Civil Engineering 2022 Paper II 50 marks Critically evaluate

Paper II — Q8

(a) (i) The Gross Command Area for a distributary is 15000 hectares, 80% of which can be irrigated. The intensity of irrigation…

(a)
(i)

The Gross Command Area for a distributary is 15000 hectares, 80% of which can be irrigated. The intensity of irrigation for Rabi season is 60% and that for Kharif season is 30%. If the average duty at the head of the distributary is 2500 ha/cumec for Rabi season and 1500 ha/cumec for Kharif season, determine the discharge required at the head of the distributary. 10 marks

(ii)

Explain Lacey's Regime Theory. Define Initial Regime and Final Regime. Compare the Lacey's Regime Theory with Kennedy's Theory with respect to the design of alluvial channels. 10 marks

(b)

What is leachate? What problems may it create if left unmanaged in a solid waste landfill? Explain how the leachate is managed in sanitary landfills. 15 marks

(c)
(i)

Explain the purpose and procedure for the following stages in EIA process : Screening

(ii)

Scoping

(iii)

Public consultation 15 marks

हिंदी में प्रश्न पढ़ें

प्र.8. (a) (i) एक वितरिका (डिस्ट्रीब्यूटरी) का सकल सेच्य क्षेत्र 15000 हेक्टेयर है, जिसका 80% सिंचित किया जा सकता है। सिंचाई की तीव्रता रबी मौसम के लिए 60% है तथा खरीफ मौसम के लिए 30% है। यदि वितरिका के मुख पर औसत जलाकृति रबी मौसम के लिए 2500 ha/cumec है तथा खरीफ मौसम के लिए 1500 ha/cumec है, तो वितरिका के मुख पर आवश्यक निस्सरण ज्ञात कीजिए। (10 अंक)

(ii)

लेसी के रिजिम सिद्धांत की व्याख्या कीजिए। प्रारंभिक रिजिम तथा अंतिम रिजिम को परिभाषित कीजिए। जलोद वाहिकाओं के अभिकल्पन के संदर्भ में लेसी के रिजिम सिद्धांत तथा कैननेडी के सिद्धांत की तुलना कीजिए। (10 अंक)

(b)

निश्चालक (लीचेट) क्या है? यदि एक ठोस अपशिष्ट भू-भराव में इसे अगर्भीत छोड़ दिया जाए तो यह क्या समस्याएँ पैदा कर सकता है? व्याख्या कीजिए कि स्वच्छ भू-भराव में निश्चालक को कैसे प्रबंधित किया जाता है। (15 अंक)

(c)
(i)

ई.आई.ई. प्रक्रिया में निम्नलिखित अवस्थाओं के उद्देश्य तथा प्रक्रिया की व्याख्या कीजिए : छानना (स्क्रीनिंग)

(ii)

स्कोपिंग

(iii)

सार्वजनिक परामर्श (15 अंक)

Q8 of the 2022 UPSC Mains Civil Engineering Paper II, as printed
The question as printed in the 2022 Civil Engineering paper

Model answer

Drafted with AI by UPSC Answer Check against this question's marking rubric, to the expected length. UPSC does not publish answers for Mains — this is one way to score well, not an official key. How we build rubrics and answers.

(a)(i) Discharge at the head of the distributary

Gross command area = 15,000 ha; culturable command area = 0.8 × 15,000 = 12,000 ha.

Rabi: area irrigated = 60% of 12,000 = 7,200 ha; with a duty of 2,500 ha/cumec the discharge needed is 7,200/2,500 = 2.88 cumec.

Kharif: area irrigated = 30% of 12,000 = 3,600 ha; with a duty of 1,500 ha/cumec the discharge needed is 3,600/1,500 = 2.40 cumec.

The two seasons do not overlap, so the distributary must be designed for the larger of the two: the discharge required at its head is 2.88 cumec, governed by the Rabi crop. The annual intensity of irrigation is 90%, but it is the seasonal demand, not the annual, that fixes the channel capacity.

(a)(ii) Lacey's regime theory, and comparison with Kennedy

Lacey held that a channel in alluvium carrying a constant discharge and a constant sediment load will, if allowed to adjust its width, depth and slope, reach a stable or 'regime' condition in which it neither silts nor scours. The regime dimensions depend on the discharge Q and on a silt factor f = 1.76√mr, mr being the mean particle size in mm. His equations, for Q in cumec and lengths in metres: velocity V = (Qf²/140)^(1/6); wetted perimeter P = 4.75√Q; hydraulic radius R = 2.5V²/f; bed slope S = f^(5/3)/(3340 Q^(1/6)); and the section is taken as a semi-ellipse. Given Q and f, the section and slope follow directly without trial.

Initial regime is the state of a newly made channel that has adjusted its bed slope and depth by silting or scouring but not its width, because the banks are stiffer than the bed; it appears stable but is not in true regime. Final regime is reached when the channel has freely adjusted all three, width, depth and slope, so that the section is in equilibrium with the water and sediment it carries; Lacey's equations apply to this state. A third state, permanent regime, is a lined or rigid-boundary channel that cannot change at all.

Comparison with Kennedy. Kennedy, from observations on the Upper Bari Doab canal, gave one relation, the critical velocity V₀ = 0.55 m y^0.64 (y the depth, m the critical velocity ratio, near 1), at which the silt just stays in suspension; the section had to be found by trial with Kutter's equation, the width or B/D ratio being chosen by the designer, and the slope being assumed. Lacey provides a complete set of equations that fix width, depth and slope uniquely, so no trial and no assumed slope is needed. Kennedy related the silt-supporting eddies to the bed only and used the depth; Lacey held that eddies are generated over the whole wetted perimeter and used the hydraulic radius. Kennedy allowed for the grade of silt only through m and gave no slope equation; Lacey brought the silt grade in explicitly through f, and gave the slope. Kennedy took the trapezoidal section; Lacey the semi-ellipse. Kennedy's method allows the designer freedom in B/D, which can be useful, whereas Lacey's fixed P = 4.75√Q gives wide, shallow channels and is strictly valid only for channels in true regime carrying the same silt as the parent river. Kennedy's is a fair first approximation; Lacey's is the basis of present design.

(b) Leachate in a landfill

Leachate is the liquid that drains from a landfill: rain and moisture that has percolated through the waste, together with the water released by decomposition, carrying with it the soluble and suspended matter it has picked up. It is dark, foul-smelling, high in BOD and COD (tens of thousands of mg/l in a young landfill), ammonia, chlorides, dissolved solids, heavy metals and organic contaminants.

Left unmanaged it seeps from the base of the fill into the ground and pollutes the groundwater over a wide area for decades, making wells unusable; it runs off into streams and lakes, deoxygenating them and killing aquatic life; it accumulates in the fill, raising the water table within the waste, weakening it and making slopes unstable; it produces odour and attracts vectors; it corrodes structures; and its toxic and carcinogenic content enters the food chain. The ammonia and heavy-metal load persists long after the biodegradable fraction has gone.

In a sanitary landfill leachate is managed at four points. Prevention: the site is chosen away from aquifers, the waste is placed in cells and covered daily, and the final cover (compacted clay, geomembrane, drainage layer and topsoil, graded to shed water) keeps rain out; surface run-off from outside is diverted round the site. Containment: the base is lined with a composite liner, a compacted clay layer of low permeability (k < 10⁻⁷ cm/s) overlain by an HDPE geomembrane, often doubled with a leak-detection layer between. Collection: above the liner a drainage layer of gravel with perforated pipes laid to a slope leads the leachate to sumps, from which it is pumped out; the head of leachate over the liner is kept below 30 cm. Treatment: the collected leachate is treated on site (anaerobic followed by aerobic biological treatment, ammonia stripping, chemical precipitation of metals, membrane or activated-carbon polishing) or carried to a sewage treatment works; recirculating part of it through the fill accelerates stabilisation. Monitoring wells up-gradient and down-gradient of the site check that the system is working, and the site is managed for 20–30 years after closure.

Diagram: Sanitary landfill: liner, leachate collection and final cover

(c) Screening, scoping and public consultation in EIA

The EIA process in India is governed by the EIA Notification of 2006 (as amended) under the Environment (Protection) Act, 1986.

Diagram: EIA process flowchart under the EIA Notification 2006

Screening decides whether a project needs an EIA at all, and at what level. Purpose: to keep the effort proportionate, so that only projects likely to have significant impacts go through the full study. Procedure: the proponent submits Form 1 (and Form 1A for building projects) with a pre-feasibility report to the appraisal authority. Projects are categorised by type and size in the schedule to the notification: Category A projects (large thermal plants, major mining, big irrigation, ports, airports and so on) go to the Ministry of Environment, Forest and Climate Change and its Expert Appraisal Committee; Category B go to the State Environment Impact Assessment Authority and its State Expert Appraisal Committee, which screens them further into B1, which require an EIA, and B2, which do not. Location in a notified sensitive area can raise a project's category.

Scoping decides what the EIA must cover. Purpose: to identify, early, the impacts that matter and the alternatives to be studied, so that the study is focused and the terms of reference are known before work begins. Procedure: the EAC or SEAC, on the basis of Form 1, the pre-feasibility report and, if it wishes, a site visit, issues the Terms of Reference for the EIA within 60 days; the ToR list the baseline surveys (air, water, noise, soil, ecology, socio-economics over one season at least), the impacts to be assessed, the alternatives of site and technology to be considered, and the contents of the environment management plan. The EIA report and EMP are then prepared by an accredited consultant against those ToR.

Public consultation puts the draft EIA before the people affected. Purpose: to obtain the concerns of the local community and other stakeholders and to have them answered in the final report, so that the decision is informed and the project is accepted. Procedure: it has two parts, a public hearing at or near the site and written responses from others with an interest. The proponent submits the draft EIA to the State Pollution Control Board, which publishes a notice, makes the draft available and conducts the hearing within 45 days, chaired by the District Magistrate or a representative, with the proceedings video-recorded and the minutes signed; the SPCB forwards the proceedings to the regulatory authority. The proponent must address the material concerns raised in the final EIA and EMP, which then go to the appraisal committee. Certain projects (modernisation without increased pollution, projects within notified industrial estates, defence projects, some irrigation projects) are exempt from public consultation. Appraisal by the committee and the grant of environmental clearance with conditions, followed by post-clearance monitoring, complete the process.

How this answer will be evaluated

What earns full marks: Precise calculations with units; clear definitions of regimes; comprehensive comparison; detailed leachate management; distinct EIA stages with procedures.

Evaluation rubric

Each sub-part is marked on its own, against the marks and word limit printed on the paper.

  1. (a)(i) Determine the discharge required at the head of the distributary for Rabi and Kharif seasons. 10 marks

    calculate— given → formula → substitution → result with units → interpretation

    Must cover

    • Calculate CCA as 80% of 15000 ha (12000 ha)
    • Apply irrigation intensity to CCA for Rabi (60%) and Kharif (30%)
    • Use Duty formula Q = Area / Duty for both seasons
    • Identify the governing discharge (maximum of the two)

    Loses marks

    • Using Gross Command Area instead of CCA
    • Omitting the governing discharge conclusion

    Earns more

    • Explicitly state Rabi and Kharif discharges separately
    • Show units (ha, cumec) in every step
    • Mention that seasons do not overlap

    Extra mark

    • Neat tabular presentation of data
  2. (a)(ii) Explain Lacey's Regime Theory, define regimes, and compare with Kennedy's Theory. 10 marks

    compare— paired headings or point-wise contrast → key differences → significance → conclusion

    Must cover

    • Define Initial Regime (bed slope/depth adjusted, width not)
    • Define Final Regime (width, depth, and slope all adjusted)
    • State Lacey's key equations (e.g., f = 1.76√mr)
    • Compare Lacey vs Kennedy (e.g., Lacey is more comprehensive)

    Loses marks

    • Confusing Initial and Final Regime definitions
    • Failing to mention the comparison aspect

    Earns more

    • Mention Kennedy's silt factor formula
    • Note that Lacey's theory is based on regime conditions
    • Mention limitations of Kennedy's theory

    Extra mark

    • Comparison table of Lacey vs Kennedy parameters
  3. (b) Define leachate, its problems in landfills, and its management in sanitary landfills. 15 marks

    explain— definition/context → points in order → small example → short close

    Must cover

    • Define leachate (liquid percolating through waste)
    • List problems: groundwater contamination, odor, structural instability
    • Explain collection system (perforated pipes, trenches)
    • Explain treatment/disposal (treatment plant, discharge)

    Loses marks

    • Failing to distinguish between open dump and sanitary landfill management
    • Vague description of treatment methods

    Earns more

    • Mention liner systems (clay, HDPE) to prevent leakage
    • Discuss monitoring of leachate quality
    • Mention recirculation of leachate

    Extra mark

    • Sketch of leachate collection system
  4. (c) Explain the purpose and procedure of Screening, Scoping, and Public Consultation in EIA. 15 marks

    explain— definition/context → points in order → small example → short close

    Must cover

    • Screening: Purpose (identify projects needing EIA) and procedure (checklist)
    • Scoping: Purpose (define key issues) and procedure (identify impacts)
    • Public Consultation: Purpose (stakeholder input) and procedure (hearings, notices)
    • Distinguish between the three stages clearly

    Loses marks

    • Confusing Screening with Scoping
    • Failing to explain the 'procedure' for any stage

    Earns more

    • Mention the role of regulatory authority (e.g., MoEFCC in India)
    • Explain the sequence of these stages in the EIA process
    • Mention the outcome of each stage (e.g., Terms of Reference)

    Extra mark

    • Flowchart of the EIA process highlighting these stages
What "Critically evaluate" is asking you to do

Judge how well something has performed against the standard it set for itself — its stated aim, mandate or promise — and commit to a verdict. Name the yardstick before you judge; an unanchored judgement reads as opinion. “Critically” is not a section added at the end: name the yardstick you are judging by — the evidence, the stated objective, a constitutional principle, a rival explanation — and let a verdict close each part of the body. Where the question quotes a claim, that verdict must land on the claim itself, accepted, qualified or rejected, and not on the theme in general.

Structure that answers it

Name the yardstick — stated aim, mandate or benchmark → performance against it → shortfall against it → why the gap exists → verdict

Where marks are lost

Merits in one paragraph, demerits in the next, and a conclusion calling for a balanced and holistic approach. That is a survey with the judgement left out and it holds the answer in the middle band. The opposite error is reading “critically” as permission to attack — and with the odd pairings, critically describe or critically explain, the exposition still carries most of the marks, the judgement being a layer on it rather than a substitute for it.

All UPSC directive words, compared →

Practice this exact question

Write your answer and it is marked point by point against the model answer above — what you covered, what you missed, what you got wrong.

Evaluate my answer →

More from Civil Engineering 2022 Paper II

Write this answer and get it marked in about 20 seconds

Free account: 5 AI evaluations a month, marked against the rubric above.

Start free

Already have an account? Log in