Paper II — Q5
(a) Scheduled areas (10 marks) (b) Ramapithecus-Sivapithecus debate (10 marks) (c) Village as little republic (10 marks) (d)…
Write short notes on the following in about 150 words each:
Scheduled areas 10 marks
Ramapithecus-Sivapithecus debate 10 marks
Village as little republic 10 marks
Dravidian languages and their subgroups 10 marks
Karma and Rebirth 10 marks
हिंदी में प्रश्न पढ़ें
निम्नलिखित प्रत्येक पर लगभग 150 शब्दों में लघु टिप्पणी लिखिए :
अनुसूचित क्षेत्र (10 अंक)
रामापिथेकस-सिवापिथेकस वाद-विवाद (10 अंक)
छोटे गणतंत्र के रूप में गाँव (10 अंक)
द्रविड भाषाएँ और उनके उपसमूह (10 अंक)
कर्म और पुनर्जन्म (10 अंक)
Model answer
Drafted with AI by UPSC Answer Check against this question's marking rubric, to the 150-word length. UPSC does not publish answers for Mains — this is one way to score well, not an official key. How we build rubrics and answers.
(a) Scheduled areas
Scheduled Areas are tribal-dominated areas declared by the President under Paragraph 6 of the Fifth Schedule (Article 244(1)), in states other than Assam, Meghalaya, Tripura and Mizoram, whose tribal areas fall under the Sixth Schedule. They are found in states such as Jharkhand, Odisha, Chhattisgarh, Madhya Pradesh, Gujarat, Rajasthan, Maharashtra, Andhra Pradesh, Telangana, Himachal Pradesh and Kerala. The Governor may direct that central or state laws do not apply or apply with changes, and makes regulations to prohibit or restrict transfer of tribal land and to regulate money-lending. A Tribes Advisory Council advises on welfare, and the Governor reports to the President on administration. The PESA Act, 1996 extends Panchayats to these areas and empowers Gram Sabhas over resources and disputes. Implementation of land protection and PESA remains uneven.
(b) Ramapithecus–Sivapithecus debate
Fossil teeth and jaws from the Miocene Siwalik deposits of India and Pakistan (about 12–8 million years old) were named Ramapithecus by G.E. Lewis in 1934. From the 1960s, Elwyn Simons and David Pilbeam argued that it was a hominid (human ancestor) on the basis of small canines, thick enamel, and a parabolic dental arch, placing the human origin in Asia. The view was criticised from the 1970s (Greenfield, 1979, who argued that Ramapithecus was the female of Sivapithecus, with thick-enamelled ape features), and molecular clocks dated the human–ape split to about 5–8 million years, too recent for a 12-million-year-old hominid. In 1980–82, the discovery of Sivapithecus face and jaws from the Potwar Plateau, Pakistan, showed orangutan-like features, so both are now regarded as one ape genus, Sivapithecus, related to the orangutan, and not a hominid ancestor.
(c) Village as little republic
The phrase comes from Sir Charles Metcalfe (1830), who described the Indian village as a little republic, self-sufficient and almost independent of outside relations, which survives while dynasties fall. Henry Maine (Village Communities, 1871) and Marx (the "Asiatic mode of production") carried the image into social theory. It portrays the village as a corporate unit with its own economy, caste-based division of labour, council and stability.
Modern sociologists have criticised it. Srinivas (Rampura) and Dube showed that villages are linked to other villages by caste, marriage and trade, and to the state and market. Béteille and others showed internal inequality, dominant castes, faction and conflict, not harmony, and colonial records show the village paid revenue and was part of wider political systems. Thus the village was never a closed republic, though it has a strong local identity and institutions such as the panchayat.
(d) Dravidian languages and their subgroups
The Dravidian family has about 70–85 languages spoken mainly in South India, with outliers in central and eastern India (Gondi, Kurukh) and Brahui in Pakistan. Krishnamurti divides it into four groups:
- South Dravidian: Tamil, Malayalam, Kannada, Tulu, Kodagu, Toda, Kota and Irula.
- South-Central Dravidian: Telugu, Gondi, Konda and Kui.
- Central Dravidian: Kolami, Parji, Naiki and Gadaba.
- North Dravidian: Kurukh (Oraon), Malto and Brahui.
Tamil has the oldest literature (Sangam). Features are agglutinative structure, retroflex consonants, a clusivity distinction in "we" and gender based on human versus non-human or masculine versus non-masculine. Dravidian has influenced Indo-Aryan in sounds and vocabulary.
(e) Karma and rebirth
Karma is the doctrine that actions have moral consequences, determining future births (samsara), and rebirth is the cycle continuing until liberation. Its forms differ: in Hinduism the soul (atman) is reborn according to karma and dharma, in Buddhism there is rebirth without a permanent soul (anatta), and in Jainism karma is subtle matter that clings to the soul (jiva).
Anthropologically, it is a moral theory that explains suffering and inequality, and so may legitimise caste hierarchy (Dumont, Weber's theodicy), while also giving hope of mobility through right conduct. Marriott and Inden saw Indian persons as "dividual", exchanging substance and moral qualities, in which karma has a place. Tribal groups have local versions, combining their own beliefs of ancestors and spirits with Hindu ideas.
How this answer will be evaluated
Framework: UPSC Anthropology Paper II (Sociology & Social Anthropology)
What earns full marks: Precise definitions, named scholars/sites, clear subgroups, strong Indian context.
Evaluation rubric
Each sub-part is marked on its own, against the marks and word limit printed on the paper.
- (a) (a) Write a short note on scheduled areas (10 marks). 10 marks · 150 words
write short notes— define → 3-4 key features → one example → one-line significance
Must cover
- Fifth Schedule, Article 244(1), declared by the President
- States with scheduled areas; Sixth Schedule distinction
- Governor's powers over laws, land transfer and moneylending
- TAC and PESA
Loses marks
- Mixing Fifth and Sixth Schedules.
- Wrong authority.
Earns more
- Implementation gaps.
- Names of states.
Extra mark
- Tribal land alienation
- Recent developments
- (b) (b) Write a short note on Ramapithecus-Sivapithecus debate (10 marks). 10 marks · 150 words
write short notes— define → 3-4 key features → one example → one-line significance
Must cover
- Lewis 1934 naming and Siwalik finds
- Hominid interpretation by Simons and Pilbeam
- Criticism: Greenfield and molecular clock
- 1980-82 Potwar Sivapithecus face; reclassification as ape
Loses marks
- Saying Ramapithecus is a hominid ancestor.
- Wrong discoverers.
Earns more
- Dental traits.
- Asian origin idea.
Extra mark
- Orangutan relationship
- Dates
- (c) (c) Write a short note on village as little republic (10 marks). 10 marks · 150 words
write short notes— define → 3-4 key features → one example → one-line significance
Must cover
- Metcalfe 1830 and Maine
- Image of self-sufficient autonomous village
- Critique: Srinivas, Dube, Béteille
- Village embedded in caste, state and market
Loses marks
- Accepting the republic image uncritically.
- No critique.
Earns more
- Colonial records.
- Local institutions.
Extra mark
- Marx's Asiatic mode
- Factionalism
- (d) (d) Write a short note on Dravidian languages and their subgroups (10 marks). 10 marks · 150 words
write short notes— define → 3-4 key features → one example → one-line significance
Must cover
- Family and distribution
- Four groups with languages
- Literary antiquity of Tamil
- Structural features and influence on Indo-Aryan
Loses marks
- Putting Telugu in South Dravidian.
- No subgroups.
Earns more
- Outliers such as Brahui and Kurukh.
- Agglutination.
Extra mark
- Krishnamurti's classification
- Gender rule
- (e) (e) Write a short note on karma and rebirth (10 marks). 10 marks · 150 words
write short notes— define → 3-4 key features → one example → one-line significance
Must cover
- Definition of karma and samsara
- Hindu, Buddhist and Jain variants
- Social function: explaining inequality, legitimating caste
- Anthropological perspectives and tribal versions
Loses marks
- Treating all traditions as the same.
- No anthropological angle.
Earns more
- Dharma link.
- Dividual person concept.
Extra mark
- Dumont and Weber
- Mobility through conduct
What "Write short notes" is asking you to do
Five or six self-contained answers, marked separately, typically 10 marks and about 150 words each. Each note must carry its own definition, its two or three defining features and a line on why it matters; a common introduction or conclusion across the notes earns nothing.
Structure that answers it
Per note: one-line definition or identification → two or three features, mechanisms or named examples → one line of significance or Indian application
Where marks are lost
Writing the first two notes at essay length and rationing the rest. Each note is marked on its own, so marks surrendered on a compressed or unattempted note cannot be won back by the long ones.
Practice this exact question
Write your answer and it is marked point by point against the model answer above — what you covered, what you missed, what you got wrong.
Evaluate my answer →More from Anthropology 2023 Paper II
- Q2 (a) "Tribes are backward Hindus." Critically comment with reference to the contributions…
- Q3 (a) "Sanskritization is a culture-bound concept." Critically comment to assess the streng…
- Q4 (a) Elucidate the problems faced by Particularly Vulnerable Tribal Groups and the major c…
- Q5 Write short notes on the following in about 150 words each: (a) Scheduled areas (10 marks…
- Q6 (a) Is annihilation of caste possible? Discuss the future of caste system in the light of…
- Q7 (a) Elucidate the shifting terrains of India's tribal policies in colonial and post-colon…
- Q8 (a) Discuss the distribution of tribes in different geographical regions of India. Identi…