin⁴(θ/2). Check: the units are m² per steradian. The count of scattered α-particles varies as 1/sin⁴(θ/2), Z² and 1/E², as verified by Geiger and Marsden.

Diagram: Rutherford scattering orbit

(b) Highest-occupied nucleon level in ⁵⁶Fe, cubical box model

For a cubical box of side L = 10⁻¹² cm = 10⁻¹⁴ m: E = E₀(n₁² + n₂² + n₃²), with n = 1, 2, 3, … and E₀ = π²ħ²/(2mL²). E₀ = π²(1.055×10⁻³⁴)²/(2 × 1.67×10⁻²⁷ × 10⁻²⁸) = 3.29×10⁻¹³ J = 2.05 MeV. ⁵⁶Fe has Z = 26 protons and N = 30 neutrons. By the Pauli principle each spatial level holds two nucleons of one kind (spin up and down), and protons and neutrons fill levels independently. The levels, in order of S = n₁² + n₂² + n₃², have these states and cumulative capacity per kind: S = 3: 1 state, 2; S = 6: 3 states, 8; S = 9: 3 states, 14; S = 11: 3 states, 20; S = 12: 1 state, 22; S = 14: 6 states, 34. Both 26 protons and 30 neutrons exceed 22 and fit within 34, so the highest occupied level has S = 14. E_max = 14E₀ = 14 × 2.05 = 28.7 MeV (4.6×10⁻¹² J). This treats nucleons as independent particles in a rigid box, so it gives the order of magnitude (a few tens of MeV, comparable to the Fermi energy).

(c) Nuclear forces and the meson theory of exchange forces

Nuclear forces are the strong forces between nucleons that bind the nucleus. Their features are: short range (about 1-2 fm); much stronger than the Coulomb force at that range; charge independence (n-n, p-p and n-p forces are nearly equal); dependence on spin and a non-central (tensor) part; saturation; and a repulsive core at about 0.5 fm. Yukawa's meson theory (1935): nucleons interact by exchanging virtual mesons. A nucleon emits a meson of mass m, violating energy conservation by ΔE ≈ mc² for a time Δt ≈ ħ/mc², and another nucleon absorbs it. The meson can travel at most cΔt, so the range is R ≈ ħ/(mc). For R ≈ 1.4 fm, mc² = ħc/R ≈ 140 MeV, matching the pion discovered in 1947. Charged pions give charge exchange: p → n + π⁺, n → p + π⁻. Neutral pions give p-p and n-n forces. The exchange gives the Yukawa potential V(r) = −g² e^(−r/R)/r, which falls off faster than the Coulomb 1/r. Pion exchange also gives the spin-dependent and tensor parts (the deuteron's quadrupole moment shows the tensor force). Heavier mesons (ρ, ω) account for the short-range repulsion and saturation.

How this answer will be evaluated

Framework: Principle > Setup and diagram > Derivation > Result and limiting case

What earns full marks: Complete derivation with diagram, correct calculation with units, clear meson theory explanation

Evaluation rubric

Each sub-part is marked on its own, against the marks and word limit printed on the paper.

  1. (a) Derive Rutherford's scattering cross section for α-particles. 20 marks

    derive— given → assumptions → stepwise derivation → result → check

    Must cover

    • Assumptions: Coulomb force, point heavy nucleus, non-relativistic, single scattering
    • Impact parameter b, angle θ and conservation of angular momentum and energy
    • b = (kzZe²/mv²) cot(θ/2)
    • dσ/dΩ = (zZe²/16πε₀E)² csc⁴(θ/2)

    Loses marks

    • Quoting the formula without derivation or without defining b.

    Earns more

    • Marks for the assumptions, the b-θ relation, the cross-section step and the final formula.

    Extra mark

    • Labelled trajectory diagram and the Geiger-Marsden check.
  2. (b) Calculate the kinetic energy of the highest occupied nucleon of ⁵⁶Fe in a cubical box. 15 marks

    calculate— given → formula → substitution → result with units → interpretation

    Must cover

    • E₀ = π²ħ²/(2mL²) = 2.05 MeV for L = 10 fm
    • Levels E = E₀(n₁²+n₂²+n₃²) with two nucleons of each kind per state
    • Z = 26 and N = 30 fill up to S = 14
    • E = 14E₀ ≈ 28.7 MeV

    Loses marks

    • Unit conversion errors or ignoring Pauli's principle.

    Earns more

    • Marks for E₀, the level counting for protons and neutrons and the final energy with units.

    Extra mark

    • Order-of-magnitude comparison with the Fermi gas.
  3. (c) Define nuclear forces and explain Yukawa's meson theory of exchange forces. 15 marks

    explain— definition/context → points in order → small example → short close

    Must cover

    • Nuclear forces are strong, short-range, charge-independent, saturating
    • Virtual-meson exchange with R ≈ ħ/mc
    • mc² ≈ 140 MeV, i.e. the pion, with charged and neutral exchange
    • Yukawa potential V(r) = −g²e^(−r/R)/r

    Loses marks

    • Confusing nuclear with electromagnetic force or omitting the pion.

    Earns more

    • Marks for the definition, the exchange mechanism, the range argument and the potential.

    Extra mark

    • Tensor and spin dependence; heavy mesons for the repulsive core.
What "Derive" is asking you to do

Reach the stated expression from a starting relation, justifying every step. The destination is printed in the question, so only the route earns marks, and the assumptions you work under are part of that route.

Structure that answers it

Assumptions and notation defined → starting relation or governing equation → each step with its justification → the required expression → limiting case or boundary check

Where marks are lost

Writing the standard result first and fitting three lines to it, which an examiner reads at a glance. Marks also go on assumptions left unstated — lossless medium, small amplitude, errors independent with zero mean — and on symbols used before they are defined, even when the question says usual notations.

All UPSC directive words, compared →

Practice this exact question

Write your answer and it is marked point by point against the model answer above — what you covered, what you missed, what you got wrong.

Evaluate my answer →

More from Physics 2023 Paper II

Write this answer and get it marked in about 20 seconds

Free account: 5 AI evaluations a month, marked against the rubric above.

Start free

Already have an account? Log in