Medical Science 2022 Paper II 50 marks Discuss

Paper II — Q8

(a) The ‘End TB Strategy’ is an evolution over the previous strategies to win over tuberculosis. (i) What are the key principles…

(a)
(i)

The ‘End TB Strategy’ is an evolution over the previous strategies to win over tuberculosis. What are the key principles of the ‘End TB Strategy’ ?

(ii)

What are the ‘pillars and components’ of this strategy ?

(iii)

What are the major barriers that have thwarted the progress in the battle against the disease ? 4+10+6=20

(b)
(i)

What has been the impact of HPV vaccination in India ?

(ii)

Discuss the currently available Human Papilloma Virus (HPV) Vaccines and their schedules. 7½+7½=15

(c)
(i)

A 60 year old lady comes to surgery OPD with 6×4 cm lump in her right breast with nipple discharge. What will be the possible findings on clinical examination if this lump were to be malignant ?

(ii)

How will you investigate this patient ?

(iii)

What are the important structures which are to be preserved during modified radical mastectomy ? 6+6+3=15

हिंदी में प्रश्न पढ़ें
(i)

(क) ट्यूबरकुलोसिस पर विजय प्राप्त करने हेतु ‘एंड टी.बी. रणनीति’ पूर्व में अपनाई गई रणनीतियों की तुलना में अधिक उन्नत है। ‘एंड टी.बी. रणनीति’ के मुख्य सिद्धांत क्या हैं ?

(ii)

इस रणनीति के ‘स्तंभ तथा घटक’ क्या हैं ?

(iii)

ऐसे मुख्य अवरोधक कौन से हैं जो रोग पर विजय प्राप्त करने में बाधक बने हुए हैं ? 4+10+6=20

(ख) (i) एच.पी.वी. (HPV) टीकाकरण का भारत पर क्या प्रभाव पड़ा है ?

(ii)

आजकल उपलब्ध ह्यूमन पैपिलोमा वायरस (HPV) टीकों और उनमें से प्रत्येक को लगाए जाने की सारणी की व्याख्या कीजिए। 7½+7½=15

(ग) एक 60-वर्षीय महिला जिसके दाहिने स्तन में 6×4 cm का पिण्ड है और जिसे स्तनाग्र से स्राव आ रहा है, शल्यचिकित्सा बाह्य रोग विभाग में आती है।

(i)

यदि यह पिण्ड दुर्दम है तो रोगलाक्षणिक जांच करने पर क्या-क्या संभावित लक्षण मिलेंगे ?

(ii)

इस रोगी की जांच कैसे की जानी चाहिए ?

(iii)

संशोधित समूल स्तनोच्छेदन करते समय किन-किन रचनाओं को सुरक्षित रखना होता है ? 6+6+3=15

Q8 of the 2022 UPSC Mains Medical Science Paper II, as printed
The question as printed in the 2022 Medical Science paper

Model answer

Drafted with AI by UPSC Answer Check against this question's marking rubric, to the expected length. UPSC does not publish answers for Mains — this is one way to score well, not an official key. How we build rubrics and answers.

(a)(i) Key principles

Adopted by the World Health Assembly in 2014 for 2016-2035, with the vision of a world free of TB. Its four principles:

  1. Government stewardship and accountability, with monitoring and evaluation.
  2. A strong coalition with civil society organisations and communities.
  3. Protection and promotion of human rights, ethics and equity.
  4. Adaptation of the strategy and targets at country level, with global collaboration.

Targets against 2015: 90% fall in incidence and 95% fall in deaths by 2035, and no TB-affected family facing catastrophic costs.

(a)(ii) Pillars and components

Pillar 1, integrated patient-centred care and prevention:

  • Early diagnosis including universal drug-susceptibility testing, systematic screening of contacts and high-risk groups.
  • Treatment of all people with TB, including drug-resistant TB, with patient support.
  • Collaborative TB/HIV activities and management of comorbidities (diabetes, undernutrition).
  • Preventive treatment of high-risk persons and vaccination against TB.

Pillar 2, bold policies and supportive systems:

  • Political commitment with adequate resources for care and prevention.
  • Engagement of communities, civil society and public and private providers.
  • Universal health coverage, regulation for case notification, vital registration, quality and rational use of medicines, infection control.
  • Social protection, poverty alleviation and action on other determinants.

Pillar 3, intensified research and innovation:

  • Discovery, development and rapid uptake of new tools (diagnostics, drugs, vaccines).
  • Operational research to optimise implementation.

India’s National Strategic Plan (Detect, Treat, Prevent, Build) translates these through NAAT-based diagnosis, Ni-kshay notification, private sector engagement, TB preventive therapy, Ni-kshay Poshan Yojana (₹1000 a month) and Ni-kshay Mitra community support.

(a)(iii) Barriers

  1. Missing cases: under-diagnosis and under-notification, especially in the private sector.
  2. Drug resistance: MDR and pre-XDR TB, with gaps in drug-susceptibility testing.
  3. Undernutrition, poverty, overcrowding, smoking, alcohol, diabetes and HIV.
  4. Stigma and delayed care-seeking, high out-of-pocket and catastrophic costs.
  5. Weak primary care, staff shortages, drug stock-outs, loss to follow-up.
  6. Slow uptake of new tools and no effective adult vaccine, disruption by COVID-19.
  7. Funding gaps. WHO’s Global TB Report 2025 shows a 21% fall in India’s incidence from 2015 to 2024, well short of End TB milestones, with India still carrying about a quarter of global cases.

(b)(i) Impact of HPV vaccination in India

  • Burden: India has about 1.27 lakh new cervical cancer cases and about 80,000 deaths a year, around one-fifth of the global burden.
  • Early programmes: Punjab (2016, Bathinda and Mansa), Delhi (2016) and Sikkim (2018, school-based, over 95% coverage) showed that school-based delivery is feasible and acceptable.
  • Evidence: the IARC multicentre trial in India showed one dose gave protection against persistent HPV 16/18 infection similar to two or three doses, which informed WHO’s 2022 single-dose recommendation.
  • Indigenous quadrivalent vaccine Cervavac (Serum Institute, 2022) lowered cost.
  • National campaign: launched on 28 February 2026, offering a single free dose of Gardasil-4 to about 1.15 crore girls aged 14.
  • Impact on cancer incidence will appear only after decades, but countries with high coverage show steep falls in HPV infection, precancer and cervical cancer. Combined with screening, this supports the WHO 90-70-90 elimination targets.

(b)(ii) Vaccines and schedules

  1. Bivalent (Cervarix): HPV 16 and 18. Two doses at 0 and 6 months for 9-14 years, three doses (0, 1, 6 months) from 15 years.
  2. Quadrivalent (Gardasil-4, and Cervavac): HPV 6, 11, 16, 18, also preventing genital warts. Two doses (0, 6-12 months) for 9-14 years, three doses (0, 2, 6 months) from 15 years.
  3. Nonavalent (Gardasil-9): adds 31, 33, 45, 52, 58. Two doses for 9-14 years, three doses (0, 2, 6 months) for older ages.
  • WHO (2022): one or two doses for girls 9-14 (primary target), one or two doses for 15-20 years, two doses for those over 21, three doses for immunocompromised (including HIV).
  • Given intramuscularly, ideally before sexual debut. No boosters needed.

(c)(i) Findings if malignant

  1. Lump: hard, irregular, ill-defined, non-tender, possibly fixed to skin, pectoralis major (fixed on contraction) or chest wall.
  2. Skin: dimpling, puckering, peau d’orange, ulceration, satellite nodules.
  3. Nipple: recent retraction, deviation, eczematous change (Paget disease), blood-stained discharge from a single duct.
  4. Nodes: hard, matted or fixed axillary nodes, supraclavicular nodes.
  5. Distant spread: hepatomegaly, bone tenderness, pleural effusion.

(c)(ii) Investigations

  • Triple assessment: clinical examination, imaging (bilateral mammography and ultrasound of breast and axilla), and image-guided core needle biopsy for histology with ER, PR, HER2 and Ki-67. FNAC of palpable nodes.
  • Nipple discharge cytology, ductography or MRI if needed.
  • Staging (a 6 cm tumour is T3, locally advanced): chest X-ray, ultrasound abdomen or CECT chest-abdomen, bone scan or PET-CT.
  • Baseline: CBC, LFT, RFT, blood sugar, ECG, echocardiography before anthracyclines or trastuzumab. Genetic testing (BRCA) if indicated.

(c)(iii) Structures preserved in MRM

  1. Pectoralis major with its medial and lateral pectoral nerves.
  2. Long thoracic nerve (to serratus anterior, to prevent a winged scapula).
  3. Thoracodorsal nerve and vessels (to latissimus dorsi, for later flap reconstruction).
  4. Axillary vein, and the intercostobrachial nerve and cephalic vein where possible. Pectoralis minor is preserved (Auchincloss), divided (Scanlon) or removed (Patey).
Diagram: Axilla after MRM

How this answer will be evaluated

Framework: Clinical Sequence (Definition > Aetiology > Features > Investigation > Management)

What earns full marks: Comprehensive, accurate, and well-structured answers with specific details and correct terminology.

Evaluation rubric

Each sub-part is marked on its own, against the marks and word limit printed on the paper.

  1. (a)(i) List the key principles of the 'End TB Strategy'. 4 marks

    enumerate— list the items in order → one line each → no commentary

    Must cover

    • Government stewardship and accountability with monitoring
    • Coalition with civil society and communities
    • Human rights, ethics and equity
    • Country-level adaptation with global collaboration

    Loses marks

    • Listing the pillars instead of the principles, or confusing with DOTS
    • Listing symptoms instead of strategic principles

    Earns more

    • Targets: 90% lower incidence and 95% fewer deaths by 2035 vs 2015
    • Reference to WHO 2015-2035 timeframe

    Extra mark

    • Zero catastrophic costs for TB-affected families
  2. (a)(ii) Describe the 'pillars and components' of the strategy. 10 marks

    describe— define → structure or process in order → labelled diagram → significance

    Must cover

    • Pillar 1: Integrated, patient-centred care and prevention
    • Pillar 2: Bold policies and supportive systems
    • Pillar 3: Intensified research and innovation
    • Components such as universal DST, TB/HIV activities, preventive therapy, social protection

    Loses marks

    • Listing the components of the old DOTS strategy as pillars
    • Vague description without specific components

    Earns more

    • India NSP: Detect, Treat, Prevent, Build
    • Ni-kshay Poshan Yojana or Ni-kshay Mitra support

    Extra mark

    • Universal drug-susceptibility testing
  3. (a)(iii) Highlight the major barriers that have thwarted progress. 6 marks

    highlight— name the salient points → one line of substance each → close

    Must cover

    • Drug resistance (MDR/XDR-TB)
    • Health system weaknesses
    • Stigma and discrimination
    • Inadequate financing

    Loses marks

    • Listing only clinical barriers
    • Ignoring social and economic barriers

    Earns more

    • Mention of 'TB-HIV co-infection'
    • Mention of 'poverty and social determinants'

    Extra mark

    • Mention of 'lack of new diagnostics'
  4. (b)(i) Discuss the impact of HPV vaccination in India. 7.5 marks

    discuss— intro → 3-4 dimensions → example → balanced close

    Must cover

    • Burden of cervical cancer in India (about one-fifth of global cases)
    • State programmes (Punjab, Delhi, Sikkim) and the 2026 national campaign
    • IARC India trial evidence for single-dose efficacy
    • Expected fall in HPV infection and cervical cancer, cost-effectiveness

    Loses marks

    • Confusing with 'Mission Indradhanush'
    • Listing only theoretical benefits

    Earns more

    • Mention of 'National HPV Vaccination Programme'
    • Mention of 'school-based vaccination'

    Extra mark

    • Indigenous vaccine Cervavac lowering cost
  5. (b)(ii) Describe the currently available HPV vaccines and their schedules. 7.5 marks

    describe— define → structure or process in order → labelled diagram → significance

    Must cover

    • Bivalent (Cervarix): HPV 16, 18
    • Quadrivalent (Gardasil-4, Cervavac): HPV 6, 11, 16, 18
    • Nonavalent (Gardasil-9): adds 31, 33, 45, 52, 58
    • Schedule: 2 doses at 9-14 years, 3 doses from 15 years, WHO 2022 single-dose option

    Loses marks

    • Confusing vaccine types
    • Incorrect dosing schedules

    Earns more

    • Mention of 'HPV types covered'
    • Three doses for immunocompromised, no boosters

    Extra mark

    • Mention of 'vaccine efficacy'
  6. (c)(i) Describe the possible findings on clinical examination if the lump were malignant. 6 marks

    describe— define → structure or process in order → labelled diagram → significance

    Must cover

    • Hard, irregular, fixed lump
    • Skin changes: dimpling, peau d'orange
    • Nipple changes: retraction, discharge
    • Axillary lymphadenopathy

    Loses marks

    • Listing only benign findings
    • Ignoring skin and nipple changes

    Earns more

    • Mention of 'ulceration'
    • Mention of 'edema'

    Extra mark

    • Mention of 'inflammatory changes'
  7. (c)(ii) Describe how you will investigate this patient. 6 marks

    describe— define → structure or process in order → labelled diagram → significance

    Must cover

    • Imaging: Mammography, Ultrasound
    • Biopsy: image-guided core biopsy with ER, PR, HER2
    • Staging: CXR, CECT or PET-CT, bone scan
    • Lab tests: CBC, LFT, RFT

    Loses marks

    • Listing only imaging
    • Ignoring biopsy

    Earns more

    • Mention of 'MRI breast'
    • Mention of 'PET scan'

    Extra mark

    • Mention of 'genetic testing'
  8. (c)(iii) Enumerate the important structures to be preserved during modified radical mastectomy. 3 marks

    enumerate— list the items in order → one line each → no commentary

    Must cover

    • Pectoralis major with medial and lateral pectoral nerves
    • Long thoracic nerve
    • Thoracodorsal nerve and vessels, axillary vein

    Loses marks

    • Listing axillary lymph nodes as preserved structures
    • Omitting the long thoracic or thoracodorsal nerve

    Earns more

    • Mention of 'nerve preservation'
    • Intercostobrachial nerve and cephalic vein

    Extra mark

    • Mention of 'cosmetic outcome'
What "Discuss" is asking you to do

Lay the issue out from more than one side — how it arose, what is claimed for it, what is held against it, and where it now stands. UPSC attaches discuss to broad topics with several live dimensions, so coverage of the dimensions earns more than the strength of your opinion.

Structure that answers it

Set the issue up → the case as it is made → the case against → the dimension both sides leave out → where the balance now lies

Where marks are lost

Listing facts with no thread between them, or arguing one side throughout and calling it a discussion.

All UPSC directive words, compared →

Practice this exact question

Write your answer and it is marked point by point against the model answer above — what you covered, what you missed, what you got wrong.

Evaluate my answer →

More from Medical Science 2022 Paper II

Write this answer and get it marked in about 20 seconds

Free account: 5 AI evaluations a month, marked against the rubric above.

Start free

Already have an account? Log in