Paper I — Q4
(a) A governor of Hartnell type has each ball of weight 20 N and the lengths of vertical and horizontal arms of the bell crank…
A governor of Hartnell type has each ball of weight 20 N and the lengths of vertical and horizontal arms of the bell crank lever are 125 mm and 65 mm, respectively. The fulcrum of the bell crank lever is at a distance of 100 mm from the axis of rotation. The maximum and minimum radii of rotation of the balls are 125 mm and 80 mm, and the corresponding equilibrium speeds are 325 rpm and 300 rpm, respectively. Find the stiffness of the spring and the equilibrium speed when the radius of rotation is 100 mm. 20 marks
Determine the deflection at a point 1 m from the left-hand end of the beam loaded as shown in the figure below. Use double integration method. The beam is having a constant flexural rigidity of 0·6 MN-m² : 20 marks
Enumerate different types of cams and followers commonly used. State their relative merits and demerits. 10 marks
हिंदी में प्रश्न पढ़ें
एक हार्टनेल गवर्नर के प्रत्येक बॉल का वजन 20 N तथा बेल क्रैंक लीवर की उद्धवर्ध तथा क्षैतिजीय भुजाओं की लम्बाइयाँ क्रमशः 125 mm तथा 65 mm हैं। बेल क्रैंक लीवर का फलक्रम, घूर्णन अक्ष से 100 mm की दूरी पर स्थित है। बॉलों की अधिकतम तथा न्यूनतम घूर्णन त्रिज्याएँ 125 mm तथा 80 mm हैं, एवं संबंधित संतुलन गतियाँ क्रमशः 325 rpm तथा 300 rpm हैं। स्प्रिंग की दृढ़ता तथा उसकी संतुलन गति ज्ञात कीजिए, जब घूर्णन त्रिज्या 100 mm है। (20 अंक)
नीचे चित्र में दर्शाए गए भारित धरन के बाएँ किनारे से 1 m की दूरी पर विचलन ज्ञात कीजिए। दिशा: समाकल विधि का प्रयोग कीजिए। धरन की स्थिर आनमनी दृढ़ता 0·6 MN-m² है : (20 अंक)
सामान्यतः इस्तेमाल होने वाले विभिन्न प्रकार के कैम और फॉलोअर (अनुगामियों) को एक-एक कर बताइए। इनके सापेक्ष गुणों और दोषों को बताइए। (10 अंक)
The figure this question refers to, in words
The question paper is a scan and the diagram did not survive as text. This is the figure as read from the original page — every component, value and label — so the question can be worked from the text below.
(b) A horizontal beam with supports at points A and B. Point A is a pin support located 0.6 m from the left end. Point B is a roller support at the right end. The total length of the beam is 3.0 m. The beam is subjected to the following loads: 1. A downward point load of 15 kN at the left end (0.6 m to the left of A). 2. A uniformly distributed load (UDL) of 20 kN/m acting downwards over the central span between A and the point where the UDL ends. The UDL starts at A and extends 1.2 m to the right. 3. A downward point load of 15 kN located at the end of the UDL (1.2 m to the right of A). The distance from the end of the UDL to support B is 1.2 m. The reaction at A is labeled RA and the reaction at B is labeled RB. The flexural rigidity is given as 0.6 MN-m^2.
Model answer
Drafted with AI by UPSC Answer Check against this question's marking rubric, to the expected length. UPSC does not publish answers for Mains — this is one way to score well, not an official key. How we build rubrics and answers.
(a)
Given: ball weight W = 20 N, so m = 20/9.81 = 2.0387 kg. The ball (vertical) arm is x = 125 mm and the sleeve (horizontal) arm is y = 65 mm. The fulcrum is 100 mm from the spindle axis. At r₁ = 80 mm, N₁ = 300 rpm; at r₂ = 125 mm, N₂ = 325 rpm.
Assumptions (standard): The sleeve weight is not given and is neglected. Arm obliquity and the moment of the ball weight are also neglected. With the fulcrum at 100 mm, the arms are exactly vertical and horizontal at r = 100 mm.
Moment equilibrium about the fulcrum. Each lever carries half of the total spring force S:
F_c · x = (S/2) · y, so S = 2F_c x/y = 2F_c(125/65) = 3.846 F_c
Minimum radius (r₁ = 0.08 m, N₁ = 300 rpm): ω₁ = 2π × 300/60 = 31.416 rad/s F_c1 = mω₁²r₁ = 2.0387 × 31.416² × 0.08 = 160.97 N S₁ = 3.846 × 160.97 = 619.12 N
Maximum radius (r₂ = 0.125 m, N₂ = 325 rpm): ω₂ = 2π × 325/60 = 34.034 rad/s F_c2 = 2.0387 × 34.034² × 0.125 = 295.19 N S₂ = 3.846 × 295.19 = 1135.33 N
Sleeve lift (ball travel × arm ratio): h = (r₂ – r₁)(y/x) = (125 – 80)(65/125) = 45 × 0.52 = 23.4 mm
Spring stiffness: k = (S₂ – S₁)/h = (1135.33 – 619.12)/23.4 = 516.21/23.4 = 22.06 N/mm (22.06 kN/m)
Speed at r = 100 mm. Lift from the lowest position: h' = (100 – 80) × 0.52 = 10.4 mm Spring force: S = S₁ + k h' = 619.12 + 22.06 × 10.4 = 848.55 N F_c = S y/(2x) = 848.55 × 65/(2 × 125) = 220.62 N ω = √(F_c/(m r)) = √(220.62/(2.0387 × 0.1)) = 32.896 rad/s N = 60ω/2π = 314.1 rpm
Interpretation. The spring stiffness is about 22 N/mm. The speed at mid-radius is 314 rpm, which is not the mean of 300 and 325 rpm because F_c varies as ω²r. Including ball weight and obliquity changes k by only about 5 per cent, and it leaves N at r = 100 mm unchanged because the arms are exactly vertical and horizontal there.
(b)
Take x from the left end, in kN and m. The UDL resultant is 24 kN at x = 1.2 m, and EI = 0.6 MN·m² = 600 kN·m².
Reactions. Moments about B: R_A × 2.4 = 15 × 3.0 + 24 × 1.8 + 15 × 1.2 = 45 + 43.2 + 18 = 106.2, so R_A = 44.25 kN. ΣF_y = 0: R_B = 15 + 24 + 15 – 44.25 = 9.75 kN.
Bending moment (Macaulay form, sagging positive). The UDL stops at x = 1.8 m, so it is continued to the right end and cancelled by an equal upward load:
EI d²y/dx² = M = –15x + 44.25⟨x – 0.6⟩ – 10⟨x – 0.6⟩² + 10⟨x – 1.8⟩² – 15⟨x – 1.8⟩
This gives M_A = –9 kN·m, M at 1.8 m = +11.7 kN·m, and M_B = 0 ✓.
First integration (slope): EI dy/dx = –7.5x² + 22.125⟨x – 0.6⟩² – (10/3)⟨x – 0.6⟩³ + (10/3)⟨x – 1.8⟩³ – 7.5⟨x – 1.8⟩² + C₁
Second integration (deflection): EI y = –2.5x³ + 7.375⟨x – 0.6⟩³ – (5/6)⟨x – 0.6⟩⁴ + (5/6)⟨x – 1.8⟩⁴ – 2.5⟨x – 1.8⟩³ + C₁x + C₂
Boundary conditions. At x = 0.6 m, y = 0: –2.5(0.216) + 0.6C₁ + C₂ = 0, so 0.6C₁ + C₂ = 0.54 … (1) At x = 3.0 m, y = 0: –67.5 + 7.375(13.824) – (5/6)(33.1776) + (5/6)(2.0736) – 2.5(1.728) + 3C₁ + C₂ = 0 –67.5 + 101.952 – 27.648 + 1.728 – 4.32 + 3C₁ + C₂ = 0, so 3C₁ + C₂ = –4.212 … (2) Subtracting (1) from (2): 2.4C₁ = –4.752, so C₁ = –1.98 kN·m² and C₂ = 0.54 + 1.188 = 1.728 kN·m³.
Deflection at x = 1 m (only the ⟨x – 0.6⟩ terms are active): EI y = –2.5(1)³ + 7.375(0.4)³ – (5/6)(0.4)⁴ – 1.98(1) + 1.728 = –2.5 + 0.472 – 0.0213 – 1.98 + 1.728 = –2.3013 kN·m³
y = –2.3013/600 = –3.836 × 10⁻³ m
Deflection at 1 m from the left end = 3.84 mm, downward.
At x = 0 the same equation gives EI y = +1.728 kN·m³, so the overhang tip rises by 2.88 mm while the span sags.
(c)
A cam converts rotation into a prescribed follower motion. Cams are classified by shape; followers by contact surface, motion and path.
Types of cams
- Disc / radial (plate) cam: merits — Simple, compact, cheap; the most widely used (IC-engine valves); demerits — Needs a spring or gravity to keep contact; large rise needs a large cam.
- Wedge / translating cam: merits — Simple to make; converts one reciprocation into another; demerits — Limited stroke; reciprocating inertia.
- Cylindrical (drum/barrel) cam: merits — Positive drive through a groove; follower moves parallel to the axis (machine-tool feeds); demerits — Harder to machine; backlash in the groove.
- Spiral, conical, globoidal and spherical cams: merits — Special motions, large oscillation angles (indexing); demerits — Costly, complex manufacture.
Types of followers
- Knife-edge: merits — Follows any profile precisely; demerits — Rapid wear, high contact stress; only for slow, light duty.
- Roller: merits — Rolling contact, low friction and wear; suits high speed (engines, textile machines); demerits — Bulkier; pin wear; cannot follow a concave profile of radius smaller than the roller.
- Flat-faced (mushroom): merits — Compact; takes large side thrust; offsetting it spreads wear; demerits — Cannot follow concave profiles; surface stress and sliding friction.
- Spherical-faced: merits — Avoids edge stress when misaligned (automobile tappets); demerits — More sliding friction than a roller.
By motion, followers are reciprocating or oscillating; by path, radial or offset. The choice balances load, speed, accuracy, wear and cost.
How this answer will be evaluated
What earns full marks: Rigorous derivations, correct units, clear diagrams, and physical interpretation of results.
Evaluation rubric
Each sub-part is marked on its own, against the marks and word limit printed on the paper.
- (a) Hartnell governor: spring stiffness and equilibrium speed at r = 100 mm. 20 marks
calculate— given → formula → substitution → result with units → interpretation
Must cover
- Moment balance about fulcrum: S = 2F_c x/y (sleeve weight neglected, arms ⟂ at mid-position)
- F_c at 80 mm/300 rpm ≈ 161 N and at 125 mm/325 rpm ≈ 295 N; S ≈ 619 N and 1135 N
- Sleeve lift h = (r₂ − r₁)y/x = 23.4 mm; k ≈ 22.06 N/mm
- At r = 100 mm: S ≈ 849 N, F_c ≈ 221 N, N ≈ 314 rpm
Loses marks
- Using S = F_c x/y without the factor 2 when spring acts on both balls
Earns more
- Governor sketch with arms
Extra mark
- Comment on effect of obliquity
- (b) Deflection 1 m from the left end of an overhanging beam by double integration (EI = 0.6 MN·m²). 20 marks
calculate— given → formula → substitution → result with units → interpretation
Must cover
- Reactions R_A = 44.25 kN, R_B = 9.75 kN
- Macaulay moment expression with UDL cut-off
- Boundary conditions y = 0 at x = 0.6 and 3.0 m ⇒ C₁ = −1.98, C₂ = 1.728
- Deflection at 1 m ≈ 3.84 mm downward
Loses marks
- Wrong support positions from the figure
Earns more
- BM check values (−9 kN·m at A, +11.7 kN·m at 1.8 m)
Extra mark
- Overhang tip rises ≈ 2.88 mm
- (c) Types of cams and followers with merits and demerits. 10 marks
enumerate— list the items in order → one line each → no commentary
Must cover
- Cams: disc/radial, wedge/translating, cylindrical, others (spiral, conical, globoidal)
- Followers by contact: knife-edge, roller, flat-faced, spherical
- Followers by motion (reciprocating/oscillating) and path (radial/offset)
- Merits/demerits of each (wear, friction, speed, profile limits)
Loses marks
- Listing without merits/demerits
Earns more
- Applications (IC engines, machine tools)
Extra mark
- Positive-drive cams
What "Solve" is asking you to do
Choose the method, then carry it through to a final answer. Identifying what kind of problem this is and why that method applies is the first thing marked; a correct figure arrived at invisibly earns almost nothing.
Structure that answers it
Given data and what is required → method chosen, with the reason it applies → set-up (equation, circuit, free body, trial balance) → working, step by step → answer with units and any condition of validity
Where marks are lost
Doing the middle steps mentally and writing only the result. In mathematics papers, a further loss comes from giving a decimal where the exact value in surds or fractions was wanted, or from skipping the justification a part explicitly asks for.
Practice this exact question
Write your answer and it is marked point by point against the model answer above — what you covered, what you missed, what you got wrong.
Evaluate my answer →More from Mechanical Engineering 2024 Paper I
- Q1 (a) A rod of length 2 m and weight 450 N rests on ground at one end. The other end is sup…
- Q2 (a) Bodies A, B and C of weights 100 N, 200 N and 150 N, respectively are connected as sh…
- Q3 (a) Show the loading on the beams corresponding to the bending moment diagrams shown belo…
- Q4 (a) A governor of Hartnell type has each ball of weight 20 N and the lengths of vertical…
- Q5 (a) A cutting tool is used to machine alloy steel at cutting speed of 40 m/min. Consideri…
- Q6 (a) A perfectly plastic material having yield strength of 300 MPa is subjected to extrusi…
- Q7 (a) An orthogonal cutting of metal is performed using cutting speed of 120 m/min, tool ra…