Paper I — Q8
(a) (i) In stratified sampling under optimum allocation, how will you proceed to select units from different strata, if one or…
In stratified sampling under optimum allocation, how will you proceed to select units from different strata, if one or more nᵢ's happens to be greater than Nᵢ (i ≥ 2) ?
A sample survey was conducted in a certain district of Himachal Pradesh. Four strata A, B, C and D of villages were formed according to the acreage of fruit trees as obtained from revenue records. A random sample of villages was selected from each stratum and the number of apple orchards in each selected village was noted. The data are shown below :
| Stratum | Total number of villages (Nᵢ) | Number of villages in sample (nᵢ) | Number of orchards in the selected villages |
|---|---|---|---|
| A (0 – 3 acres) | 275 | 15 | 2, 5, 1, 9, 6, 7, 0, 4, 7, 0, 5, 0, 0, 3, 0 |
| B (3 – 6 acres) | 146 | 10 | 21, 11, 7, 5, 6, 19, 5, 24, 30, 24 |
| C (6 – 15 acres) | 93 | 12 | 3, 10, 4, 11, 38, 11, 4, 46, 4, 18, 1, 39 |
| D (15 acres and above) | 62 | 11 | 30, 42, 20, 38, 29, 22, 31, 28, 66, 14, 15 |
Estimate the number of orchards in the district.
For a second order polynomial model with one predictor variable, derive the least squares normal equations clearly stating the conditions assumed. How will you interpret the parameters in this model ?
Describe why it is recommended to work with predictor variables centred around the mean. Comment on fitted values of the response variable in this case. Prove your claim.
What are split-plot designs ? When do you recommend the use of such designs ? If e₁ and e₂ are the main plot and sub-plot errors respectively, both estimated in units of a single sub-plot, explain why e₁ is expected to be larger than e₂.
हिंदी में प्रश्न पढ़ें
स्तरीत प्रतिचयन में अनुकूलतम नियतन के अंतर्गत यदि एक या अधिक nᵢ, Nᵢ (i ≥ 2) से ज्यादा बड़े हैं, तो आप विभिन्न स्तरों से इकाइयों का चयन किस प्रकार करेंगे ?
हिमाचल प्रदेश के किसी जिले में एक प्रतिदर्श सर्वेक्षण किया गया । राजस्व अभिलेखों द्वारा प्राप्त फलदार पेड़ों के क्षेत्रफल के आधार पर गाँवों के चार स्तर A, B, C और D बनाए गए । प्रत्येक स्तर से गाँवों का एक यादृच्छिक प्रतिदर्श चुना गया और प्रत्येक चुने गए गाँव से सेब के बगीचों की संख्या लिखी गई । आँकड़े नीचे दर्शाए गए हैं :
| स्तर | गाँवों की कुल संख्या (Nᵢ) | प्रतिदर्श में गाँवों की संख्या (nᵢ) | चुने गए गाँवों में बगीचों की संख्या |
|---|---|---|---|
| A (0 – 3 एकड़) | 275 | 15 | 2, 5, 1, 9, 6, 7, 0, 4, 7, 0, 5, 0, 0, 3, 0 |
| B (3 – 6 एकड़) | 146 | 10 | 21, 11, 7, 5, 6, 19, 5, 24, 30, 24 |
| C (6 – 15 एकड़) | 93 | 12 | 3, 10, 4, 11, 38, 11, 4, 46, 4, 18, 1, 39 |
| D (15 एकड़ और अधिक) | 62 | 11 | 30, 42, 20, 38, 29, 22, 31, 28, 66, 14, 15 |
जिले में बगीचों की संख्या का आकलन कीजिए ।
द्विघातीय बहुपद निर्देश जिसमें एक प्रावकता चर है, के लिए माने गए प्रतिबंधों को स्पष्ट लिखते हुए, न्यूनतम वर्ग प्रसामान्य समीकरण व्युत्पन्न कीजिए । आप इस निर्देश में प्राचलों की व्याख्या कैसे करेंगे ?
वर्णन कीजिए कि क्यों माध्य के परितः केंद्रित प्रावकता चरों को संस्तुत किया जाता है । इस विषय में अनुक्रिया चर के आसंगित मानों पर टिप्पणी लिखिए । अपने दावे को सिद्ध कीजिए ।
विभक्त-क्षेत्र अभिकल्पनाएँ क्या हैं ? आप इन अभिकल्पनाओं के उपयोग को कब संस्तुत करेंगे ? यदि e₁ और e₂ क्रमशः मुख्य क्षेत्र और उप-क्षेत्र त्रुटियाँ हैं, दोनों ही एकल उप-क्षेत्र इकाइयों में आकलित हैं, तो स्पष्ट कीजिए कि क्यों e₁, e₂ से अधिक बड़ा अनुमानित होता है ।
The figure this question refers to, in words
The question paper is a scan and the diagram did not survive as text. This is the figure as read from the original page — every component, value and label — so the question can be worked from the text below.
(a) Table with 4 columns and 4 data rows: Columns: Stratum | Total number of villages (N_i) | Number of villages in sample (n_i) | Number of orchards in the selected villages Row 1: A (0 - 3 acres) | 275 | 15 | 2, 5, 1, 9, 6, 7, 0, 4, 7, 0, 5, 0, 0, 3, 0 Row 2: B (3 - 6 acres) | 146 | 10 | 21, 11, 7, 5, 6, 19, 5, 24, 30, 24 Row 3: C (6 - 15 acres) | 93 | 12 | 3, 10, 4, 11, 38, 11, 4, 46, 4, 18, 1, 39 Row 4: D (15 acres and above) | 62 | 11 | 30, 42, 20, 38, 29, 22, 31, 28, 66, 14, 15
Model answer
Drafted with AI by UPSC Answer Check against this question's marking rubric, to the expected length. UPSC does not publish answers for Mains — this is one way to score well, not an official key. How we build rubrics and answers.
(a)(i) Optimum allocation when some nᵢ exceed Nᵢ
Compute the provisional optimum allocation nᵢ = n·NᵢSᵢ/ΣNᵢSᵢ (or nᵢ ∝ NᵢSᵢ/√Cᵢ if costs differ). For every stratum with nᵢ > Nᵢ, take all its units (nᵢ = Nᵢ), since it cannot supply more. Remove these strata, reduce the sample size to n′ = n − ΣNᵢ over the exhausted strata, and recompute the optimum allocation among the remaining strata with the same weights. Repeat until every nᵢ ≤ Nᵢ. Then take a complete enumeration in the exhausted strata and an SRSWOR of the revised size in the others.
(a)(ii) Estimate of the number of orchards
The unbiased estimator is Ŷ_st = ΣNᵢȳᵢ.
- A: Σy = 49, n = 15, contribution 275 × 49/15 = 898.33.
- B: Σy = 152, n = 10, ȳ = 15.2, contribution 146 × 15.2 = 2219.20.
- C: Σy = 189, n = 12, ȳ = 15.75, contribution 93 × 15.75 = 1464.75.
- D: Σy = 335, n = 11, contribution 62 × 335/11 = 1888.18.
Ŷ_st = 898.33 + 2219.20 + 1464.75 + 1888.18 = 6470.47, so the district has about 6470 orchards.
(b)(i) Second-order polynomial model: normal equations
Model: yᵢ = β₀ + β₁xᵢ + β₂xᵢ² + εᵢ. Assume fixed xᵢ (at least three distinct values), E(εᵢ) = 0, Var(εᵢ) = σ², uncorrelated errors, and normality for inference. Minimising Q = Σ(yᵢ − β₀ − β₁xᵢ − β₂xᵢ²)² gives nβ₀ + β₁Σx + β₂Σx² = Σy, β₀Σx + β₁Σx² + β₂Σx³ = Σxy, β₀Σx² + β₁Σx³ + β₂Σx⁴ = Σx²y, that is X′Xβ = X′y with X = [1, x, x²]. Interpretation: β₀ is the mean response at x = 0; β₁ is the slope at x = 0 (dy/dx = β₁ + 2β₂x); β₂ measures curvature, upward if positive and downward if negative; the turning point is x = −β₁/(2β₂).
(b)(ii) Why centre the predictor
With z = x − x̄ the model is y = γ₀ + γ₁z + γ₂z² + ε. Centring is recommended because x and x² are highly correlated when x is far from zero, which makes X′X ill-conditioned and the estimates unstable; centring makes Σz = 0, reduces this multicollinearity, and makes γ₀ the mean response at x̄ and γ₁ the slope at x̄. Fitted values are unchanged. Since 1, z = x − x̄ and z² = x² − 2x̄x + x̄² are linear combinations of 1, x, x² and vice versa, the two design matrices have the same column space, hence the same projection matrix: ŷᵢ = β̂₀ + β̂₁xᵢ + β̂₂xᵢ² = γ̂₀ + γ̂₁zᵢ + γ̂₂zᵢ², with the same residuals and SSE. The coefficients are related by β₂ = γ₂, β₁ = γ₁ − 2γ₂x̄, β₀ = γ₀ − γ₁x̄ + γ₂x̄².
(c) Split-plot designs
In a split-plot design, large main plots receive the levels of one factor, each main plot is divided into sub-plots, and the levels of a second factor are randomised to sub-plots within each main plot. Randomisation therefore occurs at two levels, with a main-plot error e₁ and a sub-plot error e₂.
Use it when one factor needs large units or is hard or costly to change (irrigation, tillage, machine settings), while another can be applied to small units, or when more precision is wanted on the sub-plot factor and the interaction.
e₁ is expected to be larger than e₂ because main plots are larger and more heterogeneous, so the variation among main plots includes soil or unit differences that are partly removed within a main plot, where adjacent sub-plots are more alike. Even when both are expressed per sub-plot, e₁ carries this extra variation, and it usually has fewer degrees of freedom. Main-plot comparisons are therefore less precise, sub-plot comparisons more precise.
How this answer will be evaluated
Framework: Statistics, Paper 1
What earns full marks: Rigorous derivation, correct calculations, clear interpretation of statistical concepts.
Evaluation rubric
Each sub-part is marked on its own, against the marks and word limit printed on the paper.
- (a)(i) (i) Describe optimum allocation in stratified sampling when some nᵢ exceed Nᵢ, 10 marks 10 marks
explain— definition/context → points in order → small example → short close
Must cover
- Provisional allocation nᵢ ∝ NᵢSᵢ (or NᵢSᵢ/√Cᵢ)
- Set nᵢ = Nᵢ for the exhausted strata and reallocate the remaining sample
- Repeat until all nᵢ ≤ Nᵢ
Loses marks
- Leaving nᵢ > Nᵢ
- Not re-computing after removing strata
Earns more
- Cost version of the allocation
- Complete enumeration in exhausted strata and SRSWOR elsewhere
Extra mark
- Remark on how the allocation changes the variance
- (a)(ii) (ii) Estimate the number of orchards in the district from the stratified data, 10 marks 10 marks
calculate— given → formula → substitution → result with units → interpretation
Must cover
- Estimator Σ Nᵢȳᵢ
- Stratum totals 49, 152, 189, 335 and means
- Estimate ≈ 6470 orchards
Loses marks
- Using a simple unweighted mean
- Arithmetic errors in the stratum sums
Earns more
- Correct contributions per stratum: 898.33, 2219.20, 1464.75, 1888.18
Extra mark
- Standard error about 668 from the stratified variance formula
- (b)(i) (i) Derive the normal equations of a second-order polynomial model with assumptions and interpret the parameters, 7 marks 7 marks
derive— given → assumptions → stepwise derivation → result → check
Must cover
- Model and assumptions
- Three normal equations from minimising Q, i.e. X′Xβ = X′y
- Interpretation of β₀, β₁, β₂ and the turning point
Loses marks
- Missing the cubic and quartic sums
- Treating β₁ as the overall slope
Earns more
- At least three distinct x values
- Slope interpretation via dy/dx = β₁ + 2β₂x
Extra mark
- Matrix form with design matrix [1, x, x²]
- (b)(ii) (ii) Explain why centring the predictor is recommended and prove that fitted values are unchanged, 8 marks 8 marks
describe— define → structure or process in order → labelled diagram → significance
Must cover
- Reduction of multicollinearity between x and x²
- Same column space of [1, z, z²] and [1, x, x²]
- Fitted values, residuals and SSE unchanged
Loses marks
- Claiming fitted values change
- Stating the claim without proof
Earns more
- Coefficient relations β₂ = γ₂, β₁ = γ₁ − 2γ₂x̄, β₀ = γ₀ − γ₁x̄ + γ₂x̄²
- Meaning of γ₀ and γ₁ at x̄
Extra mark
- Projection-matrix argument
- (c) What are split-plot designs, when are they recommended, and why is e₁ expected to exceed e₂? 15 marks 15 marks
explain— definition/context → points in order → small example → short close
Must cover
- Two-level layout: main plots and sub-plots with two randomisations
- Situations: hard-to-change or large-unit factor, higher precision for sub-plot factor
- Reason e₁ > e₂: main plots larger and more heterogeneous, sub-plot neighbours more alike
Loses marks
- Confusing with a randomised block design
- No explanation of why e₁ is larger
Earns more
- Naming main-plot and sub-plot errors
- Fewer degrees of freedom for e₁
- Examples such as irrigation by variety
Extra mark
- Consequence: less precise main-plot comparisons
What "Solve" is asking you to do
Choose the method, then carry it through to a final answer. Identifying what kind of problem this is and why that method applies is the first thing marked; a correct figure arrived at invisibly earns almost nothing.
Structure that answers it
Given data and what is required → method chosen, with the reason it applies → set-up (equation, circuit, free body, trial balance) → working, step by step → answer with units and any condition of validity
Where marks are lost
Doing the middle steps mentally and writing only the result. In mathematics papers, a further loss comes from giving a decimal where the exact value in surds or fractions was wanted, or from skipping the justification a part explicitly asks for.
Practice this exact question
Write your answer and it is marked point by point against the model answer above — what you covered, what you missed, what you got wrong.
Evaluate my answer →More from Statistics 2021 Paper I
- Q5 (a) For a simple linear regression model Y = β₀ + β₁Xᵢ + εᵢ, i = 1, ..., n (i) Derive the…
- Q6 (a) For a multiple linear regression model with three covariates X₁, X₂ and X₃, let rᵢⱼ d…
- Q7 (a) (i) What is confounding in factorial experiments ? (ii) A 2^6factorial experiment is…
- Q8 (a) (i) In stratified sampling under optimum allocation, how will you proceed to select u…