Paper II — Q2
(a) The network for a construction project is shown in the figure given below. The three time estimates for each activity are…
The network for a construction project is shown in the figure given below. The three time estimates for each activity are given along each activity arrow. Determine the: (i) Expected time of completion of each activity, (ii) Earliest expected time for each event, (iii) Latest allowable occurrence time for each event, (take earliest expected time for last event as the scheduled completion time for the project), (iv) Slack for each event, (v) Critical path of the network. Also, give explanation of dotted arrow shown in the network. What is the significance of critical path? All time estimates are in days. [Network (optimistic–most likely–pessimistic, days): 1→2: 4–7–16; 1→3: 4–8–18; 1→4: 6–9–18; 2→6: 3–6–15; 2→3: dotted (dummy); 3→5: 4–7–16; 4→5: 5–9–19; 4→7: 6–10–20; 5→6: 2–6–10; 5→7: 8–11–20; 6→7: 3–5–13.] 20 marks
What are the functions of tie bars in rigid pavements? A cement concrete pavement has a thickness of 30 cm and lane width 3·75 m. Design the tie bars along the longitudinal joints using the data given below: Allowable working stress in steel tie bars = 1250 kg/cm², Allowable tensile stress in deformed bars (Sₛ) = 2000 kg/cm², Allowable bond stress in plain bars (Sᵦ) = 17·5 kg/cm², Allowable bond stress in deformed bars (Sᵦ) = 24·6 kg/cm², Unit weight of concrete pavement (W) = 2400 kg/m³, Maximum value of friction coefficient (f) = 1·35. 15 marks
A high speed B.G. section with a maximum sanctioned speed of 130 kmph is proposed. The section is passing through a transition length with a 2° curve. Calculate the superelevation, maximum permissible speed and transition length for this section at curve. Assume the equilibrium speed as 90 kmph and the booked speed of the goods train to be 60 kmph. Rate of change of Cant or Cant deficiency is 35 mm/sec. Assume any other data suitably. 15 marks
हिंदी में प्रश्न पढ़ें
(क) एक निर्माण परियोजना के लिए जाल (नेटवर्क) नीचे दिए गए चित्र में दर्शाया गया है। प्रत्येक क्रिया के तीन आकलित समय प्रत्येक क्रिया तीर के साथ दिखाए गए हैं। ज्ञात कीजिए: (i) प्रत्येक क्रिया के पूरा होने का अपेक्षित समय, (ii) प्रत्येक घटना के लिए यथाशीघ्र अपेक्षित समय, (iii) प्रत्येक घटना के लिए यथाविलम्बित अनुज्ञेय घटन काल (अंतिम घटना के यथाशीघ्र अपेक्षित समय को परियोजना के लिए निर्धारित समापन समय के रूप में लीजिए), (iv) प्रत्येक घटना का स्लैक, (v) जाल का क्रांतिक पथ। जाल में दर्शाए गए बिंदुकित तीर का स्पष्टीकरण भी दीजिए। क्रांतिक पथ का क्या महत्व है? सभी आकलित समय दिनों में दिए गए हैं। [नेटवर्क (आशावादी–सर्वाधिक संभावित–निराशावादी, दिन): 1→2: 4–7–16; 1→3: 4–8–18; 1→4: 6–9–18; 2→6: 3–6–15; 2→3: बिंदुकित (डमी); 3→5: 4–7–16; 4→5: 5–9–19; 4→7: 6–10–20; 5→6: 2–6–10; 5→7: 8–11–20; 6→7: 3–5–13।] (20 अंक) (ख) दृढ़ कुट्टिमों में बंधन छड़ों (टाई बार) के क्या कार्य हैं? एक सीमेंट कंक्रीट कुट्टिम की मोटाई 30 सेमी और लेन की चौड़ाई 3·75 मीटर है। नीचे दिए गए आंकड़ों का उपयोग करते हुए अनुदैर्ध्य संधियों में बंधन छड़ों की अभिकल्पना कीजिए: स्टील बंधन छड़ों में अनुज्ञेय कार्यकारी प्रतिबल = 1250 किग्रा/सेमी², विकृत छड़ों में अनुज्ञेय तनन प्रतिबल (Sₛ) = 2000 किग्रा/सेमी², सादा छड़ों में अनुज्ञेय बंध प्रतिबल (Sᵦ) = 17·5 किग्रा/सेमी², विकृत छड़ों में अनुज्ञेय बंध प्रतिबल (Sᵦ) = 24·6 किग्रा/सेमी², कंक्रीट कुट्टिम का एकक भार (W) = 2400 किग्रा/मी³, घर्षण गुणांक का अधिकतम मान (f) = 1·35। (15 अंक) (ग) उच्च गति वाली बड़ी लाइन (बी.जी.) का एक भाग है जिसकी अधिकतम अनुमत गति 130 किमी प्रति घंटा प्रस्तावित है। यह भाग 2° वक्र वाली संक्रमण लंबाई से गुजर रहा है। वक्र पर इस भाग के लिए बाह्योत्थान (सुपरएलिवेशन), अधिकतम अनुमत गति और संक्रमण लंबाई की गणना कीजिए। संतुलन गति 90 किमी प्रति घंटा और मालगाड़ी की अभिलेखित गति 60 किमी प्रति घंटा मान लीजिए। कैंट न्यूनता या कैंट के परिवर्तन की दर 35 मिमी प्रति सेकंड है। किन्हीं अन्य आंकड़ों को उपयुक्त रूप से मान लीजिए। (15 अंक)
The figure this question refers to, in words
The question paper is a scan and the diagram did not survive as text. This is the figure as read from the original page — every component, value and label — so the question can be worked from the text below.
(a) An activity-on-arrow (AOA) project network diagram with 7 numbered circular event nodes (1 through 7). Node 1 is the start event on the left, node 7 is the end event on the right. Solid arrows represent activities, each labelled with three time estimates in days in the format optimistic-most likely-pessimistic. The activities are: 1-2 labelled 4-7-16; 1-3 labelled 4-8-18; 1-4 labelled 6-9-18; 2-6 labelled 3-6-15; 3-5 labelled 4-7-16; 4-5 labelled 5-9-19; 4-7 labelled 6-10-20; 5-6 labelled 2-6-10; 5-7 labelled 8-11-20; 6-7 labelled 3-5-13. A dashed (dummy) arrow runs from node 2 to node 3. The question asks for expected activity times, earliest and latest event times, event slacks, the critical path, and the meaning of the dashed arrow.
(b) Table 1 (Photographic Coordinates): Point | Photographic Coordinates x (cm) | y (cm) A | + 5.65 | + 3.75 B | - 3.45 | + 8.55
Table 2 (Closed Traverse ABCD): Line | Length (m) | Latitude | Departure AB | 350.8 | + 303.03 | + 176.6 BC | 408.5 | - 336.7 | + 231.4 CD | 285.4 | - 211.3 | - 191.9
Model answer
Drafted with AI by UPSC Answer Check against this question's marking rubric, to the expected length. UPSC does not publish answers for Mains — this is one way to score well, not an official key. How we build rubrics and answers.
(a) Expected activity time t_e = (t_o + 4t_m + t_p)/6.
(i) Expected times (days):
- 1–2: (4 + 28 + 16)/6 = 8; 1–3: (4 + 32 + 18)/6 = 9; 1–4: (6 + 36 + 18)/6 = 10
- 2–6: (3 + 24 + 15)/6 = 7; 3–5: (4 + 28 + 16)/6 = 8; 4–5: (5 + 36 + 19)/6 = 10
- 4–7: (6 + 40 + 20)/6 = 11; 5–6: (2 + 24 + 10)/6 = 6; 5–7: (8 + 44 + 20)/6 = 12; 6–7: (3 + 20 + 13)/6 = 6
- Dummy 2–3: 0
(ii) Earliest expected times (forward pass, take the maximum at merge events):
E₁ = 0; E₂ = 8; E₃ = max(9, 8 + 0) = 9; E₄ = 10; E₅ = max(9 + 8, 10 + 10) = 20; E₆ = max(8 + 7, 20 + 6) = 26; E₇ = max(10 + 11, 20 + 12, 26 + 6) = 32 days.
(iii) Latest allowable times (backward pass from L₇ = 32, take the minimum at burst events):
L₇ = 32; L₆ = 26; L₅ = min(32 − 12, 26 − 6) = 20; L₄ = min(20 − 10, 32 − 11) = 10; L₃ = 20 − 8 = 12; L₂ = min(26 − 7, 12 − 0) = 12; L₁ = min(12 − 8, 12 − 9, 10 − 10) = 0.
(iv) Event slack S = L − E: S₁ = 0, S₂ = 4, S₃ = 3, S₄ = 0, S₅ = 0, S₆ = 0, S₇ = 0 days.
(v) Critical path: the zero-slack events form two paths of equal length 32 days: 1–4–5–6–7 (10 + 10 + 6 + 6) and 1–4–5–7 (10 + 10 + 12).
Dotted arrow: it is a dummy activity, with zero time and no resources. It shows only a logical dependency: activity 3–5 cannot start until event 2 (completion of 1–2) as well as event 3 has occurred.
Significance of the critical path: it is the longest path through the network, so it fixes the project duration (32 days). Its activities have zero float; any delay on them delays the whole project, so they get the closest monitoring and first call on resources, and crashing to shorten the project must act on them.
(b) Functions of tie bars in rigid pavements:
- They hold adjacent slabs together at longitudinal joints and prevent the joint from opening.
- They prevent lateral separation and differential vertical movement (faulting) between lanes.
- By keeping the joint tight they maintain aggregate interlock and load transfer and keep out water and incompressibles.
- They are not load-transfer dowels; they are thin deformed bars designed to resist the friction force that pulls the slabs apart.
Design (IRC:58 approach): the steel across one metre of joint must resist the friction force from the slab between the joint and the free edge.
- Force per metre = f W h b = 1.35 × 2400 kg/m³ × 0.30 m × 3.75 m = 3645 kg.
- Using deformed bars (S_s = 2000 kg/cm²): A_s = 3645/2000 = 1.82 cm² per metre. With 12 mm bars (A = 1.131 cm²), spacing = 1.131/1.82 = 0.62 m; provide 12 mm bars at 60 cm c/c.
- Length: each half must develop the bar force by bond, so L = d S_s/(2 S_b) = 1.2 × 2000/(2 × 24.6) = 48.8 cm; provide 50 cm long bars (25 cm on each side of the joint).
- If plain bars are used (S_s = 1250 kg/cm², S_b = 17.5 kg/cm²): A_s = 3645/1250 = 2.92 cm²/m, so 12 mm bars at 38 cm c/c, and L = 1.2 × 1250/(2 × 17.5) = 42.9 cm, say 45 cm.
(c) For B.G. (G = 1750 mm), R = 1750/D = 1750/2 = 875 m.
Superelevation (cant) for the equilibrium speed 90 kmph:
C_a = GV²/(127R) = 1750 × 90²/(127 × 875) = 127.6 mm (below the 165 mm maximum).
Check for the slow goods train (60 kmph): its equilibrium cant = 1750 × 60²/(127 × 875) = 56.7 mm, so cant excess = 127.6 − 56.7 = 70.9 mm < 75 mm (permissible).
Maximum permissible speed, assuming a cant deficiency C_d = 100 mm (allowed on high-speed B.G. routes):
V_max = 0.27√[(C_a + C_d)R] = 0.27√(227.6 × 875) = ≈ 120 kmph. At 130 kmph the cant deficiency would be about 137 mm (> 100 mm), so the sanctioned 130 kmph cannot be run on this curve without a speed restriction.
Transition length (rate of change of cant or cant deficiency = 35 mm/s):
- Based on cant: L = C_a V_max/(3.6 × 35) = 127.6 × 120/126 = ≈ 122 m.
- Based on cant deficiency: L = 100 × 120/126 = 95 m.
- Based on cant gradient 1 in 720: L = 0.72 × 127.6 = 92 m.
- Adopt the largest, L ≈ 122 m (say 125 m).
How this answer will be evaluated
What earns full marks: All calculations correct, clear steps, and proper units used.
Evaluation rubric
Each sub-part is marked on its own, against the marks and word limit printed on the paper.
- (a) Compute PERT parameters, event times, slack, and identify the critical path. 20 marks
calculate— given → formula → substitution → result with units → interpretation
Must cover
- t_e = (t_o + 4t_m + t_p)/6: 1-2 = 8, 1-3 = 9, 1-4 = 10, 2-6 = 7, 3-5 = 8, 4-5 = 10, 4-7 = 11, 5-6 = 6, 5-7 = 12, 6-7 = 6 days; dummy 2-3 = 0
- Forward pass E = 0, 8, 9, 10, 20, 26, 32 and backward pass L = 0, 12, 12, 10, 20, 26, 32 for events 1–7
- Slack: event 2 = 4 days, event 3 = 3 days, all others 0; critical paths 1-4-5-6-7 and 1-4-5-7, both 32 days
- Dummy 2→3 carries only logic (3-5 waits for event 2); the critical path fixes the project duration and has zero float
Loses marks
- Incorrect critical path identification
- Missing slack calculations for non-critical events
Earns more
- Correctly calculates slack for all events
- Identifies critical path duration as 32 days
- Explains dotted arrow as a dummy activity
Extra mark
- Neatly drawn network diagram with times
- (b) Design tie bars for longitudinal joints based on frictional force. 15 marks
calculate— given → formula → substitution → result with units → interpretation
Must cover
- Functions: hold slabs together at the longitudinal joint, prevent separation and differential settlement, keep the joint tight for load transfer and against water ingress
- Force per metre of joint = f W h b = 1.35 × 2400 × 0.30 × 3.75 = 3645 kg
- A_s = force/S_s: 1.82 cm²/m with deformed bars (S_s = 2000), so 12 mm bars at about 60 cm c/c (plain bars: 2.92 cm²/m, 12 mm at 38 cm)
- Length L = d S_s/(2 S_b) = 1.2 × 2000/(2 × 24.6) = 48.8 cm, provide 50 cm (plain bars: 43 cm, provide 45 cm)
Loses marks
- Omission of frictional force calculation
- Incorrect unit conversion in force calculation
Earns more
- Correct calculation of total frictional force
- Proper selection of bar diameter and spacing
Extra mark
- Sketch of tie bar arrangement
- (c) Calculate superelevation, max speed, and transition length for a curve. 15 marks
calculate— given → formula → substitution → result with units → interpretation
Must cover
- R = 1750/D = 875 m for a 2° B.G. curve
- Cant for the equilibrium speed 90 kmph: e = GV²/(127R) = 127.6 mm; cant excess for 60 kmph goods = 70.9 mm < 75 mm
- Maximum speed with an assumed cant deficiency of 100 mm: V = 0.27√[(C_a + C_d)R] ≈ 120 kmph, so 130 kmph is not permissible on this curve
- Transition length L = C_a V_max/(3.6 × 35) ≈ 122 m (cant-deficiency check 95 m; 0.72C_a = 92 m)
Loses marks
- Incorrect radius calculation
- Missing cant deficiency check
Earns more
- Correct calculation of cant deficiency
- Proper application of transition length formula
Extra mark
- Sketch of superelevation profile
What "Solve" is asking you to do
Choose the method, then carry it through to a final answer. Identifying what kind of problem this is and why that method applies is the first thing marked; a correct figure arrived at invisibly earns almost nothing.
Structure that answers it
Given data and what is required → method chosen, with the reason it applies → set-up (equation, circuit, free body, trial balance) → working, step by step → answer with units and any condition of validity
Where marks are lost
Doing the middle steps mentally and writing only the result. In mathematics papers, a further loss comes from giving a decimal where the exact value in surds or fractions was wanted, or from skipping the justification a part explicitly asks for.
Practice this exact question
Write your answer and it is marked point by point against the model answer above — what you covered, what you missed, what you got wrong.
Evaluate my answer →More from Civil Engineering 2024 Paper II
- Q1 (a) Describe various defects in clay bricks giving sources/causes of defects. (10 marks)…
- Q2 (a) The network for a construction project is shown in the figure given below. The three…
- Q3 (a) (i) Explain spot speed, running speed, space-mean speed, time-mean speed and average…
- Q4 (a) The network of a certain project is shown in the figure given below with the estimate…
- Q5 (a) What is a flood hydrograph ? The monthly discharge (Q) data of a river at a gauging s…