Statistics 2021 Paper I 50 marks Compulsory Solve

Paper I — Q1

(a) A production unit manufacturing surgical masks is concerned about the quality of their masks. A random sample of n masks are…

(a)

A production unit manufacturing surgical masks is concerned about the quality of their masks. A random sample of n masks are inspected to estimate 'p', the probability of manufacturing a defective mask. How large a sample is required so that the estimate of p lies in the range p ± 0.1 with probability 0.95 ? 10 marks

(b)
(i)

An insurance company studies a sample of 150 policy-holders. There are three categories of policies : auto, home and medical. The following results are obtained about the policies held by the policy-holders : 30 have only home insurance

(ii)

10 have only medical insurance

(iii)

98 have auto insurance, but not all three types of insurance

(iv)

27 have medical insurance, but not all three types of insurance

(v)

13 have auto and medical insurance Given that a policy-holder has medical insurance, calculate the probability that he has home insurance. 10 marks

(c)

Let X and Y be independent and identically distributed exponential random variables with mean λ > 0. Define Z = 1, & if X < Y 0, & if X ≥ Y Find E[X|Z = 1] + E[X|Z = 0]. 10 marks

(d)

Let X₁, X₂, ..., Xₙ be a random sample from f(x, θ) = (log(θ))/(θ - 1)θ^x; 0 < x < 1, θ > 1 Is there a function of θ, say g(θ), for which there exists an unbiased estimator whose variance attains the C-R lower bound ? If yes, find it. If not, show why not. 10 marks

(e)
(i)

Let f(x, θ) be the Cauchy pdf f(x, θ) = (θ)/(π) 1/(θ² + x²); -∞ < x < ∞, θ > 0 Show that this family does not have Monotone Likelihood Ratio (MLR).

(ii)

If X is one observation from f(x, θ), show that |X| is sufficient for θ and hence the distribution of |X| does have an MLR. (5+5 marks)

हिंदी में प्रश्न पढ़ें
(a)

सर्जिकल मास्क बनाने वाली एक उत्पादन इकाई की मास्क की गुणवत्ता जाँचने में रुचि है । दोषपूर्ण मास्क बनाने की प्रायिकता, 'p', के आकलन के लिए n मास्क के एक यादृच्छिक प्रतिदर्श का निरीक्षण किया गया । प्रतिदर्श कितना बड़ा होना चाहिए ताकि 0.95 प्रायिकता के साथ p के आकलक का परिसर p ± 0.1 हो ? (10 अंक)

(b)
(i)

एक बीमा कंपनी ने 150 पॉलिसी-धारकों के प्रतिदर्श का अध्ययन किया । पॉलिसी के तीन वर्ग हैं : वाहन, गृह और चिकित्सा । पॉलिसी-धारकों द्वारा गृहीत पॉलिसियों के संबंध में निम्न परिणाम प्राप्त हुए : 30 के पास केवल गृह बीमा है

(ii)

10 के पास केवल चिकित्सा बीमा है

(iii)

98 के पास वाहन बीमा है, लेकिन सभी तीन प्रकार के बीमा नहीं हैं

(iv)

27 के पास चिकित्सा बीमा है, लेकिन सभी तीन प्रकार के बीमा नहीं हैं

(v)

13 के पास वाहन और चिकित्सा बीमा है यदि यह दिया हुआ है कि पॉलिसी-धारक के पास चिकित्सा बीमा है, तो उसके पास गृह बीमा होने की प्रायिकता परिकलित कीजिए । (10 अंक)

(c)

माना X और Y स्वतंत्र और सर्वसम बंटित चर्याताकि यादृच्छिक चर हैं जिनका माध्य λ > 0 है । परिभाषित है Z = 1, & यदि X < Y 0, & यदि X ≥ Y ज्ञात कीजिए : E[X|Z=1] + E[X|Z=0] (10 अंक)

(d)

माना X₁, X₂, ..., Xₙ f(x, θ) = (log(θ))/(θ - 1)θ^x; 0 < x < 1, θ > 1 से लिया गया कोई यादृच्छिक प्रतिदर्श है । क्या θ का एक फलन, माना g(θ), के लिए कोई अनभिनत आकलक है जिसका प्रसरण सी.-आर. (C-R) निम्न परिबंध प्राप्त करता हो ? यदि हाँ, तो ज्ञात कीजिए । यदि नहीं, तो दर्शाइए क्यों नहीं । (10 अंक)

(e)
(i)

माना f(x, θ) = (θ)/(π)1/(θ² + x²); -∞ < x < ∞, θ > 0 कौशी का प्रायिकता घनत्व फलन है । दर्शाइए कि इस बंटन संवर्ग के लिए एकदिष्ट संभाविता अनुपात (एम.एल.आर.) नहीं है ।

(ii)

यदि X, f(x, θ) से लिया गया एक प्रेक्षण है, तो दर्शाइए कि |X|, θ का पर्याप्त प्रतिदर्शज है और इसलिए |X| के बंटन के लिए एम.एल.आर. है । (5+5 अंक)

Q1 of the 2021 UPSC Mains Statistics Paper I, as printed
The question as printed in the 2021 Statistics paper

Model answer

Drafted with AI by UPSC Answer Check against this question's marking rubric, to the expected length. UPSC does not publish answers for Mains — this is one way to score well, not an official key. How we build rubrics and answers.

(a) Sample size for estimating a proportion

Let p be the true proportion of defective masks and p̂ the sample proportion. For large n, by the normal approximation, p̂ ≈ N(p, p(1-p)/n). We need P(p̂ lies in p ± 0.1) = 0.95. Thus P(|p̂ − p| ≤ 0.1) = 0.95, so 0.1 = 1.96 sqrt(p(1-p)/n). Since p is unknown, use the maximum possible value p(1-p) ≤ 1/4. Hence n ≥ (1.96)² (1/4) / (0.1)² = 3.8416 × 0.25 / 0.01 = 96.04. Therefore the required sample size is n = 97 masks. If a prior guess p₀ is available, replace 1/4 by p₀(1-p₀). The normal approximation is valid when np and n(1-p) are at least about 5.

(b) Conditional probability from the policy counts

Let A = auto, H = home, M = medical. Define: a = only auto, x = auto and home only, y = auto and medical only, z = home and medical only, t = all three. Given: h = only home = 30, m = only medical = 10. From (iii): a + x + y = 98. From (iv): m + y + z = 27 ⇒ 10 + y + z = 27 ⇒ y + z = 17. From (v): y + t = 13.

The total number of policy-holders is 150, so a + x + y + z + t + h + m = 150. Using a + x + y = 98 and h + m = 40, 98 + z + t + 40 = 150 ⇒ z + t = 12. Now y + z = 17 and z + t = 12 give y − t = 5, so y = t + 5. But y + t = 13, hence (t + 5) + t = 13 ⇒ 2t = 8 ⇒ t = 4. Then y = 9 and z = 8.

Thus the number having medical insurance is m + y + z + t = 10 + 9 + 8 + 4 = 31. The number having both home and medical insurance is z + t = 8 + 4 = 12. Therefore, P(H | M) = 12/31. (Here (v) is read as all holders of both auto and medical insurance, including those with all three.) Answer: 12/31.

(c) Conditional means given the order of two exponentials

Since X and Y are iid exponential with mean λ, f_X(x) = (1/λ) e^−x/λ, x > 0. Also P(Z = 1) = P(X < Y) = 1/2.

Now E[X | Z = 1] = E[X | X < Y] = [∫₀^∞ ∫_x^∞ x f_X(x) f_Y(y) dy dx] / P(X < Y). The inner integral is f_X(x) P(Y > x) = (1/λ) e^−x/λ e^−x/λ. So the numerator is (1/λ) ∫₀^∞ x e^−2x/λ dx = (1/λ)(λ²/4) = λ/4. Dividing by 1/2 gives E[X | Z = 1] = λ/2.

Similarly, E[X | Z = 0] = [∫₀^∞ ∫₀^x x f_X(x) f_Y(y) dy dx] / P(X ≥ Y). The inner integral is f_X(x) F_X(x) = (1/λ) e^−x/λ(1 − e^−x/λ). Thus the numerator is (1/λ)[∫₀^∞ x e^−x/λ dx − ∫₀^∞ x e^−2x/λ dx] = (1/λ)(λ² − λ²/4) = 3λ/4. Dividing by 1/2 gives E[X | Z = 0] = 3λ/2.

Therefore, E[X | Z = 1] + E[X | Z = 0] = λ/2 + 3λ/2 = 2λ. Answer: 2λ.

(d) Cramér–Rao bound for an exponential family

The density is f(x, θ) = log(θ)/(θ − 1) · θ^x, 0 < x < 1, θ > 1. Write η = log θ. Then f(x, θ) = η/(e^η − 1) e^ηx = exp(ηx − A(η)), where A(η) = log((e^η − 1)/η). Thus this is a one-parameter exponential family with sufficient statistic x. For a sample of size n, the likelihood depends on the data through S = Σ Xᵢ, and the family is regular.

For one observation, E[X] = A′(η) = e^η/(e^η − 1) − 1/η = θ/(θ − 1) − 1/log θ. Also Var(X) = A″(η) = 1/(log θ)² − θ/(θ − 1)².

Take g(θ) = E_θ[X] = θ/(θ − 1) − 1/log θ. Then X̄ = (1/n) Σ Xᵢ is unbiased for g(θ). Its variance is Var(X̄) = Var(X)/n. The derivative is g′(θ) = A″(η)/θ. The Fisher information for n observations is I_n(θ) = n A″(η)/θ². Therefore the Cramér–Rao lower bound for g(θ) is (g′(θ))² / I_n(θ) = (A″(η)²/θ²) / (n A″(η)/θ²) = A″(η)/n = Var(X)/n = Var(X̄). Hence the bound is attained.

Yes. The function is g(θ) = θ/(θ − 1) − 1/log θ, and X̄ is the unbiased estimator attaining the C-R lower bound.

(e) Cauchy family: MLR and sufficiency

(i) For θ₂ > θ₁, the likelihood ratio is R(x) = f(x, θ₂)/f(x, θ₁) = [θ₂/(π(θ₂² + x²))] / [θ₁/(π(θ₁² + x²))] = (θ₂/θ₁) · (θ₁² + x²)/(θ₂² + x²). Then d/dx log R(x) = 2x/(θ₁² + x²) − 2x/(θ₂² + x²) = 2x(θ₂² − θ₁²) / [(θ₁² + x²)(θ₂² + x²)]. For x > 0 this derivative is positive, while for x < 0 it is negative. Hence R(x) decreases on (−∞, 0) and increases on (0, ∞). It is not monotone over the whole real line. Therefore the Cauchy family does not have a Monotone Likelihood Ratio.

(ii) Since f(x, θ) = θ/(π(θ² + x²)) = θ/(π(θ² + |x|²)), the density depends on x only through |x|. By the factorization theorem, f(x, θ) = g(|x|, θ) h(x), with h(x) = 1 and g(t, θ) = θ/(π(θ² + t²)). Hence |X| is sufficient for θ.

Let Y = |X|. For y > 0, f_Y(y, θ) = f_X(y, θ) + f_X(−y, θ) = 2θ/(π(θ² + y²)). For θ₂ > θ₁, the likelihood ratio is r(y) = f_Y(y, θ₂)/f_Y(y, θ₁) = (θ₂/θ₁) · (θ₁² + y²)/(θ₂² + y²). Then d/dy log r(y) = 2y(θ₂² − θ₁²) / [(θ₁² + y²)(θ₂² + y²)] > 0 for y > 0. Thus r(y) is nondecreasing in y. Therefore the distribution of |X| does have a Monotone Likelihood Ratio.

How this answer will be evaluated

Framework: UPSC Statistics Paper 1

What earns full marks: All parts solved with correct methods, clear notation, and full justification.

Evaluation rubric

Each sub-part is marked on its own, against the marks and word limit printed on the paper.

  1. (a) Find the sample size so that the sample proportion lies within p ± 0.1 with probability 0.95, 10 marks 10 marks

    calculate— given → formula → substitution → result with units → interpretation

    Must cover

    • Normal approximation of the sample proportion
    • Use of the worst case p(1-p) ≤ 1/4 and z = 1.96
    • Result n ≥ 96.04, so n = 97

    Loses marks

    • Using a wrong z value
    • Giving 96 instead of rounding up

    Earns more

    • Mention of the validity condition np and n(1-p) at least about 5
    • Use of a prior guess p0 when available

    Extra mark

    • Comment that rounding is upward
  2. (b) Find the probability that a medical policy-holder also has home insurance, from the policy counts, 10 marks 10 marks

    calculate— given → formula → substitution → result with units → interpretation

    Must cover

    • Set up the Venn regions and the equations from the five conditions
    • Solve t = 4, y = 9, z = 8
    • P(H | M) = 12/31

    Loses marks

    • Final answer without the working
    • Dividing by 150 instead of the medical total

    Earns more

    • Cross-check that the total equals 150 and medical equals 27 plus all three
    • Stating the reading of condition (v)

    Extra mark

    • Noting that the other reading of (v) would change the answer
  3. (c) Find E[X | Z = 1] + E[X | Z = 0] for iid exponential X and Y with mean λ, 10 marks 10 marks

    calculate— given → formula → substitution → result with units → interpretation

    Must cover

    • P(X < Y) = 1/2
    • E[X | X < Y] = λ/2 and E[X | X ≥ Y] = 3λ/2
    • Sum = 2λ

    Loses marks

    • Treating the rate as λ instead of the mean
    • Wrong conditional probability

    Earns more

    • Correct integrals or the min-max argument
    • Total expectation check E[X] = λ

    Extra mark

    • Use of the independence of min and event X < Y
  4. (d) Show whether an unbiased estimator attains the C-R bound for some g(θ), and find it, 10 marks 10 marks

    justify— claim → 3-4 reasons → evidence → conclusion

    Must cover

    • Recognise the exponential family with η = log θ and sufficient statistic x
    • g(θ) = θ/(θ-1) - 1/log θ with X̄ unbiased
    • Verify variance of X̄ equals the C-R bound A''(η)/n

    Loses marks

    • Answer without verification of the bound
    • Wrong form of the exponential family

    Earns more

    • Correct A(η), mean and variance
    • Correct derivative g'(θ) = A''(η)/θ and Fisher information

    Extra mark

    • Remark that only this function and its linear transforms attain the bound
  5. (e)(i) (i) Show the Cauchy family lacks MLR, 5 marks 5 marks

    justify— claim → 3-4 reasons → evidence → conclusion

    Must cover

    • Likelihood ratio (θ2/θ1)(θ1²+x²)/(θ2²+x²)
    • Derivative of its log changes sign at x = 0
    • Conclusion: not monotone, so no MLR

    Loses marks

    • Assuming monotonicity without checking
    • Algebra errors in the derivative

    Earns more

    • Correct ordering θ2 > θ1

    Extra mark

    • Describe decreasing then increasing shape
  6. (e)(ii) (ii) Show |X| is sufficient and has MLR, 5 marks 5 marks

    justify— claim → 3-4 reasons → evidence → conclusion

    Must cover

    • Density depends on x only through |x|, so |X| is sufficient by factorisation
    • Density of |X| is 2θ/(π(θ²+y²))
    • Likelihood ratio non-decreasing in y, so MLR holds

    Loses marks

    • Forgetting the factor 2 or the folding of the density
    • Claiming MLR for X itself

    Earns more

    • Correct factorisation with h(x) = 1
    • Sign of the derivative for y > 0

    Extra mark

    • Link to existence of a UMP test for |X|
What "Solve" is asking you to do

Choose the method, then carry it through to a final answer. Identifying what kind of problem this is and why that method applies is the first thing marked; a correct figure arrived at invisibly earns almost nothing.

Structure that answers it

Given data and what is required → method chosen, with the reason it applies → set-up (equation, circuit, free body, trial balance) → working, step by step → answer with units and any condition of validity

Where marks are lost

Doing the middle steps mentally and writing only the result. In mathematics papers, a further loss comes from giving a decimal where the exact value in surds or fractions was wanted, or from skipping the justification a part explicitly asks for.

All UPSC directive words, compared →

Practice this exact question

Write your answer and it is marked point by point against the model answer above — what you covered, what you missed, what you got wrong.

Evaluate my answer →

More from Statistics 2021 Paper I

Write this answer and get it marked in about 20 seconds

Free account: 5 AI evaluations a month, marked against the rubric above.

Start free

Already have an account? Log in