Q8
(a) How can morphology of Indian towns be described historically? Discuss the major features of the first planned city in India after independence. (20 marks) (b) Health is the outcome of interaction between physical setting, cultural traits and ecological connection. Explain. (15 marks) (c) What are the major regional rapid transit systems developed in India? How are urban problems being addressed by them? (15 marks)
हिंदी में प्रश्न पढ़ें
(a) भारतीय नगरों की आकारिकी का ऐतिहासिक वर्णन किस प्रकार किया जा सकता है? स्वतंत्रता पश्चात् भारत के पहले नियोजित शहर की प्रमुख विशेषताओं की विवेचना कीजिए। (20 अंक) (b) स्वास्थ्य भौतिक स्थिति, सांस्कृतिक लक्षणों व पारिस्थितिक संबंध के बीच परस्परिक क्रिया का परिणाम है। व्याख्या कीजिए। (15 अंक) (c) भारत में विकसित प्रमुख क्षेत्रीय द्रुत पारगमन प्रणालियाँ कौन-सी हैं? उनके द्वारा शहरी समस्याओं को कैसे सम्बोधित किया जा रहा है? (15 अंक)
Directive word: Discuss
This question asks you to discuss. The directive word signals the depth of analysis expected, the structure of your answer, and the weight of evidence you must bring.
See our UPSC directive words guide for a full breakdown of how to respond to each command word.
How this answer will be evaluated
Approach
The directive 'discuss' for part (a) requires critical examination with multiple perspectives, while 'explain' for (b) and (c) demands causal reasoning. Allocate approximately 40% of word budget to part (a) given its 20 marks, with ~30% each to parts (b) and (c). Structure with a brief integrated introduction, three distinct sections for each sub-part with clear sub-headings, and a synthesizing conclusion linking urban planning, health geography, and sustainable transport.
Key points expected
- For (a): Historical morphology phases from ancient (Harappan grid pattern) through medieval (fort-camp towns, temple towns, bazaar streets) to colonial (railway towns, civil lines-cantonment duality) and post-independence planned cities
- For (a): Chandigarh as first planned city—Le Corbusier's sector concept, 7V road hierarchy, Capitol Complex, integration of green belts, and critique of social segregation
- For (b): Physical setting includes topography, climate, water quality, disease vectors; cultural traits encompass dietary practices, medical pluralism, gender norms; ecological connection involves human-environment feedback loops
- For (c): Major RRTS—Delhi-Meerut, Delhi-Panipat, Delhi-Alwar corridors; metro systems (DMRC, Bengaluru, Chennai, Kochi Water Metro); their role in decongestion, air quality improvement, and transit-oriented development
- For (c): Urban problems addressed—reduced vehicular emissions, informal settlement regularization near corridors, last-mile connectivity challenges, and equity concerns in access
Evaluation rubric
| Dimension | Weight | Max marks | Excellent | Average | Poor |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Concept correctness | 20% | 10 | Precisely defines urban morphology (built form, street pattern, land use mix) across historical periods; accurately distinguishes Chandigarh's sector theory from earlier garden city concepts; correctly identifies health geography's three-pillar framework (physical-cultural-ecological); names specific RRTS corridors with correct operational status | Broadly understands town morphology as 'shape of cities' with some historical examples; describes Chandigarh as 'well-planned' without specific features; mentions health determinants without systematic framework; lists metro cities without distinguishing RRTS from metro | Confuses morphology with demography or urbanization; identifies Chandigarh incorrectly as first planned city (ignoring Jaipur/Damodar Valley); treats health purely as medical infrastructure; conflates all rapid transit as 'metro' |
| Map / diagram | 15% | 7.5 | Includes annotated sketch map of Chandigarh showing sector grid, V2-V7 hierarchy, and Capitol Complex location; OR comparative diagrams of pre-colonial (organic) vs. colonial (dual city) morphology; OR schematic of RRTS network with interchange nodes | Mentions 'diagram needed' or draws basic unlabelled circle for Chandigarh; describes morphological patterns textually without visual representation; lists RRTS corridors without network visualization | No diagrams despite clear cartographic potential; or irrelevant diagrams (physical features of India) with no urban content |
| Indian regional examples | 25% | 12.5 | For morphology: contrasts Shahjahanabad's organic maze with Jaipur's grid, railway towns like Jamalpur; for Chandigarh: critiques displacement of villages (Kaimbwala); for health: Kerala's high HDI despite low income vs. Delhi's respiratory disease clusters; for RRTS: specific ridership data from Delhi-Meerut corridor, Kochi Water Metro's flood resilience | Mentions Harappa, Chandigarh, Delhi metro as generic examples without regional specificity; health examples limited to 'cities have pollution'; no sub-national variation acknowledged | Uses non-Indian examples (Haussmann's Paris, London Underground) as primary illustrations; or no concrete examples beyond naming Chandigarh and Delhi |
| Spatial analysis | 20% | 10 | Analyzes how morphology reflects power geometries (colonial segregation, caste-based settlement patterns); explains spatial mismatch between Chandigarh's planned sectors and informal peripheries; demonstrates how RRTS reshapes urban spatial structure through corridor development and land value gradients | Describes spatial patterns without analytical framework; notes Chandigarh is 'divided into sectors' without explaining spatial logic; mentions 'areas become developed' near transit without value capture analysis | Purely descriptive with no spatial reasoning; confuses spatial analysis with chronological narration; ignores scale (local vs. regional) entirely |
| Application / policy | 20% | 10 | Critically evaluates Chandigarh's relevance for contemporary smart cities (lessons on open space, warnings on social engineering); proposes health geography applications for pandemic preparedness (COVID-19 spatial modeling); assesses RRTS against National Urban Transport Policy 2014 and Sustainable Development Goal 11 targets | Mentions 'policy implications' generically; suggests Chandigarh model should be replicated without critique; recommends 'more metros needed' without financing or governance specifics | No policy content; or irrelevant policy discussion (agricural policy, industrial policy) with no urban transport/health/planning connection |
Practice this exact question
Write your answer, then get a detailed evaluation from our AI trained on UPSC's answer-writing standards. Free first evaluation — no signup needed to start.
Evaluate my answer →More from Geography 2024 Paper II
- Q1 On the outline map of India provided to you, mark the location of all of the following. Write in your QCA Booklet the significance of these…
- Q2 (a) Institutional factors are playing a dominant role in controlling the agricultural prosperity in India. Justify with evidences. (20 mark…
- Q3 (a) India has wide-ranging regional disparities in economic development. Explain the patterns, implications and challenges. (20 marks) (b)…
- Q4 (a) Migration is the reflection of regional disparities. What socio-economic and demographic consequences are experienced at the place of o…
- Q5 Answer the following questions in about 150 words each: (a) How are geographic factors influencing the distribution of high annual rainfall…
- Q6 (a) Industrial waste is diversified. Discuss the potentials and challenges associated with it. (20 marks) (b) How is cultural background of…
- Q7 (a) India is playing a very significant role in world affairs. Examine the stands taken by India in important global and regional summits.…
- Q8 (a) How can morphology of Indian towns be described historically? Discuss the major features of the first planned city in India after indep…