Civil Engineering 2024 Paper I 50 marks Solve

Paper I — Q2

(a) A cantilever beam ABC as shown in the above figure is having a total span of 2·0 m. The maximum safe allowable bending stress…

(a)

A cantilever beam ABC as shown in the above figure is having a total span of 2·0 m. The maximum safe allowable bending stress is 7500 kN/m² for the material. Find the maximum safe uniformly distributed load which this beam can carry. What will be the maximum shear stress at support A for the obtained safe UDL ? (Neglect the self weight of beam) [Figure: fixed at A; A to B = 1·0 m with section 1-1 = 0·2 m wide × 0·45 m deep; B to C = 1·0 m with section 2-2 = 0·2 m × 0·2 m; tops flush.] 20 marks

(b)

From first principles, derive the expression for determining the depth of neutral axis, for a rectangular reinforced concrete section without compression reinforcement, as per Limit State Method. Use the stress-strain curves for concrete and reinforcing bars shown in the Figs. 1 and 2. 10 marks

(c)

Two angles ISA 100×100×12 mm transmit an ultimate tensile force of 540 kN, acting through the C.G. of angle sections as shown in the Figure. The angles are connected to the gusset plate on either side by welding. Design the lengths l₁ and l₂ of the weld if the size of the fillet weld is 6 mm, fᵤ = 410 MPa, partial safety factor for the weld γₘw = 1·25. Relevant portion of the IS 800 : 2007 is enclosed. [Figure: each angle lies against the 12 mm gusset; the load line (C.G.) is 29·2 mm from the heel edge, where weld l₁ is laid, and weld l₂ is along the toe edge.] 20 marks

हिंदी में प्रश्न पढ़ें

(क) नीचे चित्र में दर्शाई गई प्रास धरन ABC की कुल विस्तृति 2 मीटर है । पदार्थ के लिए अधिकतम सुरक्षित अनुजेय बंकन प्रतिबल 7500 kN/m² है । उस अधिकतम सुरक्षित एक समान वितरित भार को ज्ञात कीजिए जिसे यह धरन वहन कर सकती है । प्राप्त किए गए सुरक्षित एकसमान वितरित भार के लिए आलम्ब A पर अधिकतम अपरूपण प्रतिबल कितना होगा ? (धरन का स्वभार नगण्य है) [चित्र: A पर स्थिर; A से B = 1·0 m, काट 1-1 = 0·2 m चौड़ा × 0·45 m गहरा; B से C = 1·0 m, काट 2-2 = 0·2 m × 0·2 m; ऊपरी सतह एक समतल में।] (20 अंक)

(ख) सीमान्त-अवस्था-अभिकल्पन विधि द्वारा, बिना संपीडन प्रबलन वाले एक आयताकार प्रबलित कंक्रीट काट के लिए, प्रथम सिद्धान्त के द्वारा, उदासीन अक्ष की गहराई के निर्धारण के लिए व्यंजक व्युत्पन्न कीजिए । चित्र 1 एवं 2 में क्रमशः: कंक्रीट एवं प्रबलन छड़ों के लिए दर्शाए गए वक्रों का उपयोग कीजिए । (10 अंक)

(ग) दो लोह कोण ISA 100×100×12 mm, चित्र में दर्शाए अनुसार, लोह कोण के गुरुत्व केन्द्र पर लगने वाले 540 kN के चरम तनन बल को प्रेषित करते हैं। लोह कोण, संगम पट्टिका के दोनों ओर वेल्डिंग द्वारा जोड़े गए हैं। यदि फिलेट वेल्ड का आमाप 6 mm हो तो लम्बाई l₁ एवं l₂ की अभिकल्पना कीजिए। fᵤ = 410 MPa, वेल्डिंग के लिए आंशिक सुरक्षा गुणक γₘw = 1·25। IS 800 : 2007 का संबंधित भाग संलग्न है। [चित्र: प्रत्येक कोण 12 mm संगम पट्टिका से सटा है; भार-रेखा (गुरुत्व केन्द्र) हील किनारे से 29·2 mm पर है, जहाँ वेल्ड l₁ है, तथा वेल्ड l₂ टो किनारे पर है।] (20 अंक)

Q2 of the 2024 UPSC Mains Civil Engineering Paper I, as printed
The question as printed in the 2024 Civil Engineering paper

The figure this question refers to, in words

The question paper is a scan and the diagram did not survive as text. This is the figure as read from the original page — every component, value and label — so the question can be worked from the text below.

(a) Diagram of a stepped cantilever beam ABC fixed at support A on the left and free at tip C on the right. The top surface of the beam is continuous and horizontal. Segment AB has a length of 1.0 m, and segment BC has a length of 1.0 m, making the total span 2.0 m. The beam has two different rectangular cross-sections: Section 1-1 (along segment AB) is a rectangle with a width of 0.2 m and an overall depth of 0.45 m; Section 2-2 (along segment BC) is a rectangle with a width of 0.2 m and an overall depth of 0.2 m. The bottom face of the beam steps up at point B.

(b) Graph titled 'Fig. 1 STRESS-STRAIN CURVE FOR CONCRETE' with STRESS on the vertical axis and STRAIN on the horizontal axis. On the horizontal axis, strain values 0, 0.002, and 0.0035 are marked. Three curves are shown, each starting from the origin (0, 0) as a parabolic curve up to a strain of 0.002, and then continuing horizontally as a straight line up to an ultimate strain of 0.0035 where they terminate vertically: (1) an upper curve with a plateau stress of fck, (2) an intermediate curve with a plateau stress of 0.67 fck, and (3) a lower design curve with a plateau stress of 0.67 fck / gamma_m.

(c) A horizontal angle section labeled 'ISA 100 x 100 x 12 mm' is connected to a 'Gusset plate 12 mm thick' on the left. The top horizontal edge of the angle is welded to the gusset plate over a length labeled 'l_1' (indicated with hatching). The bottom horizontal edge of the angle is welded over a length labeled 'l_2' (indicated with hatching). A horizontal dashed line indicates the center of gravity (C.G.) line of the angle section, positioned at a vertical distance of 29.2 mm from the top edge. A tensile force of 540 kN acts horizontally to the right along this C.G. line.

Model answer

Drafted with AI by UPSC Answer Check against this question's marking rubric, to the expected length. UPSC does not publish answers for Mains — this is one way to score well, not an official key. How we build rubrics and answers.

(a) The cantilever is fixed at A. Segment AB (1.0 m) has section 1-1, 0.20 m wide × 0.45 m deep; segment BC (1.0 m) has section 2-2, 0.20 m × 0.20 m. With a UDL w (kN/m) over the full 2 m, the bending moment at distance x from the free end C is wx²/2. Because the section changes, the maximum stress need not occur at the support, so both the support A and the step B must be checked.

Section moduli (Z = bd²/6):

  • Z₁ = 0.20 × 0.45²/6 = 6.75 × 10⁻³ m³ (AB)
  • Z₂ = 0.20 × 0.20²/6 = 1.333 × 10⁻³ m³ (BC)

Check at the support A: M_A = w × 2²/2 = 2w kN·m, so σ_A = 2w/6.75 × 10⁻³ = 296.3w kN/m². Setting σ_A ≤ 7500 gives w ≤ 25.3 kN/m.

Check at the step B (just inside the smaller section): M_B = w × 1²/2 = 0.5w kN·m, so σ_B = 0.5w/1.333 × 10⁻³ = 375w kN/m². Setting σ_B ≤ 7500 gives w ≤ 20 kN/m.

The smaller section governs: safe UDL w = 20 kN/m. At this load the stress at A is only 2 × 20/6.75 × 10⁻³ = 5926 kN/m², while just right of B it reaches the full 7500 kN/m².

Shear at A: V_A = 20 × 2 = 40 kN. For a rectangle the shear stress is parabolic across the depth, with its maximum at the neutral axis:

τ_max = 1.5V/(bd) = 1.5 × 40/(0.20 × 0.45) = 666.7 kN/m² ≈ 0.67 N/mm² (the average is 444.4 kN/m²).

Diagram: Stepped cantilever bending-stress check and balanced fillet welds for an angle

(b) Notation: b = width, d = effective depth, x_u = depth of the neutral axis, A_st = area of tension steel, f_ck = characteristic cube strength, f_y = characteristic yield stress of steel.

Assumptions (IS 456, cl. 38.1):

  • Plane sections remain plane, so strain varies linearly with depth.
  • The maximum compressive strain in concrete is ε_cu = 0.0035.
  • Concrete in tension is ignored.
  • Concrete follows Fig. 1 with design peak stress 0.67f_ck/γ_m = 0.67f_ck/1.5 = 0.446f_ck: parabolic up to a strain of 0.002, then constant to 0.0035.
  • Steel follows Fig. 2 with design yield stress f_y/γ_s = f_y/1.15 = 0.87f_y.

Concrete compression. Since the strain is linear, 0.002 occurs at depth x_u(1 − 0.002/0.0035) = 3x_u/7 below the top. The stress block therefore has a rectangle of height 3x_u/7 and a parabola of height 4x_u/7 (area = ⅔ × height × peak stress):

C = 0.446f_ck b [3x_u/7 + ⅔ × 4x_u/7] = 0.446f_ck b x_u (17/21) = 0.36 f_ck b x_u.

Taking moments of the two parts about the top fibre gives the line of action of C at 0.42 x_u from the compression face, so the lever arm is z = d − 0.42x_u.

Steel tension and strain compatibility. From the strain diagram, ε_s = 0.0035(d − x_u)/x_u. For the steel to reach its design stress 0.87f_y, IS 456 requires ε_s ≥ 0.87f_y/E_s + 0.002 (the 0.002 allows for the gradual yield of cold-worked bars in Fig. 2). Then T = 0.87 f_y A_st.

Equilibrium C = T:

0.36 f_ck b x_u = 0.87 f_y A_st, so x_u = 0.87 f_y A_st / (0.36 f_ck b), or x_u/d = 0.87 f_y A_st / (0.36 f_ck b d).

Limit on x_u: setting ε_s = 0.87f_y/E_s + 0.002 in the compatibility equation gives x_u,max/d = 0.0035/(0.0055 + 0.87f_y/E_s) = 0.53, 0.48 and 0.46 for Fe 250, Fe 415 and Fe 500. If the computed x_u exceeds x_u,max the section is over-reinforced and the steel does not yield.

Moment of resistance: M_u = 0.87 f_y A_st (d − 0.42 x_u) = 0.36 f_ck b x_u (d − 0.42 x_u).

Diagram: Limit-state analysis of a singly reinforced rectangular section: strain diagram, parabolic-rectangular stress block and forces

(c) Each angle carries P = 540/2 = 270 kN along its C.G., which is 29.2 mm from the heel edge (weld l₁) and 100 − 29.2 = 70.8 mm from the toe edge (weld l₂).

Balancing the welds. The two weld forces F₁ and F₂ must have their resultant on the line of P:

  • F₁ + F₂ = 270 and F₁ × 29.2 = F₂ × 70.8.
  • F₁ = 270 × 70.8/100 = 191.2 kN (heel weld, nearer the C.G.).
  • F₂ = 270 × 29.2/100 = 78.8 kN (toe weld).

Weld strength (IS 800, cl. 10.5.7):

  • f_wd = f_u/(√3 γ_mw) = 410/(√3 × 1.25) = 189.4 N/mm².
  • Throat t_t = 0.7 × 6 = 4.2 mm.
  • Strength per mm = 4.2 × 189.4 = 795 N/mm = 0.795 kN/mm.

Lengths:

  • Effective l₁ = 191.2/0.795 = 240.4 mm; effective l₂ = 78.8/0.795 = 99.1 mm.
  • Overall length = effective length + 2s (cl. 10.5.4): l₁ = 240.4 + 12 = 252.4 mm and l₂ = 99.1 + 12 = 111.1 mm.
  • Provide l₁ = 255 mm and l₂ = 115 mm for each angle.

Checks: both lengths exceed 4s = 24 mm and 40 mm; the 6 mm weld is above the 5 mm minimum for a 12 mm part and below the ¾ × 12 = 9 mm limit at the rounded toe; the welds are shorter than 150t_t = 630 mm, so no long-joint reduction is needed.

How this answer will be evaluated

Framework: Limit State Design (IS 800:2007)

What earns full marks: Complete method with all checks, labelled diagrams, and code references.

Evaluation rubric

Each sub-part is marked on its own, against the marks and word limit printed on the paper.

  1. (a) Maximum safe UDL and maximum shear stress at support A. 20 marks

    calculate— given → formula → substitution → result with units → interpretation

    Must cover

    • Section moduli: Z₁ = 0.2 × 0.45²/6 = 6.75 × 10⁻³ m³ (AB) and Z₂ = 0.2 × 0.2²/6 = 1.333 × 10⁻³ m³ (BC)
    • Moments: M_A = 2w at the support and M_B = 0.5w at the step; both sections must be checked
    • w ≤ 25.3 kN/m from A and w ≤ 20 kN/m from B, so safe UDL = 20 kN/m (governed by the step, not the support)
    • At A: V = 40 kN, τ_max = 1.5V/(bd) = 666.7 kN/m² ≈ 0.67 N/mm², at the neutral axis

    Loses marks

    • Ignoring the stepped section change
    • Using wrong section modulus for critical section
    • Final value without design check

    Earns more

    • Draw SFD and BMD diagrams
    • Show shear stress distribution formula
    • Verify shear stress against allowable limit

    Extra mark

    • Labelled sketch of beam with dimensions
    • Explicit statement of assumptions
  2. (b) Expression for neutral axis depth in singly reinforced RC section. 10 marks

    derive— given → assumptions → stepwise derivation → result → check

    Must cover

    • Assumptions: plane sections remain plane; ε_cu = 0.0035; concrete in tension ignored; design stresses 0.446 f_ck (γ_m = 1.5) and 0.87 f_y (γ_s = 1.15)
    • Stress block: area factor 17/21 gives C = 0.36 f_ck b x_u, acting 0.42 x_u from the compression face
    • Strain compatibility: ε_s = 0.0035(d − x_u)/x_u; steel yields when ε_s ≥ 0.87 f_y/E_s + 0.002, giving x_u,max/d = 0.53, 0.48, 0.46 for Fe 250, 415, 500
    • Equilibrium C = T: x_u/d = 0.87 f_y A_st/(0.36 f_ck b d)

    Loses marks

    • Skipping strain compatibility step
    • Using wrong stress block parameters
    • No final expression for xu/d

    Earns more

    • Reference to IS 456:2000 clause
    • Show stress-strain curve assumptions
    • Define all variables used

    Extra mark

    • Neat labelled stress block diagram
    • Mention of partial safety factors
  3. (c) Design lengths l1 and l2 of fillet welds for ISA angles. 20 marks

    calculate— given → formula → substitution → result with units → interpretation

    Must cover

    • Force per angle 270 kN; C.G. 29.2 mm from the heel edge and 70.8 mm from the toe
    • Moment balance about the C.G. line: F₁ = 191.2 kN (heel weld l₁) and F₂ = 78.8 kN (toe weld l₂)
    • Weld strength: f_wd = f_u/(√3 γ_mw) = 189.4 N/mm²; throat 0.7 × 6 = 4.2 mm; 0.795 kN per mm
    • Effective lengths 240.4 mm and 99.1 mm; add 2s, so provide l₁ ≈ 255 mm and l₂ ≈ 115 mm

    Loses marks

    • Ignoring CG location in force split
    • Using wrong weld strength formula
    • No check on minimum weld length

    Earns more

    • Show free body diagram of angle
    • Cites IS 800 cl. 10.5.7 (f_wd) and 10.5.4 (overall length = effective + 2s); checks weld size (min 5 mm for a 12 mm part; max ¾t at the rounded toe)
    • Verify total weld length adequacy

    Extra mark

    • Labelled sketch of weld arrangement
    • Mention of partial safety factor γmw
What "Solve" is asking you to do

Choose the method, then carry it through to a final answer. Identifying what kind of problem this is and why that method applies is the first thing marked; a correct figure arrived at invisibly earns almost nothing.

Structure that answers it

Given data and what is required → method chosen, with the reason it applies → set-up (equation, circuit, free body, trial balance) → working, step by step → answer with units and any condition of validity

Where marks are lost

Doing the middle steps mentally and writing only the result. In mathematics papers, a further loss comes from giving a decimal where the exact value in surds or fractions was wanted, or from skipping the justification a part explicitly asks for.

All UPSC directive words, compared →

Practice this exact question

Write your answer and it is marked point by point against the model answer above — what you covered, what you missed, what you got wrong.

Evaluate my answer →

More from Civil Engineering 2024 Paper I

Write this answer and get it marked in about 20 seconds

Free account: 5 AI evaluations a month, marked against the rubric above.

Start free

Already have an account? Log in