Geography 2022 Paper II 50 marks Illustrate

Q8

(a) How do agro-climatic and land capability indicators assist in macro-agricultural regionalisation of India ? Illustrate with an appropriate map. 20 (b) Discuss the geopolitical significance of Quad in the Indo-Pacific realm with reference to marine trade in the region. 15 (c) Evaluate the role of the National Food Security Act, 2013 in providing access of food to the poor in India. 15

हिंदी में प्रश्न पढ़ें

(a) भारत में बृहद्-कृषि प्रादेशीकरण में कृषि-जलवायु तथा भूमि क्षमता के सूचकांक कैसे सहायक होते हैं ? उपयुक्त मानचित्र सहित स्पष्ट कीजिए। 20 (b) हिंद-प्रशांत परिमंडल में क्षेत्र के समुद्री व्यापार के संदर्भ में क्वाड के भू-राजनीतिक महत्व की विवेचना कीजिए। 15 (c) भारत के गरीबों को खाद्य उपलब्ध कराने में राष्ट्रीय खाद्य सुरक्षा अधिनियम, 2013 की भूमिका का मूल्यांकन कीजिए। 15

Evaluate your answer to this question → See all 2022 Geography questions

Directive word: Illustrate

This question asks you to illustrate. The directive word signals the depth of analysis expected, the structure of your answer, and the weight of evidence you must bring.

See our UPSC directive words guide for a full breakdown of how to respond to each command word.

How this answer will be evaluated

Approach

The directive 'illustrate' for part (a) demands visual demonstration alongside explanation, while (b) requires 'discuss' and (c) requires 'evaluate'. Structure: Introduction (2-3 lines) → Part (a) with hand-drawn map (~40% words, 20 marks): explain agro-climatic indicators (rainfall, temperature, growing season) and land capability (soil depth, texture, drainage, slope) linking to 15 agro-climatic zones; Part (b) (~30% words, 15 marks): Quad's maritime geography, chokepoints (Malacca, Lombok), trade routes, counter to BRI; Part (c) (~30% words, 15 marks): NFSA provisions, PDS coverage, challenges (leakages, Aadhaar exclusion), One Nation One Ration Card. Conclusion: integrated view on food security through regional planning and geopolitical stability.

Key points expected

  • Part (a): Agro-climatic indicators (Thornthwaite, Trewartha classifications; rainfall variability; thermal regimes; length of growing period) and land capability indicators (ICAR land capability classes I-VIII; soil depth, texture, drainage, slope, erosion status) with their integration into Planning Commission's 15 agro-climatic zones and 127 sub-zones
  • Part (a): Hand-drawn map showing 15 agro-climatic zones with clear demarcation of Western Himalayan, Eastern Himalayan, Lower Gangetic, Middle Gangetic, Upper Gangetic, Trans-Gangetic, Eastern Plateau, Central Plateau, Western Plateau, Southern Plateau, Eastern Coastal Plains, Western Coastal Plains, Gujarat Plains, Western Dry, and Island zones
  • Part (b): Quad's geopolitical significance in Indo-Pacific: maritime containment strategy, freedom of navigation operations (FONOPs), securing Sea Lines of Communication (SLOCs) especially Malacca Strait (80% of China's oil imports), Lombok-Makassar alternative routes, and countering China's String of Pearls and BRI maritime corridor
  • Part (b): Marine trade dimensions: Indo-Pacific carries 60% global maritime trade; Quad's role in securing container traffic, rare earth supply chains, semiconductor logistics; QUAD Plus and Indo-Pacific Maritime Domain Awareness (IPMDA) initiatives
  • Part (c): NFSA 2013 provisions: legal entitlement to 5kg/person/month subsidized foodgrains at ₹3/2/1 for rice/wheat/coarse cereals; coverage of 75% rural and 50% urban population; maternity benefit of ₹6,000; children 6-14 years mid-day meals
  • Part (c): Critical evaluation: success in reducing extreme hunger (Global Hunger Index improvement), gender-inclusive PDS, One Nation One Ration Card portability; failures in exclusion errors (Aadhaar seeding issues), leakages (40% diversion in some states), inadequate nutritional diversity (cereal-centric), climate shock vulnerability, and fiscal burden on states

Evaluation rubric

DimensionWeightMax marksExcellentAveragePoor
Concept correctness20%10Precise definitions: for (a) correctly distinguishes agro-climatic (climate-based) from land capability (soil-site specific) indicators, cites ICAR land capability classification and Planning Commission methodology; for (b) accurately defines Quad as informal strategic dialogue (US, Japan, Australia, India) not military alliance; for (c) correctly states NFSA entitlements, coverage ratios, and distinguishes from erstwhile Targeted PDSBasic understanding of indicators but conflates agro-climatic with land capability or omits ICAR classification; describes Quad generally without maritime trade specificity; lists NFSA provisions without coverage percentages or legal nuancesConfuses land capability with land use or land cover; treats Quad as NATO-type alliance; misstates NFSA entitlement quantities or coverage; fundamental conceptual errors across parts
Map / diagram20%10Hand-drawn map of India showing all 15 agro-climatic zones with accurate boundaries, proper north arrow, scale, legend; zones correctly labeled (e.g., Western Dry covering Rajasthan-Gujarat arid, Trans-Gangetic in Punjab-Haryana); may include supplementary sketch for Quad showing Indo-Pacific SLOCs with Malacca, Lombok, Sunda straits markedMap drawn with 10-12 zones identifiable, some boundary inaccuracies (e.g., confusing Central and Eastern Plateau), missing scale or legend; or diagram for Quad showing generic Indo-Pacific without specific chokepointsNo map attempted for part (a); or unrecognizable scribble with <8 zones; no spatial representation for Quad maritime geography; map copied from memory with inverted geography
Indian regional examples20%10Rich regional specificity: for (a) cites Western Himalayan zone (J&K, Himachal, Uttarakhand) with temperate fruits, Upper Gangetic (wheat-sugar belt), Eastern Plateau (rice-millets); for (b) mentions India's Andaman & Nicobar strategic location, Chennai-Visakhapatnam container traffic; for (c) contrasts NFSA implementation: Tamil Nadu (universal PDS success) vs Bihar/Jharkhand (Aadhaar exclusion, portability challenges)Some regional examples: mentions Punjab-Green Revolution for (a), Malacca Strait for (b), generic BPL/APL distinction for (c); but lacks specificity in zone characteristics or state-wise NFSA performance variationNo Indian examples; or irrelevant examples (African agriculture, European CAP); generic statements without regional anchoring; conflates Indian zones with US Midwest or other foreign regions
Spatial analysis20%10Demonstrates spatial reasoning: for (a) explains why Western Dry zone has lowest land capability (arid, shallow soils) requiring drought-resistant crops; for (b) analyzes chokepoint vulnerability spatially—Malacca dilemma for China, Quad's island chain strategy; for (c) examines spatial inequity in NFSA—north-east connectivity issues, tribal hilly areas with fair price shop access gapsDescribes spatial patterns without analysis: lists zones north to south, mentions trade routes exist without vulnerability assessment, notes rural-urban coverage difference without explaining spatial barriersNo spatial dimension: treats agriculture as aspatial, ignores geography of maritime trade, discusses NFSA as uniform national policy without regional variation; no use of directional terms or locational relationships
Application / policy20%10Policy integration: for (a) links agro-climatic regionalisation to National Agriculture Policy 2000, PMFBY crop insurance zoning, and climate-smart village programs; for (b) connects Quad to India's SAGAR vision, Indo-Pacific Oceans Initiative (IPOI), and alternative supply chain resilience; for (c) critically assesses NFSA against SDG-2, suggests fortification, cash transfer pilots (Odisha's Kalia), and convergence with MGNREGA for productive assetsMentions policies superficially: notes NFSA exists without critical evaluation, lists Quad meetings without policy outcomes, suggests generic 'better implementation' without specific mechanismsNo policy application: purely descriptive answer, no contemporary relevance, ignores NFSA's legal enforceability, no mention of recent Quad summit outcomes or agricultural policy shifts; outdated or irrelevant policy references

Practice this exact question

Write your answer, then get a detailed evaluation from our AI trained on UPSC's answer-writing standards. Free first evaluation — no signup needed to start.

Evaluate my answer →

More from Geography 2022 Paper II