Paper I — Q8
(a) Directors of ABC Ltd. wish to diversify. Presently, ABC Ltd. is into selling finished goods from its own godown. ABC Ltd…
Directors of ABC Ltd. wish to diversify. Presently, ABC Ltd. is into selling finished goods from its own godown. ABC Ltd. issued debentures on 07.04.2022 and purchased fixed assets on the very same day. The purchase prices are assumed to have remained stable during the concerned period. Following financial information is available to you. [INCOME STATEMENT and BALANCE SHEET data provided] You are required to calculate the following ratios for the years 2021-22 and 2022-23 : (i) Gross Profit Ratio (ii) Operating expenses to sales ratio (iii) Operating profit ratio (iv) Capital turnover ratio (v) Stock turnover ratio (vi) Net profit to Net worth ratio (vii) Receivables collection period. Ratio relating to capital employed should be based on the capital at the end of the year. Give the reasons for change in the ratios for two years. Assume opening stock of ₹10,000 for the year 2021-22. Ignore taxation. 25 marks
How would you choose among leasing, leveraged buying and hire-purchase ? 6 marks
Under what conditions 'sale and lease back' is a preferable option ? 4 marks
"While managing Marketing Channels issues of Channel Conflicts often occur." In light of this statement, elucidate the types of Channel Conflict. Suggest the mechanisms to manage Channel Conflict. 15 marks
हिंदी में प्रश्न पढ़ें
ए.बी.सी. लिमिटेड के निदेशक विविधता लाना चाहते हैं । वर्तमान में ए.बी.सी. लिमिटेड अपने गोदामों से तैयार माल का विक्रय करती है । ए.बी.सी. लिमिटेड ने 07.04.2022 को डिब्बों का निर्माण किया और उसी दिन अचल संपत्तियों का क्रय किया । संबंधित काल में क्रय मूल्यों का स्थिर रहना माना जा सकता है । आपको निम्नलिखित वित्तीय जानकारी उपलब्ध है । [आय विवरण और तुलन पत्र का विवरण दिया गया है] वर्ष 2021-22 और 2022-23 के लिये आप को निम्नलिखित अनुपातों का आकलन करना है : (i) सकल लाभ अनुपात (ii) परिचालन व्यय से विक्रय अनुपात (iii) परिचालन लाभ अनुपात (iv) पूंजी टर्नओवर अनुपात (v) स्टॉक टर्नओवर अनुपात (vi) शुद्ध लाभ से शुद्ध मूल्य अनुपात (vii) प्राप्ति संग्रहण अवधि । नियुक्त पूंजी से संबंधित अनुपात वर्ष के अंत पर पूंजी पर आधारित होने चाहिये। दोनों वर्षों के अनुपातों के अंतर के कारण बताइये। वर्ष 2021-22 के लिये आरंभिक स्टॉक को ₹10,000 मानिये। कराधान पर ध्यान न दें । (25 अंक)
पट्टे, उत्तोलन खरीद और किराया खरीद के बीच आप किस प्रकार चयन करेंगे ? (6 अंक)
किन परिस्थितियों में बिक्री और पट्टा वापसी एक बेहतर विकल्प है ? (4 अंक)
"विपणन सरनियों के प्रबंधन के समय सरनी संघर्ष के मुद्दे बहुधा उत्पन्न होते हैं।" इस कथन के आलोक में, सरनी संघर्ष के प्रकारों को स्पष्ट कीजिए । सरनी संघर्ष के प्रबंधन हेतु क्रियाविधियों का सुझाव दीजिए । (15 अंक)
Model answer
Written by UPSC Answer Check against this question's marking rubric, to the expected length. UPSC does not publish answers for Mains — this is one way to score well, not an official key.
(a)(i) Gross Profit Ratio = (Gross Profit / Sales) × 100 2021-22: COGS = ₹10,000 + ₹3,00,000 − ₹50,000 = ₹2,60,000. GP = ₹5,00,000 − ₹2,60,000 = ₹2,40,000. Ratio = (₹2,40,000 / ₹5,00,000) × 100 = 48%. 2022-23: COGS = ₹50,000 + ₹4,50,000 − ₹70,000 = ₹4,30,000. GP = ₹8,00,000 − ₹4,30,000 = ₹3,70,000. Ratio = (₹3,70,000 / ₹8,00,000) × 100 = 46.25%.
(a)(ii) Operating Expenses to Sales Ratio = (Operating Expenses / Sales) × 100 2021-22: (₹1,00,000 / ₹5,00,000) × 100 = 20%. 2022-23: (₹1,50,000 / ₹8,00,000) × 100 = 18.75%.
(a)(iii) Operating Profit Ratio = (Operating Profit / Sales) × 100 2021-22: (₹1,40,000 / ₹5,00,000) × 100 = 28%. 2022-23: (₹2,20,000 / ₹8,00,000) × 100 = 27.5%.
(a)(iv) Capital Turnover Ratio = Sales / Capital Employed Capital employed at year-end = Equity + Reserves + Debentures. 2021-22: ₹2,00,000 + ₹1,40,000 + ₹0 = ₹3,40,000. Ratio = ₹5,00,000 / ₹3,40,000 = 1.47 times. 2022-23: ₹2,00,000 + ₹3,50,000 + ₹1,00,000 = ₹6,50,000. Ratio = ₹8,00,000 / ₹6,50,000 = 1.23 times.
(a)(v) Stock Turnover Ratio = COGS / Average Stock 2021-22: Avg stock = (₹10,000 + ₹50,000)/2 = ₹30,000. Ratio = ₹2,60,000 / ₹30,000 = 8.67 times. 2022-23: Avg stock = (₹50,000 + ₹70,000)/2 = ₹60,000. Ratio = ₹4,30,000 / ₹60,000 = 7.17 times.
(a)(vi) Net Profit to Net Worth Ratio = (Net Profit / Net Worth) × 100 2021-22: Net profit = ₹1,40,000; Net worth = ₹2,00,000 + ₹1,40,000 = ₹3,40,000. Ratio = (₹1,40,000 / ₹3,40,000) × 100 = 41.18%. 2022-23: Net profit = ₹2,10,000; Net worth = ₹2,00,000 + ₹3,50,000 = ₹5,50,000. Ratio = (₹2,10,000 / ₹5,50,000) × 100 = 38.18%.
(a)(vii) Receivables Collection Period = (Debtors / Credit Sales) × 365 2021-22: (₹1,00,000 / ₹5,00,000) × 365 = 73 days. 2022-23: (₹2,00,000 / ₹8,00,000) × 365 = 91.25 days.
Reasons for change: GP ratio fell slightly because COGS rose faster than sales. Operating expenses ratio improved due to scale economies. Operating profit ratio fell marginally. Capital turnover declined as capital employed grew much faster than sales after debenture issue and retained earnings. Stock turnover fell, indicating slower inventory movement. Net profit to net worth fell as net worth grew faster than net profit. Receivables period lengthened, showing slower collection.
(b)(i) Choosing among leasing, leveraged buying and hire-purchase Compare after-tax cash flows using discounted cash flow analysis. Key factors:
- Cost: compute effective after-tax cost of each. Leasing rentals are tax-deductible; leveraged buying gives interest and depreciation tax shields; hire-purchase gives depreciation and sometimes interest deduction.
- Ownership: buying/hire-purchase give ownership and residual value; leasing does not.
- Cash flow: leasing requires lower initial outlay; leveraged buying needs down payment; hire-purchase spreads payments.
- Risk: leasing shifts obsolescence risk to lessor; buying bears it.
- Balance sheet: leasing may be off-balance sheet; buying increases debt.
- Flexibility: leasing allows easier upgrade. Choose leasing if cash is tight, obsolescence high, tax rate low. Choose leveraged buying if asset life long, tax rate high, funds available. Choose hire-purchase if ownership desired but immediate full payment not possible.
(b)(ii) Conditions for Sale and Lease Back Preferable when: company needs immediate cash but still needs asset; asset has high market value; company is financially distressed or needs working capital; wants to improve debt-equity and current ratios; tax rate low so depreciation shield less valuable; lease rentals deductible; cost of leasing lower than borrowing; asset is non-core; company wants to avoid debt covenants.
(c) Types of Channel Conflict
- Vertical: between different levels (manufacturer vs wholesaler, wholesaler vs retailer).
- Horizontal: between same level (two retailers, two wholesalers).
- Multichannel: when manufacturer uses multiple competing channels (online vs offline).
- Inter-type: between different intermediary types (franchise vs independent).
- Goal conflict: incompatible objectives.
- Domain conflict: disagreement over territory, customers, functions.
- Perceptual conflict: differing views of market reality.
Mechanisms to Manage Channel Conflict
- Define clear roles, territories and responsibilities.
- Appoint a channel captain.
- Set joint goals and profit-sharing.
- Use arbitration, mediation, and conflict-resolution clauses.
- Differentiate products or brands by channel.
- Use exclusive/selective distribution.
- Communicate frequently and provide training.
- Implement price policies (uniform pricing, MAP).
- Monitor performance and adjust incentives.
- Vertical integration or franchising where needed.
What "Calculate" is asking you to do
Apply the standard formula or schedule to data the question has already supplied — a table of readings, cost records, a balance sheet — and produce the number. The method is rarely in doubt; the marks sit in the named intermediate quantities, each of which has to appear as a labelled line.
Structure that answers it
Data as given → formula or standard treatment, named → substitution → each intermediate, labelled → result with units
Where marks are lost
Omitting an intermediate the marking scheme pays for separately, or rounding at an intermediate line so the final figure drifts. In commerce and accountancy, any figure in a statement that no numbered working note supports is treated as unearned.
How this answer will be evaluated
Approach
Framework: Financial Ratio Analysis (Profitability, Liquidity, Activity). (a) calculate: given > formula > substitution > result with units > interpretation | (b) discuss: intro > 3-4 dimensions > example > balanced close | (c) explain: definition/context > points in order > small example > short close Full marks: Accurate calculations with correct denominators; nuanced comparison of financing; clear distinction of conflict types with actionable solutions.
Key points expected
- Gross Profit Ratio 2022-23 is higher than 2021-22
- Receivables collection period has increased significantly
- Hire-purchase transfers ownership; Leasing does not
- Sale and leaseback is for liquidity, not asset disposal
- Horizontal vs Vertical vs Multi-channel conflict definitions
Evaluation rubric
Each sub-part is marked on its own, against the marks and word limit printed on the paper.
- (a) Compute 7 specific ratios for 2021-22 and 2022-23 and explain the variance.
calculate— given → formula → substitution → result with units → interpretation
Must cover
- Gross Profit Ratio (GP/Sales x 100)
- Operating Profit Ratio (Operating Profit/Sales x 100)
- Capital Turnover Ratio (Sales/Capital Employed)
- Receivables Collection Period (Receivables/Credit Sales x 365)
Loses marks
- Using total sales instead of credit sales for collection period
- Omitting the 'reasons for change' section
- Using average capital instead of closing capital
Earns more
- Correctly identifies Operating Expenses (Warehouse+Transport+Admin+Selling)
- Uses closing capital for Capital Turnover as instructed
- Uses average stock for Stock Turnover (Opening 10k + Closing 60k)/2
- Provides specific reasons for ratio changes (e.g., increased credit sales)
Extra mark
- Identifies the specific driver of increased receivables (credit sales rise)
- (b) Compare financing options (Leasing, Leveraged Buying, Hire-Purchase) and conditions for Sale & Leaseback.
discuss— intro → 3-4 dimensions → example → balanced close
Must cover
- Distinguish ownership transfer in Hire-Purchase vs Leasing
- Define Leveraged Buying (asset-backed financing)
- Conditions for Sale & Leaseback (liquidity needs, asset utilization)
Loses marks
- Treating Hire-Purchase and Leasing as identical
- Ignoring the 'conditions' aspect of sale and leaseback
Earns more
- Mention tax implications of each method
- Discuss 'off-balance sheet' nature of operating leases
- Compare total cost of ownership
Extra mark
- Reference to specific lease accounting standards (e.g., Ind AS 116)
- (c) Elucidate types of channel conflict and suggest management mechanisms.
explain— definition/context → points in order → small example → short close
Must cover
- Horizontal Conflict (competitors in same level)
- Vertical Conflict (manufacturer vs distributor)
- Multi-channel Conflict (direct vs indirect sales)
Loses marks
- Listing types without defining them
- Suggesting mechanisms that do not address the specific conflict type
Earns more
- Mechanisms: Market segmentation, exclusive territories
- Mechanisms: Incentive alignment, joint business planning
- Role of Channel Manager or Arbitration
Extra mark
- Example of a specific brand managing channel conflict (e.g., Apple)
Practice this exact question
Write your answer and it is marked point by point against the model answer above — what you covered, what you missed, what you got wrong.
Evaluate my answer →More from Management 2024 Paper I
- Q5 (a) How can Cost-Volume-Profit (CVP) analysis be used to assess the effect of changes in…
- Q6 (a) A proforma cost sheet of a company provides the following data : | Cost per unit | ₹…
- Q7 (a) Sunder Ltd. is planning an expansion programme which will require ₹30 crores and can…
- Q8 (a) Directors of ABC Ltd. wish to diversify. Presently, ABC Ltd. is into selling finished…