Civil Engineering 2024 Paper I 50 marks Solve

Paper I — Q4

(a) A prestressed concrete T-beam having the cross-section of flange 1500 mm wide and 200 mm thick, rib of 300 mm wide and 1200…

(a)

A prestressed concrete T-beam having the cross-section of flange 1500 mm wide and 200 mm thick, rib of 300 mm wide and 1200 mm deep. The beam carries a live load of 20 kN/m apart from its dead load, over a simply supported span of 18 m. The beam is prestressed with a straight cable having constant eccentricity 'e'. Assume the losses of prestress as 16%. Determine the initial prestressing force 'Pᵢ' and its eccentricity 'e', if the permissible net stresses are equal to zero and 5 MPa respectively at top and bottom fibres of the beam. The unit weight of concrete is 25 kN/m³. 20 marks

(b)

A pin jointed, symmetrically loaded, truss 'ABCDE' is shown in the above figure. Cross-sectional area of each member is 500 mm² and E = 200 GPa. Forces in the members meeting at joint C are also shown in the figure. Calculate the vertical deflection of joint C by unit load method. [Figure: bottom chord A–C–E with AC = CE = 3·0 m, top chord B–D; all members meet at 60°, so ABC, BCD and CDE are equilateral triangles; pin support at A, roller at E; 100 kN downward at C; forces shown at C: BC = CD = 57·74 kN (tension), AC = CE = 28·87 kN (tension).] 20 marks

(c)

What are the different modes of failure of a structural steel tension member ? Explain with sketches. 10 marks

हिंदी में प्रश्न पढ़ें

(क) एक पूर्व प्रतिबलित T-धरन की अनुप्रस्थ काट में फ्लेंज 1500 mm चौड़ी एवं 200 mm मोटी और रिब 300 mm चौड़ी एवं 1200 mm गहरी है। यह धरन अपने अचल भार के अतिरिक्त 20 kN/m का चल भार, 18 m की शुद्धालम्बित विस्तृति पर वहन करती है। इस धरन को नियत उत्केन्द्रता 'e' वाले सीधे तार से पूर्व-प्रतिबलित किया गया है। पूर्व प्रतिबल में ह्रास 16% मान लीजिए। यदि धरन के शीर्ष और तल के तंतुओं में अनुज्ञेय निवल प्रतिबल क्रमशः: शून्य और 5 MPa है तो प्रारंभिक प्रतिबलन बल 'Pᵢ' और इसकी उत्केन्द्रता 'e' निर्धारित कीजिए। कंक्रीट का एकक भार 25 kN/m³ है। (20 अंक)

(ख) नीचे चित्र में एक पिन जोड़ वाली सममित रूप से भारित कैंची ABCDE दर्शाई गई है। प्रत्येक अवयव का अनुप्रस्थ काट क्षेत्रफल 500 mm² और E = 200 GPa है। जोड़ C पर मिलने वाले सभी अवयवों के बलों को चित्र में दर्शाया गया है। एकक-भार-विधि द्वारा जोड़ C के ऊर्ध्वाधर विस्थाप की गणना कीजिए। [चित्र: निचली जीवा A–C–E, AC = CE = 3·0 m; ऊपरी जीवा B–D; सभी अवयव 60° पर मिलते हैं, अतः ABC, BCD तथा CDE समबाहु त्रिभुज हैं; A पर पिन आलम्ब, E पर बेलन; C पर 100 kN नीचे की ओर; C पर दर्शाए बल: BC = CD = 57·74 kN (तनाव), AC = CE = 28·87 kN (तनाव)।] (20 अंक)

(ग) संरचनात्मक इस्पात के एक तनन अवयव में विभिन्न प्रकार की भंग विधाएं क्या हैं ? रेखाचित्रों द्वारा व्याख्या कीजिए । (10 अंक)

Q4 of the 2024 UPSC Mains Civil Engineering Paper I, as printed
The question as printed in the 2024 Civil Engineering paper

The figure this question refers to, in words

The question paper is a scan and the diagram did not survive as text. This is the figure as read from the original page — every component, value and label — so the question can be worked from the text below.

(b) A symmetric pin-jointed truss labeled ABCDE consisting of three equilateral triangles (ABC, BCD, and CDE) with 60-degree angles. The bottom chord lies on a horizontal line with joints A, C, and E, where joint A is a pin/hinged support and joint E is also supported. The horizontal distance from A to C is 3.0 m, and from C to E is 3.0 m (total span 6.0 m). The top chord connects joints B and D horizontally. Members include AB, BC, CD, DE, BD, AC, and CE. A downward vertical point load of 100 kN is applied at joint C. Internal member forces for all four members meeting at joint C are shown acting away from joint C: a force of 28.87 kN directed to the left along member AC; a force of 28.87 kN directed to the right along member CE; a force of 57.74 kN directed up-and-left along member BC; and a force of 57.74 kN directed up-and-right along member CD. The angles indicated are 60 degrees at angle BAC, angle ABC, angle BCA, angle DCE, and angle DEC.

Model answer

Drafted with AI by UPSC Answer Check against this question's marking rubric, to the expected length. UPSC does not publish answers for Mains — this is one way to score well, not an official key. How we build rubrics and answers.

(a) Section: flange 1500 × 200 mm and rib 300 mm wide. The 1200 mm is taken as the overall depth (rib 1000 mm below the flange), which gives the round section properties the data are set up for.

  • A = 1500 × 200 + 300 × 1000 = 6.0 × 10⁵ mm²
  • Centroid from the top: y_t = (3 × 10⁵ × 100 + 3 × 10⁵ × 700)/6 × 10⁵ = 400 mm, so y_b = 800 mm
  • I = 1500 × 200³/12 + 3 × 10⁵ × 300² + 300 × 1000³/12 + 3 × 10⁵ × 300² = 8.0 × 10¹⁰ mm⁴
  • Z_t = I/y_t = 2.0 × 10⁸ mm³; Z_b = I/y_b = 1.0 × 10⁸ mm³

Mid-span moments (span 18 m):

  • Self-weight g = 0.6 m² × 25 = 15 kN/m, so M_g = 15 × 18²/8 = 607.5 kN·m.
  • Live load: M_q = 20 × 18²/8 = 810 kN·m.
  • Total: M = 1417.5 kN·m.

Which stages the limits apply to. If both limits are applied at service (top = 0, bottom = 5 MPa with P = 0.84P_i), the two equations give e = 1751 mm, far outside the section (y_b = 800 mm), so that reading is impossible. The limits are therefore applied at the two critical stages at mid-span: no tension at the top fibre at transfer (P_i acting with M_g only), and 5 MPa compression at the bottom fibre at service (0.84P_i with the full M).

Top fibre at transfer:

P_i/A − P_i e/Z_t + M_g/Z_t = 0, which gives P_i(e − Z_t/A) = M_g, i.e. P_i(e − 333.3) = 607.5 × 10⁶ … (1)

Bottom fibre at service:

0.84P_i(1/A + e/Z_b) − M/Z_b = 5, which gives 0.84P_i(Z_b/A + e) = M + 5Z_b, i.e. P_i(e + 166.7) = 2282.7 × 10⁶ … (2)

Subtracting (1) from (2): 500 P_i = 1675.2 × 10⁶, so

  • P_i = 3350 kN
  • e = 333.3 + 607.5 × 10⁶/3.350 × 10⁶ = 515 mm below the centroid (285 mm above the soffit)
  • Effective force P_e = 0.84 × 3350 = 2814 kN

Stress check at mid-span (compression positive):

  • Transfer, top: 5.58 − 8.62 + 3.04 = 0.00 MPa; bottom: 5.58 + 17.24 − 6.08 = 16.75 MPa.
  • Service, top: 0.84 × (5.58 − 8.62) + 7.09 = 4.54 MPa; bottom: 0.84 × (5.58 + 17.24) − 14.18 = 5.00 MPa.

Both conditions are met and there is no tension at mid-span. At the supports (M = 0) a straight tendon would cause about 3.04 MPa tension at the top at transfer; this is normally controlled by debonding or sheathing the tendons near the ends.

Diagram: Prestressed T-beam section with tendon position and mid-span stress distributions at transfer and at service

(b) Geometry: triangles ABC, BCD and CDE are equilateral with AC = CE = 3 m, so every member is 3.0 m long. AE = 500 mm² × 200 kN/mm² = 1.0 × 10⁵ kN. Reactions: R_A = R_E = 50 kN.

Real forces N (tension +):

  • Joint C (given): AC = CE = +28.87 kN and BC = CD = +57.74 kN. Check: 2 × 57.74 × sin 60° = 100 kN.
  • Joint A: N_AB sin 60° + 50 = 0, so AB = −57.74 kN (compression); horizontally 28.87 − 57.74 cos 60° = 0.
  • Joint B: AB (compression) pushes B with (28.87 →, 50 ↑) and BC (tension) pulls it with (28.87 →, 50 ↓), so BD must supply 57.74 kN ←: BD = −57.74 kN (compression).
  • By symmetry DE = −57.74 kN.

Virtual forces n (1 kN down at C): the loading pattern is the same, so n = N/100.

  • AB, DE, BD: N = −57.74, n = −0.5774, L = 3 m, NnL = 100.0 each (300.0)
  • BC, CD: N = +57.74, n = +0.5774, L = 3 m, NnL = 100.0 each (200.0)
  • AC, CE: N = +28.87, n = +0.2887, L = 3 m, NnL = 25.0 each (50.0)
  • ΣNnL = 550.0 kN·m

δ_C = ΣNnL/(AE) = 550.0/(1.0 × 10⁵) m = 5.5 mm downward.

Energy check: ½ × 100 × δ = ΣN²L/(2AE) gives the same 5.5 mm. The top chord BD carries 57.74 kN compression and contributes 1.0 mm; it is not a zero-force member.

Diagram: Truss ABCDE with member forces and the unit-load deflection computation for joint C

(c) A tension member can fail in the member itself or at its end connection. IS 800:2007 (Section 6) takes the design strength as the least of the following:

  • Gross-section yielding (cl. 6.2). Away from the holes the whole section reaches f_y and the member stretches excessively. T_dg = A_g f_y/γ_m0 (γ_m0 = 1.10). This failure is ductile and gives warning.
  • Net-section rupture (cl. 6.3). The member fractures across the weakest section through the bolt holes, which may be a zig-zag path through staggered holes (A_n = [b − n d_h + Σp²/4g] t). T_dn = 0.9 A_n f_u/γ_m1 (γ_m1 = 1.25). This failure is sudden and less ductile.
  • Shear lag in angles and tees. When only one leg is connected, stress in the outstanding leg lags near the connection, so it is not fully effective: T_dn = 0.9 A_nc f_u/γ_m1 + β A_go f_y/γ_m0.
  • Block shear (cl. 6.4). A block of the connected plate or leg tears out: shear along the bolt line plus tension across to the edge. T_db is the lesser of A_vg f_y/(√3 γ_m0) + 0.9 A_tn f_u/γ_m1 and 0.9 A_vn f_u/(√3 γ_m1) + A_tg f_y/γ_m0.
  • Connection failure. Bolts can fail in shear or bearing and welds can fracture; the connection is designed so that this does not govern.

Gross yielding is the preferred mode because it is ductile, so connections are detailed to make rupture and block shear stronger than yielding.

Diagram: Failure modes of a steel tension member: gross yielding, net-section rupture, block shear and shear lag

How this answer will be evaluated

Framework: Civil Engineering Paper 1: Given > Assumptions > Design/Analysis > Result/Check

What earns full marks: Complete working with correct units, code references, and neat sketches; all assumptions stated.

Evaluation rubric

Each sub-part is marked on its own, against the marks and word limit printed on the paper.

  1. (a) Determine initial prestressing force Pi and eccentricity e for the T-beam. 20 marks

    calculate— given → formula → substitution → result with units → interpretation

    Must cover

    • Section properties (1200 mm overall depth): A = 6.0 × 10⁵ mm², y_t = 400 mm, I = 8.0 × 10¹⁰ mm⁴, Z_t = 2.0 × 10⁸ and Z_b = 1.0 × 10⁸ mm³
    • Moments: self-weight 15 kN/m gives M_g = 607.5 kN·m; live load M_q = 810 kN·m; total 1417.5 kN·m
    • Stress conditions: top fibre = 0 at transfer (P_i with M_g) and bottom fibre = 5 MPa at service (0.84P_i with M_g + M_q)
    • Solution: P_i ≈ 3350 kN and e ≈ 515 mm (P_e ≈ 2814 kN), with a stress check at both stages

    Loses marks

    • Ignoring prestress losses in final calculation
    • Using incorrect section modulus for T-beam
    • Missing units in intermediate steps

    Earns more

    • Shows that applying both limits at service gives e ≈ 1751 mm (outside the section) and so justifies the transfer/service pairing; a consistent answer taking the rib as 1200 mm below the flange also earns credit
    • Show free body diagram or section sketch
    • Verify final stresses against permissible limits

    Extra mark

    • Reference IS 1343 code clauses for prestressed concrete
  2. (b) Calculate vertical deflection of joint C using unit load method. 20 marks

    calculate— given → formula → substitution → result with units → interpretation

    Must cover

    • Geometry: every member is 3.0 m (equilateral triangles); AE = 500 mm² × 200 kN/mm² = 1.0 × 10⁵ kN
    • Real forces: AB = DE = BD = 57.74 kN (C); BC = CD = 57.74 kN (T); AC = CE = 28.87 kN (T)
    • Unit load at C gives n = N/100 in every member
    • δ_C = ΣNnL/AE = 550/10⁵ m = 5.5 mm downward

    Loses marks

    • Incorrect virtual force analysis at joint C
    • Using wrong member lengths for diagonal members
    • Forgetting to convert units (mm to m, GPa to MPa)

    Earns more

    • Tabulate N, n, L, and N*n*L for each member
    • Correctly resolve forces at 60° angles
    • State E and A values clearly before substitution

    Extra mark

    • Check for symmetry to reduce calculation steps
  3. (c) Explain different modes of failure of structural steel tension members. 10 marks

    explain— definition/context → points in order → small example → short close

    Must cover

    • Gross-section yielding: T_dg = A_g f_y/γ_m0 (ductile, large elongation)
    • Net-section rupture across bolt holes, including zig-zag paths and shear lag in angles: T_dn = 0.9 A_n f_u/γ_m1
    • Block shear: shear along the bolt line plus tension across to the edge (IS 800 cl. 6.4)
    • Labelled sketches of each mode; the design strength is the least of these

    Loses marks

    • Confusing tension failure with compression buckling
    • Missing sketches as explicitly requested
    • Vague description without specific failure mechanisms

    Earns more

    • Distinguish between ductile and brittle failure
    • Reference IS 800 code for design strengths
    • Show stress distribution diagrams

    Extra mark

    • Mention specific failure patterns for bolted connections
What "Solve" is asking you to do

Choose the method, then carry it through to a final answer. Identifying what kind of problem this is and why that method applies is the first thing marked; a correct figure arrived at invisibly earns almost nothing.

Structure that answers it

Given data and what is required → method chosen, with the reason it applies → set-up (equation, circuit, free body, trial balance) → working, step by step → answer with units and any condition of validity

Where marks are lost

Doing the middle steps mentally and writing only the result. In mathematics papers, a further loss comes from giving a decimal where the exact value in surds or fractions was wanted, or from skipping the justification a part explicitly asks for.

All UPSC directive words, compared →

Practice this exact question

Write your answer and it is marked point by point against the model answer above — what you covered, what you missed, what you got wrong.

Evaluate my answer →

More from Civil Engineering 2024 Paper I

Write this answer and get it marked in about 20 seconds

Free account: 5 AI evaluations a month, marked against the rubric above.

Start free

Already have an account? Log in