Paper I — Q1
(a) A cantilever beam ABCD, as shown in the above figure, is carrying a uniformly distributed load of 10 kN/m between B & C and a…
A cantilever beam ABCD, as shown in the above figure, is carrying a uniformly distributed load of 10 kN/m between B & C and a clockwise moment of 50 kN-m at free end D. Draw the free body diagram for A, D and for the member BC only. [Figure: fixed at A; AB = BC = CD = 2 m; AC has moment of inertia 2I and CD has I.] 10 marks
Cross-section of an axially loaded compression member is shown in the above figure. This compression member was to be loaded at centre 'O' of the Section. Due to mistake this was loaded at point 'P' by a concentrated load of 500 kN. Find out the stresses at points A, B, C and D of the Section. [Figure: square section 600 mm × 600 mm with corners A (top-left), B (top-right), C (bottom-right), D (bottom-left); P is 100 mm to the right of and 100 mm above the centre O, i.e. towards B.] 10 marks
A uniformly distributed load of 20 kN/m intensity and 6 m length moves over a simply supported girder of 30 m span. What will be the maximum bending moment at a section 6 m from the left support A ? 10 marks
Determine the maximum permissible load (P) on the bolt A. Assume the Bolt value as 45·3 kN. [Figure: a 12 mm gusset-plate bracket bolted to the flange of an ISMB250 column by four bolts in a 2 × 2 group, gauge 120 mm (symmetric about the column centre line) and pitch 160 mm (edge distance 40 mm); load P acts 300 mm from the column centre line; A is the upper bolt on the load side.] 10 marks
What are the functions of transverse reinforcement in a reinforced concrete column ? 10 marks
हिंदी में प्रश्न पढ़ें
(क) नीचे चित्र में दर्शाए अनुसार एक प्रास धरन ABCD, B और C के बीच 10 kN/m का एकसमान वितरित भार एवं स्वतंत्र सिरे D पर 50 kN-m का दक्षिणावर्त आघूर्ण को वहन कर रही है। A, D और अवयव BC के लिए मुक्त-पिंड-आरेख बनाइए। [चित्र: A पर स्थिर; AB = BC = CD = 2 m; AC का जड़त्व-आघूर्ण 2I तथा CD का I।] (10 अंक)
(ख) नीचे चित्र में एक अक्षीय-भारित-संपीडांग का अनुप्रस्थ काट दर्शाया गया है। इस संपीडांग को काट के केन्द्र 'O' पर भारित किया जाना था। त्रुटिवश इसे 500 kN के संकेन्द्रित भार द्वारा बिन्दु 'P' पर भारित कर दिया गया। काट के बिन्दुओं A, B, C और D पर प्रतिबल ज्ञात कीजिए। [चित्र: 600 mm × 600 mm वर्गाकार काट, कोने A (ऊपर-बाएँ), B (ऊपर-दाएँ), C (नीचे-दाएँ), D (नीचे-बाएँ); P केन्द्र O से 100 mm दाएँ तथा 100 mm ऊपर, अर्थात B की ओर।] (10 अंक)
(ग) 20 kN/m की तीव्रता एवं 6 मीटर लम्बाई का एक समान वितरित भार, 30 मीटर की विस्तृति वाले शुद्धालम्बित गर्डर पर संचलित होता है । बाँए आलम्ब A से 6 मीटर पर स्थित एक काट पर अधिकतम बकन आघूर्ण कितना होगा ? (10 अंक)
(घ) बोल्ट A के लिए अधिकतम अनुज्ञेय भार (P) ज्ञात कीजिए । बोल्ट का मान 45·3 kN मान लीजिए । [चित्र: 12 mm गसेट प्लेट का ब्रैकेट ISMB250 स्तम्भ के फ्लैंज पर 2 × 2 समूह के चार बोल्टों से जुड़ा है; गेज 120 mm (स्तम्भ की केन्द्र-रेखा के सापेक्ष सममित), पिच 160 mm (किनारा-दूरी 40 mm); भार P स्तम्भ की केन्द्र-रेखा से 300 mm पर; A भार की ओर का ऊपरी बोल्ट है।] (10 अंक)
(ङ) एक प्रबलित कंक्रीट स्तम्भ में, अनुप्रस्थ प्रबलन के क्या कार्य होते हैं ? (10 अंक)
The figure this question refers to, in words
The question paper is a scan and the diagram did not survive as text. This is the figure as read from the original page — every component, value and label — so the question can be worked from the text below.
(a) A horizontal cantilever beam ABCD fixed at the left end A and free at the right end D. The beam is divided into three segments: segment AB of length 2 m, segment BC of length 2 m, and segment CD of length 2 m (total length = 6 m). The cross-section for portion AC (from A to C, length 4 m) has a flexural rigidity or moment of inertia indicated by a circled '2I', and it is drawn with a larger depth. Portion CD (from C to D, length 2 m) has a moment of inertia indicated by a circled 'I', and it is drawn with a smaller depth aligned with the top surface. A uniformly distributed load of 10 kN/m acts downward on the top of segment BC (between B and C). At the free end D, a clockwise concentrated moment of 50 kN-m is applied.
(b) A square cross-section ABCD of an axially loaded compression member with dimensions 600 mm width by 600 mm height. The corners are labeled clockwise: A at top-left, B at top-right, C at bottom-right, and D at bottom-left. Mutually perpendicular dashed centerlines intersect at the geometric center 'O'. An eccentric point 'P' is located in the top-right quadrant, at an eccentricity of 100 mm to the right of the vertical centerline and 100 mm above the horizontal centerline. A concentrated load of 500 kN acts downward at point 'P'.
(c) A simply supported beam AB of span 30 m with support A at the left and support B at the right. A section C is located at a distance of 6 m from support A. Above the girder, a moving uniformly distributed load (UDL) of length 6 m and intensity 20 kN/m is shown with a rightward arrow indicating direction of movement.
(c) Fig. 2 titled 'FIG. 2 REPRESENTATIVE STRESS-STRAIN CURVES FOR REINFORCEMENT' showing two stress-strain plots:
- Top Plot: '23A Cold Worked Deformed Bar'
- Vertical axis: Stress (प्रतिबल) with marked values 0.80fy, 0.85fy, 0.90fy, 0.95fy, 0.975fy, and fy.
- Horizontal axis: Strain (विकृति) with marked offset values 0.0001, 0.0003, 0.0007, 0.001, 0.002, 0.003, and 0.004.
- Features two curves: an upper characteristic curve reaching a horizontal plateau at fy, and a lower design curve reaching a horizontal plateau at fy/1.15.
- Initial linear portion for both curves has modulus of elasticity Es = 200000 N/mm^2.
- Dashed lines with slope Es are drawn from strain offsets on the horizontal axis to intersect the characteristic curve:
- offset 0.0001 corresponds to stress 0.80fy
- offset 0.0003 corresponds to stress 0.85fy
- offset 0.0007 corresponds to stress 0.90fy
- offset 0.001 corresponds to stress 0.95fy
- offset 0.002 corresponds to stress 0.975fy
- offset 0.004 corresponds to stress fy (at the start of the horizontal plateau).
- Bottom Plot: '23B STEEL BAR WITH DEFINITE YIELD POINT'
- Vertical axis: Stress (प्रतिबल).
- Horizontal axis: Strain (विकृति), starting at 0.
- Features two idealized elastic-plastic curves:
- Characteristic curve: linear elastic slope with Es = 200000 N/mm^2 from the origin up to a yield stress fy, followed by a flat horizontal yield plateau at fy.
- Design curve: linear elastic slope with Es = 200000 N/mm^2 from the origin up to a design yield stress of fy/1.15 (0.87fy), followed by a flat horizontal yield plateau at fy/1.15.
(d) A bracket connection showing a 12 mm thick gusset plate fastened to a vertical column of section ISMB 250 with a flange width of 200 mm. The connection uses four bolts arranged in a 2-by-2 rectangular grid. A vertical centerline is drawn through the column and bolt group. The horizontal spacing between the two columns of bolts is 120 mm (centered on the vertical centerline). The vertical spacing between the two rows of bolts is 160 mm, with vertical edge distances of 40 mm above the top row and 40 mm below the bottom row. The top-right bolt is labelled 'A'. The gusset plate extends to the right to support a vertical downward load P applied at a horizontal distance of 300 mm from the vertical centerline of the column.
Model answer
Drafted with AI by UPSC Answer Check against this question's marking rubric, to the expected length. UPSC does not publish answers for Mains — this is one way to score well, not an official key. How we build rubrics and answers.
(a) The beam is fixed at A with AB = BC = CD = 2 m; AC has 2I and CD has I. The stiffness affects only deflection, not the statics.
Support reactions (whole beam as the free body, anticlockwise moments positive):
- ΣFy = 0: R_A − 10 × 2 = 0, so R_A = 20 kN upward.
- ΣM_A = 0: M_A − 20 × 3 − 50 = 0, so M_A = 110 kN·m anticlockwise (hogging at the wall).
FBD of support A: the wall pushes the beam up with 20 kN and applies a 110 kN·m anticlockwise couple to it; equal and opposite actions (20 kN down, 110 kN·m clockwise) act on the wall.
FBD of end D: the free end carries only the applied 50 kN·m clockwise couple. Taking segment CD as the free body, the action at C is a 50 kN·m anticlockwise couple with zero shear, so CD is in pure bending.
FBD of member BC (cut just right of B and just left of C):
- At B (action of AB on BC): shear 20 kN upward and moment 70 kN·m anticlockwise (hogging), since the loads to the right give M_B = 50 + 20 × 1 = 70 kN·m.
- On BC: UDL 10 kN/m, resultant 20 kN downward at 1 m from B.
- At C (action of CD on BC): shear 0 and moment 50 kN·m clockwise.
- Checks: ΣFy = 20 − 20 + 0 = 0; ΣM_B = 70 − 20 × 1 − 50 = 0.
Bending moment (hogging throughout): 110 kN·m at A, falling linearly to 70 kN·m at B, parabolically to 50 kN·m at C, and constant at 50 kN·m from C to D.
(b) The section is a 600 × 600 mm square with corners A (top-left), B (top-right), C (bottom-right) and D (bottom-left). The 500 kN load acts at P, 100 mm right of and 100 mm above the centroid O, i.e. towards B.
- Area = 600 × 600 = 3.6 × 10⁵ mm²; Z_x = Z_y = 600 × 600²/6 = 3.6 × 10⁷ mm³.
- Direct stress: P/A = 500 × 10³ / 3.6 × 10⁵ = 1.389 N/mm² (compression).
- Moments: M_x = M_y = 500 × 0.1 = 50 kN·m, so the extreme-fibre bending stress about each axis is M/Z = 50 × 10⁶ / 3.6 × 10⁷ = 1.389 N/mm².
- σ = P/A ± M_x/Z_x ± M_y/Z_y (compression positive; fibres on the side of P are compressed more):
- B (towards P in both directions): 1.389 + 1.389 + 1.389 = 4.167 N/mm² compression.
- A (towards P vertically, away horizontally): 1.389 + 1.389 − 1.389 = 1.389 N/mm² compression.
- C (towards P horizontally, away vertically): 1.389 − 1.389 + 1.389 = 1.389 N/mm² compression.
- D (away from P in both directions): 1.389 − 1.389 − 1.389 = −1.389 N/mm², i.e. 1.389 N/mm² tension.
Why D goes into tension: for no tension the load must lie within the kern, which for a rectangle requires 6e_x/b + 6e_y/d ≤ 1 (a rhombus with vertices at b/6 = 100 mm on the axes). Here 6(100)/600 + 6(100)/600 = 2 > 1, so P lies outside the kern. The neutral axis (σ = 0) is the line x + y = −300 mm, joining the mid-points of sides AD and DC; the triangle beyond it, at D, is in tension. Loaded at O as intended, the whole section would carry a uniform 1.389 N/mm².
(c) The influence line for bending moment at C (a = 6 m, b = 24 m, L = 30 m) is a triangle with peak ordinate ab/L = 6 × 24/30 = 4.8 m at C; y = 0.8x left of C and y = 0.2(30 − x) right of C.
For a UDL shorter than the span, M_C is greatest when the section divides the load in the same ratio as it divides the span: 1.2 m of load left of C and 4.8 m right (1.2 : 4.8 = 6 : 24). The load then occupies 4.8 m to 10.8 m from A, and the ordinates under its two ends are equal: 0.8 × 4.8 = 3.84 and 0.2 × (30 − 10.8) = 3.84. Moving the load either way would drop a higher ordinate than it picks up, so this position gives the maximum.
Area of ILD under the load = ½(3.84 + 4.8)(1.2) + ½(4.8 + 3.84)(4.8) = 5.184 + 20.736 = 25.92 m².
M_max at C = w × area = 20 × 25.92 = 518.4 kN·m.
(d) The bracket is bolted by four bolts in a 2 × 2 group: gauge 120 mm (x = ±60 mm about the column centre line) and pitch 160 mm (y = ±80 mm). P acts 300 mm from the centroid of the group, and A is the upper bolt on the load side. The plate is treated as rigid (elastic method).
- r = √(60² + 80²) = 100 mm for every bolt; Σr² = 4 × 100² = 40 000 mm².
- Direct shear: P/4 = 0.25P on each bolt, downward.
- Twisting moment: M = 300P N·mm (clockwise).
- Torsional shear on A acts perpendicular to its radius: F_t = M·r/Σr² = 300P × 100/40 000 = 0.75P. Its horizontal component is M·y/Σr² = 300P × 80/40 000 = 0.60P, and its vertical component is M·x/Σr² = 300P × 60/40 000 = 0.45P, downward (the same sense as the direct shear).
- Resultant on A: R = √[(0.60P)² + (0.25P + 0.45P)²] = √(0.36 + 0.49) P = 0.922P.
- Set R equal to the bolt value: 0.922P = 45.3 kN, so P = 49.1 kN.
The two bolts on the load side (A and the one below it) are equally critical; each bolt on the far side carries only √(0.60² + 0.20²) P = 0.63P.
(e) Transverse reinforcement (lateral ties or helical spirals) in an RC column does the following:
- Prevents buckling of the longitudinal bars. Ties shorten the unsupported length of each compression bar, so the bars reach their design stress without bowing outward and spalling the cover.
- Confines the concrete core. Closely spaced ties, and especially helical spirals, restrain lateral expansion under axial compression, which raises the strength and the ultimate strain of the core. IS 456 (cl. 39.4) allows a helically reinforced column 1.05 times the strength of a similar tied column when the helix meets the volume requirement.
- Gives ductility. Confinement lets the column undergo large deformations without sudden failure; IS 13920 therefore requires special confining links near beam–column joints in seismic zones.
- Resists shear. Under wind or earthquake loads the ties act as shear reinforcement, like stirrups in a beam.
- Holds the cage together. Ties keep the longitudinal bars in position during concreting and restrain lap splices against splitting.
Detailing rules (IS 456, cl. 26.5.3.2):
- Tie diameter: not less than one-quarter of the largest longitudinal bar diameter, and not less than 6 mm.
- Pitch: not more than the least lateral dimension of the column, 16 times the smallest longitudinal bar diameter, or 300 mm.
- Restraint: every corner bar and alternate bars must be held by a tie corner; bars within 75 mm of a restrained bar need not be tied separately.
How this answer will be evaluated
What earns full marks: All parts solved with correct method, units, and checks; neat diagrams.
Evaluation rubric
Each sub-part is marked on its own, against the marks and word limit printed on the paper.
- (a) Free body diagrams for support A, free end D, and member BC. 10 marks
map— locate accurately → label → one line on why it matters
Must cover
- FBD of support A: R_A = 20 kN upward and M_A = 110 kN·m anticlockwise (hogging) on the beam
- FBD at D: the applied 50 kN·m clockwise couple, balanced at C by 50 kN·m with zero shear (CD in pure bending)
- FBD of BC with the 10 kN/m UDL (resultant 20 kN at mid-length of BC)
- Internal actions on BC: shear 20 kN up and 70 kN·m hogging at B; shear 0 and 50 kN·m at C; equilibrium checked
Loses marks
- Missing reaction at fixed support A
- Ignoring the 50 kN-m moment at D
Earns more
- Labelled dimensions (2m, 2m)
- Consistent sign convention
Extra mark
- Neat, to-scale sketch
- (b) Stresses at points A, B, C, and D of the section. 10 marks
calculate— given → formula → substitution → result with units → interpretation
Must cover
- Direct stress P/A = 500 × 10³ / 3.6 × 10⁵ = 1.389 N/mm²
- Moments M_x = M_y = 500 × 0.1 = 50 kN·m (e = 100 mm about each axis)
- Section modulus Z = 600³/6 = 3.6 × 10⁷ mm³ about each axis, so M/Z = 1.389 N/mm²
- Superposition: A = 1.389 (C), B = 4.167 (C), C = 1.389 (C), D = 1.389 N/mm² (T)
Loses marks
- Ignoring eccentricity of load P
- Incorrect section properties for 600x600 mm
Earns more
- Explains the tension at D: P lies outside the kern (6e_x/b + 6e_y/d = 2 > 1); neutral axis joins the mid-points of AD and DC
- Units carried through (MPa or N/mm²)
Extra mark
- Stress distribution diagram
- (c) Maximum bending moment at a section 6 m from support A. 10 marks
calculate— given → formula → substitution → result with units → interpretation
Must cover
- ILD for M at C: triangle with peak ab/L = 6 × 24/30 = 4.8 m at C
- Load placed so that C divides it in the ratio 6 : 24 (1.2 m left, 4.8 m right; from 4.8 m to 10.8 m; equal end ordinates 3.84)
- Area of ILD under the load = 25.92 m²
- M_max = 20 × 25.92 = 518.4 kN·m
Loses marks
- Incorrect ILD peak value
- Placing load symmetrically without justification
Earns more
- Correct peak ordinate of ILD (ab/L = 4.8 m)
- Clear sketch of load position
Extra mark
- Comparison with mid-span moment
- (d) Maximum permissible load P on bolt A. 10 marks
calculate— given → formula → substitution → result with units → interpretation
Must cover
- Bolt-group centroid on the column centre line; e = 300 mm, M = 300P
- r = 100 mm for every bolt; Σr² = 4(60² + 80²) = 40 000 mm²
- Bolt A: direct 0.25P down plus torsional 0.60P horizontal and 0.45P down; resultant 0.922P
- 0.922P ≤ 45.3 kN, so P ≈ 49.1 kN
Loses marks
- Ignoring the moment caused by eccentric load P
- Incorrect bolt group centroid
Earns more
- Correct geometry (gauge 120 mm × pitch 160 mm; e = 300 mm)
- Vector addition of forces
Extra mark
- Check for bearing or tearing
- (e) Functions of transverse reinforcement in an RCC column. 10 marks
explain— definition/context → points in order → small example → short close
Must cover
- Prevention of buckling of longitudinal bars
- Confinement of concrete core
- Resistance to shear forces
- Ductility and energy dissipation
Loses marks
- Listing only one function
- Confusing with beam stirrups function
Earns more
- IS 456 cl. 26.5.3.2 detailing: tie diameter ≥ φ/4 and ≥ 6 mm; pitch ≤ least lateral dimension, 16φ and 300 mm
- Distinguishes lateral ties from helical reinforcement, whose confinement earns a 1.05 strength factor (IS 456 cl. 39.4)
Extra mark
- Sketch of column with ties
What "Solve" is asking you to do
Choose the method, then carry it through to a final answer. Identifying what kind of problem this is and why that method applies is the first thing marked; a correct figure arrived at invisibly earns almost nothing.
Structure that answers it
Given data and what is required → method chosen, with the reason it applies → set-up (equation, circuit, free body, trial balance) → working, step by step → answer with units and any condition of validity
Where marks are lost
Doing the middle steps mentally and writing only the result. In mathematics papers, a further loss comes from giving a decimal where the exact value in surds or fractions was wanted, or from skipping the justification a part explicitly asks for.
Practice this exact question
Write your answer and it is marked point by point against the model answer above — what you covered, what you missed, what you got wrong.
Evaluate my answer →More from Civil Engineering 2024 Paper I
- Q1 (a) A cantilever beam ABCD, as shown in the above figure, is carrying a uniformly distrib…
- Q2 (a) A cantilever beam ABC as shown in the above figure is having a total span of 2·0 m. T…
- Q3 (a) A box culvert ABCD is shown in the above figure. By using member fixed end moments gi…
- Q4 (a) A prestressed concrete T-beam having the cross-section of flange 1500 mm wide and 200…