Paper I — Q6
(a) The discharge Q over a small rectangular weir depends on head H over the weir, the weir height P, gravity g, width of the…
The discharge Q over a small rectangular weir depends on head H over the weir, the weir height P, gravity g, width of the weir L and fluid properties : density ρ, dynamic viscosity μ. Express the relationship between the variables in dimensionless form using Buckingham method. 15 marks
A rectangular channel is 4·0 m wide and carries a discharge of 5·0 m³/s at a depth of 1·0 m. A smooth contraction of the channel width is proposed at a section. Find the smallest contracted width that will not affect the upstream flow conditions. Neglect the energy losses in the transition. 15 marks
In the given diagram, the height of a retaining wall is 5 m with a batter angle 6°. The back face of the retaining wall is supporting a sandy soil, the surface of which is sloping at an angle 12° with the horizontal. Determine the active force per unit length of the retaining wall. Also find the direction and location of the resultant force. The properties of backfill soil are as below : Angle of shearing resistance = 32° Cohesion = 0 Assume angle of wall friction as 50% of angle of shearing resistance. Bulk density = 15·5 kN/m³ 15 marks
What is the effect of earthquake on lateral earth pressure against a retaining wall ? 5 marks
हिंदी में प्रश्न पढ़ें
एक छोटे आयताकार विवर के ऊपर निस्सरण Q, विवर के ऊपर दाबोच्चता H, विवर की ऊँचाई P, गुरुत्व g, विवर की चौड़ाई L और तरल के गुणधर्मों : घनत्व ρ, गतिक श्यानता μ पर निर्भर करता है। बकिंघम विधि का उपयोग करते हुए चरों के बीच सम्बन्ध को विमारहित प्ररूप में व्यक्त कीजिए। 15 अंक
एक आयताकार वाहिका 4·0 m चौड़ी है और 1·0 m की गहराई पर 5·0 m³/s का निस्सरण वहन करती है । एक परिच्छेद पर वाहिका की चौड़ाई का मसृण संकुचन प्रस्तावित है । न्यूनतम संकुचित चौड़ाई ज्ञात कीजिए जिससे प्रतिप्रवाह प्रवाह अवस्थाएँ प्रभावित नहीं हों । संक्रमण में ऊर्जा ह्रास की उपेक्षा कीजिए । 15 अंक
दिए गए आरेख में, 6° के आन्त कोण वाली प्रतिधारक भित्ति की ऊँचाई 5 m है । प्रतिधारक भित्ति का पश्च पृष्ठ रेतीली मृदा को आलम्ब प्रदान कर रहा है जिसकी सतह क्षैतिज से 12° के कोण पर आनत है । प्रतिधारक भित्ति की प्रति एकक लम्बाई पर सक्रिय बल को निर्धारित कीजिए । परिणामी बल की स्थिति और दिशा भी ज्ञात कीजिए । पश्च भराव मृदा के गुणधर्म इस प्रकार हैं : अपरूपण प्रतिरोध का कोण = 32° संसजन = 0 भित्ति के घर्षण कोण को अपरूपण प्रतिरोध के कोण का 50% मान लीजिए । स्थूल घनत्व = 15·5 kN/m³ 15 अंक
एक प्रतिधारक भित्ति के विरुद्ध पार्श्व मृदा दाब पर भूकंप का क्या प्रभाव होता है ? 5 अंक
The figure this question refers to, in words
The question paper is a scan and the diagram did not survive as text. This is the figure as read from the original page — every component, value and label — so the question can be worked from the text below.
(c) A 2D cross-sectional diagram of a retaining wall. The wall is a trapezoidal shape with a vertical height dimensioned as 5 m. The back face of the wall is inclined, making an angle of 6 degrees with the vertical. The front face is vertical. The wall supports a sandy soil backfill. The ground surface of the backfill is sloping upwards away from the wall at an angle of 12 degrees with the horizontal. The base of the wall is horizontal.
Model answer
Drafted with AI by UPSC Answer Check against this question's marking rubric, to the expected length. UPSC does not publish answers for Mains — this is one way to score well, not an official key. How we build rubrics and answers.
(a) Dimensionless form of the weir discharge equation (Buckingham π method)
The discharge over the weir is a function of six independent variables: Q = f(H, P, g, L, ρ, μ), i.e. f₁(Q, H, P, g, L, ρ, μ) = 0
Dimensions of the variables (M, L, T):
- Discharge: Symbol — Q; Dimensions — L³T⁻¹
- Head over the weir: Symbol — H; Dimensions — L
- Height of the weir: Symbol — P; Dimensions — L
- Gravitational acceleration: Symbol — g; Dimensions — LT⁻²
- Width of the weir: Symbol — L; Dimensions — L
- Density: Symbol — ρ; Dimensions — ML⁻³
- Dynamic viscosity: Symbol — μ; Dimensions — ML⁻¹T⁻¹
Number of π terms. There are n = 7 variables and m = 3 fundamental dimensions, so the number of π terms is n − m = 4.
Repeating variables. Choose H (geometry), g (flow/kinematics) and ρ (fluid). Together they contain M, L and T, and none of them can be formed from the others.
π₁ = Q Hᵃ gᵇ ρᶜ M⁰L⁰T⁰ = (L³T⁻¹)(L)ᵃ(LT⁻²)ᵇ(ML⁻³)ᶜ
- M: c = 0
- T: −1 − 2b = 0, so b = −½
- L: 3 + a + b − 3c = 0, so a = −5/2
- π₁ = Q/(H^(5/2) g^(1/2))
π₂ = P Hᵃ gᵇ ρᶜ. Here c = 0 and b = 0, so a = −1: π₂ = P/H
π₃ = L Hᵃ gᵇ ρᶜ. Similarly, π₃ = L/H
π₄ = μ Hᵃ gᵇ ρᶜ
- M: 1 + c = 0, so c = −1
- T: −1 − 2b = 0, so b = −½
- L: −1 + a + b − 3c = 0, so a = −3/2
- π₄ = μ/(ρ H^(3/2) g^(1/2))
Result. Q/(√g H^(5/2)) = φ[P/H, L/H, μ/(ρ H^(3/2) √g)] or Q = √g H^(5/2) · φ(P/H, L/H, μ/(ρ√g H^(3/2)))
Check. Each group is dimensionless. π₄ is the inverse of a Reynolds number built on the velocity √(gH) and length H. It accounts for viscous effects, which matter only at very small heads. Because Q is proportional to L for a wide weir, the result is usually written Q = C_d L √(2g) H^(3/2), with C_d = φ(P/H, Re, …). This is the familiar weir equation.
(b) Smallest contracted width that does not disturb the upstream flow
Upstream section. B₁ = 4.0 m, Q = 5.0 m³/s, y₁ = 1.0 m.
- q₁ = 5/4 = 1.25 m²/s and V₁ = 1.25 m/s
- Froude number: F₁ = V₁/√(gy₁) = 1.25/√(9.81 × 1.0) = 0.399. The approach flow is subcritical.
- Specific energy: E₁ = y₁ + V₁²/2g = 1.0 + 1.25²/(2 × 9.81) = 1.0796 m
Principle. As the channel is narrowed, the discharge per unit width q = Q/B increases. With no energy loss and a horizontal bed, the specific energy stays E₁. For subcritical flow the depth falls in the contraction, and the minimum specific energy needed to pass q, E_min = (3/2)(q²/g)^(1/3), rises. The contraction can be narrowed until E_min just equals the available E₁, at which point critical depth occurs at the throat. Any narrower and E₁ would be too small to pass the flow: the flow would choke, and the upstream depth would rise (afflux). The upstream conditions would then be affected.
Critical condition at the throat.
- y_c = (2/3)E₁ = (2/3) × 1.0796 = 0.7198 m
- q_max = √(g y_c³) = √(9.81 × 0.7198³) = 1.9126 m²/s
- B_min = Q/q_max = 5.0/1.9126 = 2.61 m
Check. At the throat, V_c = 5/(2.614 × 0.7198) = 2.657 m/s and F = 2.657/√(9.81 × 0.7198) = 1.00. The specific energy there is y_c + V_c²/2g = 0.7198 + 0.3598 = 1.0796 m = E₁ ✓.
Result. The width can be reduced smoothly from 4.0 m to about 2.61 m without any change in the upstream depth of 1.0 m. At that width the flow passes through critical depth (0.72 m) at the throat. Any contraction narrower than 2.61 m causes choking and backs water up the channel.
(c)(i) Active thrust on the battered retaining wall (Coulomb's theory)
Data. H = 5 m and γ = 15.5 kN/m³. The back face is inclined at θ = 6° to the vertical: the heel projects under the backfill, so the soil rests on the back face. The backfill surface slopes at β = 12°, φ = 32°, c = 0, and δ = 0.5φ = 16°.
Because the wall face is inclined and wall friction acts, Rankine's theory does not apply. Coulomb's wedge theory is used. With α = 90° − 6° = 84° as the angle of the back face with the horizontal, measured on the soil side:
K_a = sin²(α + φ) / { sin²α · sin(α − δ) · [1 + √( sin(φ + δ) sin(φ − β) / (sin(α − δ) sin(α + β)) )]² }
Substituting the values:
- sin²(116°) = 0.8078
- sin²84° = 0.9891
- sin 68° = 0.9272
- sin 48° = 0.7431
- sin 20° = 0.3420
- sin 96° = 0.9945
The square-root term is √(0.7431 × 0.3420/(0.9272 × 0.9945)) = 0.5250. K_a = 0.8078/[0.9891 × 0.9272 × (1.5250)²] = 0.379
Active force. P_a = ½ K_a γ H² = ½ × 0.379 × 15.5 × 5² = 73.4 kN per metre run
A trial-wedge check gives the same maximum thrust, 73.4 kN/m, on a failure plane at about 56.6° to the horizontal. For comparison, a vertical wall would have K_a = 0.324. The battered back face increases the thrust, because part of the soil load bears on the wall.
Direction. The thrust makes the angle δ = 16° with the normal to the back face, on the side that opposes the downward movement of the wedge. The normal is itself 6° below the horizontal, so P_a acts at 6° + 16° = 22° below the horizontal, pointing towards the wall.
- Horizontal component: P_h = 73.4 cos 22° = 68.0 kN/m
- Vertical component: P_v = 73.4 sin 22° = 27.5 kN/m (downward)
Location. With c = 0, the pressure grows linearly with depth, so the distribution is triangular. The resultant therefore acts at H/3 = 1.67 m above the base, which is 1.68 m measured along the back face.
(c)(ii) Effect of an earthquake on lateral earth pressure
During an earthquake, horizontal and vertical ground accelerations act on the soil wedge as inertia forces. In the pseudo-static (Mononobe–Okabe) method, these are the forces k_hW and k_vW, where k_h and k_v are the seismic coefficients. They tilt the resultant body force by ψ = tan⁻¹[k_h/(1 ± k_v)]. The effects are as follows:
- The critical wedge becomes flatter and larger, so the active pressure increases: P_ae = ½γH²(1 ± k_v)K_ae, with K_ae greater than K_a.
- The passive resistance decreases (K_pe is less than K_p). This reduces the resistance in front of the toe.
- The dynamic increment ΔP = P_ae − P_a acts higher than H/3. IS 1893 places it at mid-height, which raises the overturning moment.
- Saturated backfill can develop excess pore pressure or liquefy, and the wall's own inertia adds to the sliding and overturning forces.
Walls in seismic zones therefore need larger factors of safety against sliding and overturning, and free-draining, well-compacted backfill.
How this answer will be evaluated
Framework: Buckingham Pi Theorem
What earns full marks: Rigorous derivation, correct units, clear diagrams, and precise final values with checks.
Evaluation rubric
Each sub-part is marked on its own, against the marks and word limit printed on the paper.
- (a) Dimensionless relationship for weir discharge using Buckingham method. 15 marks
derive— given → assumptions → stepwise derivation → result → check
Must cover
- Variables Q, H, P, g, L, ρ, μ listed with dimensions; n − m = 7 − 3 = 4 π terms
- Repeating variables H, g, ρ; π₁ = Q/(√g H^{5/2}); π₂ = P/H; π₃ = L/H
- π₄ = μ/(ρ√g H^{3/2}) — inverse Reynolds number based on √(gH) and H
- Final dimensionless form Q/(√g H^{5/2}) = φ(P/H, L/H, μ/(ρ√g H^{3/2}))
Loses marks
- Incorrect number of dimensionless groups
- Missing fundamental dimensions in setup
Earns more
- Correct selection of repeating variables
- Explicit calculation of exponents for each π term
Extra mark
- Identification of specific groups like Reynolds number
- (b) Smallest contracted width for a rectangular channel. 15 marks
calculate— given → formula → substitution → result with units → interpretation
Must cover
- Upstream: q = 1.25 m²/s, V = 1.25 m/s, Fr = 0.399 (subcritical); E₁ = 1.0796 m
- No-loss transition: specific energy constant; choking when E_min = E₁ at the throat
- Critical depth yc = 2E/3 = 0.7198 m; qmax = √(g yc³) = 1.913 m²/s
- B_min = 5.0/1.913 = 2.61 m; any narrower → choking and upstream afflux
Loses marks
- Ignoring specific energy conservation
- Incorrect Froude number calculation
Earns more
- Explicit statement of energy loss assumption
- Verification of flow regime (subcritical/supercritical)
Extra mark
- Sketch of channel contraction profile
- (c)(i) Active force, direction, and location for a retaining wall. 15 marks
calculate— given → formula → substitution → result with units → interpretation
Must cover
- Coulomb wedge theory (inclined wall with wall friction; Rankine not applicable); α = 84°, δ = 16°, β = 12°
- Ka = 0.379 (all terms of the Coulomb formula shown)
- Pa = ½ Ka γ H² = 73.4 kN/m; direction 22° below horizontal (Ph = 68.0, Pv = 27.5 kN/m)
- Resultant at H/3 = 1.67 m above the base (triangular distribution); direction/location drawn
Loses marks
- Ignoring wall friction angle
- Incorrect pressure distribution assumption
Earns more
- Correct handling of sloping backfill angle
- Inclusion of wall friction angle in Ka calculation
Extra mark
- Free body diagram of the soil wedge
- (c)(ii) Effect of earthquake on lateral earth pressure. 5 marks
explain— definition/context → points in order → small example → short close
Must cover
- Earthquake increases active thrust (pseudo-static Mononobe–Okabe: Kae > Ka)
- Passive resistance decreases (Kpe < Kp)
- Dynamic increment ΔP acts higher (IS 1893: mid-height) → larger overturning moment
- Liquefaction/pore pressure and wall inertia; drainage and higher FOS needed
Loses marks
- Vague description without physical mechanism
- Ignoring dynamic vs static pressure difference
Earns more
- Mention of Mononobe-Okabe method
- Distinction between active and passive states
Extra mark
- Sketch of seismic pressure distribution
What "Derive" is asking you to do
Reach the stated expression from a starting relation, justifying every step. The destination is printed in the question, so only the route earns marks, and the assumptions you work under are part of that route.
Structure that answers it
Assumptions and notation defined → starting relation or governing equation → each step with its justification → the required expression → limiting case or boundary check
Where marks are lost
Writing the standard result first and fitting three lines to it, which an examiner reads at a glance. Marks also go on assumptions left unstated — lossless medium, small amplitude, errors independent with zero mean — and on symbols used before they are defined, even when the question says usual notations.
Practice this exact question
Write your answer and it is marked point by point against the model answer above — what you covered, what you missed, what you got wrong.
Evaluate my answer →More from Civil Engineering 2025 Paper I
- Q3 (a) Analyse the continuous beam shown in the figure by slope-deflection method. Draw the…
- Q4 (a) Analyse the frame shown in the figure by the moment distribution method. Draw the Ben…
- Q5 (a) A rigid body having dimensions of 0·6 m wide, 0·9 m high and 1·2 m long weighs 10 kN…
- Q6 (a) The discharge Q over a small rectangular weir depends on head H over the weir, the we…
- Q7 (a) A braced cut 7·0 m deep and 3·0 m wide is proposed in a cohesionless sand deposit. As…
- Q8 (a) The consolidated undrained (CU) tests were performed on the four over-consolidated cl…