Paper I — Q7
(a) A canal is to be excavated through a soil with c = 20 kN/m², φ = 20°, e = 0·80 and G = 2·70. The side slope is 1 in 1. The…
A canal is to be excavated through a soil with c = 20 kN/m², φ = 20°, e = 0·80 and G = 2·70. The side slope is 1 in 1. The depth of the canal is to be 8 m. Determine the factor of safety with respect to cohesion when the canal runs full. What will be the factor of safety if the canal is rapidly emptied ? For β = 45°, the stability number for various φ values are as given below: φ = 5°, 10°, 15°, 20°, 25° S_n = 0·14, 0·12, 0·10, 0·08, 0·06 15 marks
The soil profile at a building site consists of dense sand up to 3 m depth, normally loaded soft clay from 3 m to 8 m depth and stiff impervious rock below 8 m depth. The ground water table is at 0·60 m depth below ground level. The sand has a density of 18·6 kN/m³ above water table and 19·2 kN/m³ below water table. For the clay, natural water content is 50%, liquid limit is 70% and specific gravity is 2·70. Calculate the probable ultimate settlement resulting from a uniformly distributed surface load of 50 kN/m² applied over an extensive area of the site. 15 marks
The flow of water in a canal varies from 425 l/s to 680 l/s. It is desired to discharge not less than 340 l/s of water and not more than 425 l/s over a 90° V-notch weir into one channel, while the remainder goes over a sharp-crested rectangular weir. Find the length of rectangular weir and maximum head on each weir. Take C_d = 0·58 for both weirs. 20 marks
हिंदी में प्रश्न पढ़ें
(क) एक नहर को एक मृदा, जिसका c = 20 kN/m², φ = 20°, e = 0·80 एवं G = 2·70 है, में खोदा जाना है। पार्श्व ढाल 1 में 1 है। नहर की गहराई 8 m रखनी है। नहर के पूर्ण प्रवाहित होने पर संसजन के सापेक्ष में सुरक्षा गुणक ज्ञात कीजिए। यदि नहर तेजी से खाली की जाए, तो सुरक्षा गुणांक क्या होगा ? β = 45° के लिए, φ के विभिन्न मानों के लिए स्थायित्व अंक निम्नप्रकार हैं : φ = 5°, 10°, 15°, 20°, 25° S_n = 0·14, 0·12, 0·10, 0·08, 0·06 (15 अंक)
(ख) एक निर्माण स्थल पर मृदा परिछेदिका (प्रोफाइल) में सघन रेत 3 m गहराई तक, सामान्य भारित मृदु मृत्तिका 3 m से 8 m गहराई तक एवं 8 m से नीचे दृढ़-अप्रवेश्य चट्टान है। भौम जल स्तर धरातल से 0·6 m नीचे है। रेत का घनत्व जल स्तर के ऊपर 18·6 kN/m³ और जल स्तर के नीचे 19·2 kN/m³ है। मृत्तिका के लिए प्राकृतिक जलांश 50%, द्रव सीमा 70% और विशिष्ट घनत्व 2·70 है। स्थल के एक विस्तृत क्षेत्र पर लगाए गए 50 kN/m² के एकसमान वितरित सतही भार के कारण होने वाले संभावित चरम निषदन की गणना कीजिए। (15 अंक)
(ग) एक नहर में जल प्रवाह 425 l/s से 680 l/s तक परिवर्तित होता है। यह अपेक्षित है कि 90° के V-नोच वियर से एक वाहिका में छोड़े जाने वाले जल का विसर्जन 340 l/s से कम एवं 425 l/s से अधिक न हो, जबकि बचा हुआ जल एक तीक्ष्ण-शिखर-आयताकार वियर के ऊपर से जाता है। आयताकार वियर की लंबाई और प्रत्येक वियर के ऊपर अधिकतम दाबोच्चता ज्ञात कीजिए। दोनों वियर के लिए C_d = 0·58 लीजिए। (20 अंक)
The figure this question refers to, in words
The question paper is a scan and the diagram did not survive as text. This is the figure as read from the original page — every component, value and label — so the question can be worked from the text below.
(a) Table with two rows and six columns. The first row contains the header 'phi (in degrees)' followed by values: 5, 10, 15, 20, 25. The second row contains the header 'SN' followed by values: 0.14, 0.12, 0.10, 0.08, 0.06.
Model answer
Drafted with AI by UPSC Answer Check against this question's marking rubric, to the expected length. UPSC does not publish answers for Mains — this is one way to score well, not an official key. How we build rubrics and answers.
(a) Unit weights from G = 2.70 and e = 0.80:
- γ_sat = (G + e)γ_w/(1 + e) = 3.50 × 9.81/1.80 = 19.08 kN/m³
- γ′ = (G − 1)γ_w/(1 + e) = 1.70 × 9.81/1.80 = 9.27 kN/m³
A 1 in 1 side slope gives β = 45°. Taylor's stability number is S_n = c/(F_c γ H), with H = 8 m.
Canal running full: the slope is submerged, so the effective (submerged) unit weight acts and the full φ = 20° is mobilised. From the table, S_n = 0.08:
F_c = c/(S_n γ′ H) = 20/(0.08 × 9.27 × 8) = 3.37
Canal rapidly emptied: the soil stays saturated, so the driving weight is γ_sat, but the pore pressures have not yet dissipated, so the frictional resistance still corresponds to the submerged weight. Taylor's approach uses a weighted friction angle
φ_w = (γ′/γ_sat)φ = (9.27/19.08) × 20° = 9.7°.
From the given table, S_n = 0.12 at 10° and 0.14 at 5°; interpolating for 9.7°, S_n ≈ 0.121. Then
F_c = 20/(0.121 × 19.08 × 8) = 1.08 (≈ 1.09 if S_n = 0.12 is read directly).
Rapid drawdown therefore cuts the factor of safety from 3.37 to about 1.1, which is why sudden emptying is the critical case for canal and dam slopes.
(b) Only the soft clay (3 m to 8 m) consolidates; the dense sand and the rock are treated as incompressible.
Clay properties (saturated): e₀ = wG = 0.50 × 2.70 = 1.35; γ_sat = (2.70 + 1.35) × 9.81/2.35 = 16.91 kN/m³; γ′ = 7.10 kN/m³.
Initial effective stress at the middle of the clay (5.5 m depth):
- Sand above the water table: 0.6 × 18.6 = 11.16 kPa
- Sand below the water table: 2.4 × (19.2 − 9.81) = 22.54 kPa
- Upper half of the clay: 2.5 × 7.10 = 17.74 kPa
- σ′₀ = 51.4 kPa
Compression index (Skempton, normally consolidated clay): C_c = 0.009(w_L − 10) = 0.009 × 60 = 0.54.
The load is spread over an extensive area, so Δσ = 50 kPa at every depth. For the 5 m clay layer:
S = [C_c H/(1 + e₀)] log₁₀[(σ′₀ + Δσ)/σ′₀] = (0.54 × 5/2.35) × log₁₀(101.4/51.4) = 1.149 × 0.295 = 0.34 m (about 340 mm).
Dividing the clay into sublayers would give a slightly larger value, because the upper part of the layer has lower σ′₀.
(c) Both weirs draw from the same canal, so they work under one common water level; the rectangular weir crest is set above the V-notch vertex so that the V-notch alone takes the first 340 l/s.
V-notch (90°): Q = (8/15)C_d√(2g) tan 45° H^2.5 = 1.370 H^2.5.
- At the minimum canal flow (425 l/s) the V-notch must pass 340 l/s: H₁ = (0.340/1.370)^0.4 = 0.573 m.
- At the maximum canal flow (680 l/s) it must pass at most 425 l/s: H₂ = (0.425/1.370)^0.4 = 0.626 m (maximum head on the V-notch).
Rectangular weir: Q = (2/3)C_d√(2g) L h^1.5 = 1.713 L h^1.5. It carries 425 − 340 = 85 l/s at the minimum and 680 − 425 = 255 l/s at the maximum, and its head rises by the same 0.626 − 0.573 = 0.053 m as the water level:
- 255/85 = [(h + 0.053)/h]^1.5 = 3, so (h + 0.053)/h = 3^(2/3) = 2.080 and h = 0.050 m at minimum flow.
- Maximum head on the rectangular weir = 0.050 + 0.053 = 0.103 m; its crest is 0.573 − 0.050 = 0.523 m above the V-notch vertex.
- Length: 0.255 = 1.713 × L × 0.103^1.5 = 1.713 × L × 0.0331, so L ≈ 4.51 m.
Check at minimum flow: 1.713 × 4.51 × 0.050^1.5 = 0.085 m³/s, and the V-notch takes 0.340 m³/s, totalling 425 l/s.
How this answer will be evaluated
Framework: Geotechnical Engineering Analysis
What earns full marks: All steps shown with correct formulas, units, and final values with checks.
Evaluation rubric
Each sub-part is marked on its own, against the marks and word limit printed on the paper.
- (a) Factor of safety for full and rapidly emptied canal conditions. 15 marks
calculate— given → formula → substitution → result with units → interpretation
Must cover
- γ_sat = (G + e)γ_w/(1 + e) = 19.08 kN/m³ and γ′ = (G − 1)γ_w/(1 + e) = 9.27 kN/m³
- Canal full (submerged slope): S_n = 0.08 for φ = 20° with γ′: F_c = 20/(0.08 × 9.27 × 8) = 3.37
- Rapid drawdown: weighted φ_w = (γ′/γ_sat)φ ≈ 9.7°, S_n from the given table ≈ 0.12 (interpolated 0.121), used with γ_sat
- F_c after drawdown = 20/(0.121 × 19.08 × 8) ≈ 1.08–1.09, far below the full-canal value
Loses marks
- Using dry unit weight for full canal condition
- Ignoring the change in effective stress for rapid emptying
Earns more
- Explicitly state the stability number formula used
- Show calculation of γ_sat and γ_sub
Extra mark
- Sketch of canal cross-section with water levels
- (b) Probable ultimate settlement of the soft clay layer. 15 marks
calculate— given → formula → substitution → result with units → interpretation
Must cover
- Clay: e₀ = wG = 1.35; γ_sat = 16.9 and γ′ = 7.10 kN/m³
- σ′₀ at mid-clay (5.5 m) = 0.6 × 18.6 + 2.4 × 9.39 + 2.5 × 7.10 = 51.4 kPa
- C_c = 0.009(w_L − 10) = 0.54; Δσ = 50 kPa at all depths (extensive load)
- S = C_c H/(1 + e₀) × log[(σ′₀ + Δσ)/σ′₀] = (0.54 × 5/2.35) log(101.4/51.4) ≈ 0.34 m
Loses marks
- Ignoring the water table depth in stress calculation
- Using total stress instead of effective stress
Earns more
- Correct calculation of submerged unit weight for sand
- Explicit statement of compression index assumption
Extra mark
- Sketch of soil profile with water table and stresses
- (c) Length of rectangular weir and maximum head on each weir. 20 marks
calculate— given → formula → substitution → result with units → interpretation
Must cover
- V-notch Q = (8/15)C_d√(2g)H^2.5 = 1.370H^2.5: H = 0.573 m at 340 l/s and 0.626 m at 425 l/s
- Both weirs share the canal water level; the rectangular weir carries 85 l/s at minimum and 255 l/s at maximum flow
- Head ratio [(h + 0.053)/h]^1.5 = 255/85 = 3 gives h = 0.050 m and 0.103 m; crest 0.523 m above the V vertex
- L = 0.255/[(2/3)C_d√(2g) × 0.103^1.5] ≈ 4.5 m; maximum heads 0.626 m (V-notch) and 0.103 m (rectangular)
Loses marks
- Using wrong discharge formula for V-notch weir
- Ignoring the minimum flow constraint for V-notch
Earns more
- Correct conversion of flow rates to m³/s
- Clear separation of V-notch and rectangular weir calculations
Extra mark
- Sketch of weir arrangement with flow directions
What "Solve" is asking you to do
Choose the method, then carry it through to a final answer. Identifying what kind of problem this is and why that method applies is the first thing marked; a correct figure arrived at invisibly earns almost nothing.
Structure that answers it
Given data and what is required → method chosen, with the reason it applies → set-up (equation, circuit, free body, trial balance) → working, step by step → answer with units and any condition of validity
Where marks are lost
Doing the middle steps mentally and writing only the result. In mathematics papers, a further loss comes from giving a decimal where the exact value in surds or fractions was wanted, or from skipping the justification a part explicitly asks for.
Practice this exact question
Write your answer and it is marked point by point against the model answer above — what you covered, what you missed, what you got wrong.
Evaluate my answer →More from Civil Engineering 2024 Paper I
- Q4 (a) A prestressed concrete T-beam having the cross-section of flange 1500 mm wide and 200…
- Q5 (a) A 125 mm diameter vertical cylinder rotates concentrically inside a fixed cylinder of…
- Q6 (a) The resistance force F of a ship is a function of its length L, velocity V, accelerat…
- Q7 (a) A canal is to be excavated through a soil with c = 20 kN/m², φ = 20°, e = 0·80 and G…
- Q8 (a) A retaining wall 8 m high, with a smooth vertical back is pushed against a soil mass…