Paper II — Q8
(a) (i) What is Lacey's Silt Factor ? What is its value for standard silt ? Design an earthen canal using Lacey's silt theory…
What is Lacey's Silt Factor ? What is its value for standard silt ? Design an earthen canal using Lacey's silt theory with the following data : Full supply discharge, Q = 15 m³/s Lacey's silt factor, f = 1·0 Canal side-slope = ½ H : 1 V 10 marks
What are spillways ? Which type of spillways are provided in the following dams ?
Bhakra-Nangal Dam
Ramganga (Kalagarh) Dam
Hirakud Dam
Rihand Dam What forces act on a mass-concrete dam ? Explain any two of these forces in detail. 10 marks
Determine the dimensions of a rectangular septic tank serving 100 persons in a hostel. The dimensions of the septic tank must be able to accommodate sedimentation, sludge digestion and sludge storage functionalities. The peak discharge of sewage can be considered as 240 litres per minute. Use the following data : - Surface area required for every 10 litres per minute of peak flow = 0·92 m² - Water depth required in the sedimentation tank = 0·3 m - Freeboard required = 0·3 m - Capacity required for sludge digestion process = 0·032 m³/capita - Capacity required for digested sludge = 0·0002 m³/capita/day - Sludge withdrawal (cleaning) frequency = once in a year - Length to width of tank ratio (L/B) = 2·5 15 marks
Uniform sand is used as a filter medium to treat the water. The sand grains are 0·6 mm in diameter with a shape factor (φ) of 0·85 and specific gravity (G) of 2·67. The bed is 0·65 m deep with a porosity (η) of 0·45. The filter medium is to be expanded to a porosity (ηₑ) of 0·75 by hydraulic backwash. Determine the required backwash velocity, resulting expanded depth and loss through the expanded medium. Assume the following data for use : g = 9·81 m/s² Density of water (ρ) = 998·2 kg/m³ Viscosity of water (μ) = 1·002 × 10⁻³ N.s/m² 15 marks
हिंदी में प्रश्न पढ़ें
(क) (i) लेसी का साद गुणक क्या है ? मानक साद के लिए इसका मान क्या है ? निम्नलिखित आँकड़ों का उपयोग करते हुए लेसी के साद सिद्धान्त द्वारा एक मिट्टी की नहर की अभिकल्पना कीजिए : पूर्ण आपूर्ति निस्सरण, Q = 15 घन मीटर प्रति सेकण्ड लेसी का साद गुणक, f = 1·0 नहर की पार्श्व-प्रवणता = ½ H : 1 V (10 अंक)
उत्प्लव क्या हैं ? निम्नलिखित बाँधों में किस प्रकार के उत्प्लव प्रदान किए गए हैं ?
भाखड़ा-नांगल बाँध
रामगंगा (कालागढ़) बाँध
हीराकुड बाँध
रिहन्द बाँध एक पुंज-कंक्रीट बाँध पर कौन-से बल कार्य करते हैं ? इनमें से किन्हीं दो बलों की विस्तृत व्याख्या कीजिए। (10 अंक)
(ख) एक छात्रावास में 100 व्यक्तियों के लिए उपयोग किए जाने वाले आयताकार सेप्टिक टैंक की विमाएँ निर्धारित कीजिए। सेप्टिक टैंक की विमाएँ अवसादन, अवपंक पाचन और अवपंक भंडारण की कार्यक्षमताओं को समायोजित करने में सक्षम होनी चाहिए। मलजल का चरम निस्सरण 240 लीटर प्रति मिनट माना जा सकता है। निम्नलिखित आँकड़ों का उपयोग कीजिए : - प्रत्येक 10 लीटर प्रति मिनट अधिकतम प्रवाह के लिए आवश्यक सतह क्षेत्रफल = 0·92 वर्ग मीटर - अवसादन टैंक में पानी की आवश्यक गहराई = 0·3 मीटर - आवश्यक मुक्तांतर (फ्रीबोर्ड) = 0·3 मीटर - अवपंक पाचन प्रक्रिया के लिए आवश्यक क्षमता = 0·032 घन मीटर/व्यक्ति - पचित अवपंक के लिए आवश्यक क्षमता = 0·0002 घन मीटर/व्यक्ति/दिन - अवपंक निकासी (सफ़ाई) की आवृत्ति = वर्ष में एक बार - टैंक की लम्बाई और चौड़ाई का अनुपात (L/B) = 2·5 (15 अंक)
(ग) जल के प्रशोधन के लिए एकसमान रेत को एक छन्नक (फिल्टर) माध्यम के रूप में उपयोग किया जाता है। रेत के कण 0·6 मिमी व्यास के हैं जिनका आकृति गुणक (φ) 0·85 है और आपेक्षिक घनत्व (G) 2·67 है। परत (संस्तर) 0·65 मीटर गहरी है और इसकी संरंध्रता (η) 0·45 है। फिल्टर माध्यम को द्रविक प्रतिधावन (हाइड्रॉलिक बैकवाश) द्वारा 0·75 की संरंध्रता (ηₑ) तक विस्तारित किया जाना है। आवश्यक प्रतिधावन वेग, परिणामी विस्तारित गहराई और विस्तारित माध्यम से होने वाले ह्रास को ज्ञात कीजिए। उपयोग के लिए निम्नलिखित आँकड़े (डेटा) मान लीजिए : g = 9·81 m/s² जल का घनत्व (ρ) = 998·2 kg/m³ जल की श्यानता (μ) = 1·002 × 10⁻³ N.s/m² (15 अंक)
The figure this question refers to, in words
The question paper is a scan and the diagram did not survive as text. This is the figure as read from the original page — every component, value and label — so the question can be worked from the text below.
(c) A cross-sectional diagram of a gravity dam structure. The dam has a vertical upstream face and a sloping downstream face. The total height of the dam is 27 m. The top width of the dam is 6 m. The base width is divided into two sections: 6 m on the upstream side and 15 m on the downstream side. The downstream face slopes at a ratio of 0.75 horizontal to 1.0 vertical. The water level on the upstream side is 3 m below the top of the dam. On the downstream side, the ground level is 10 m below the top of the dam, and the total depth to the base is 20 m. Arrows labeled W1 and W2 indicate the direction of water pressure or weight forces acting on the dam. Below the diagram, the following data is provided: friction coefficient (mu) = 0.70, unit weight of concrete (gamma_c) = 24 kN/m3, unit weight of water (gamma_w) = 10 kN/m3, uplift pressure (q) = 1400 kN/m2.
Model answer
Drafted with AI by UPSC Answer Check against this question's marking rubric, to the expected length. UPSC does not publish answers for Mains — this is one way to score well, not an official key. How we build rubrics and answers.
(a)(i) Lacey's silt factor (f) expresses how the size of the bed material controls the regime (non-silting, non-scouring) dimensions of a channel in alluvium:
f = 1.76 √d_mm, where d_mm is the mean diameter of the bed material in millimetres.
Standard silt has f = 1.0, corresponding to d = (1/1.76)² ≈ 0.32 mm. Coarser material gives f > 1 and finer material f < 1.
Design data: Q = 15 m³/s, f = 1.0, side slope ½ H : 1 V.
1. Regime velocity: V = (Qf²/140)^(1/6) = (15/140)^(1/6) = 0.689 m/s
2. Area: A = Q/V = 15/0.689 = 21.77 m²
3. Hydraulic mean depth: R = (5/2)(V²/f) = 2.5 × 0.689² = 1.19 m
4. Wetted perimeter: P = 4.75√Q = 4.75√15 = 18.40 m
5. Bed slope: S = f^(5/3)/(3340 Q^(1/6)) = 1/(3340 × 15^(1/6)) = 1/(3340 × 1.570) = 1 in 5245
6. Section dimensions. Each ½ : 1 side slope has a length D√(1 + ¼) = 1.118D, so:
- P = B + 2.236D
- A = BD + 0.5D²
Eliminating B: A = PD − 1.736D², i.e. 1.736D² − 18.40D + 21.77 = 0.
Solving: D = 1.36 m and B = 18.40 − 2.236 × 1.357 = 15.36 m
Check: A = 15.36 × 1.357 + 0.5 × 1.357² = 21.77 m² and R = 21.77/18.40 = 1.18 m, consistent with the regime values.
Adopt: bed width 15.4 m, full supply depth 1.36 m, side slopes ½ : 1, bed slope 1 in 5250, with freeboard and banks as per the canal class.
(a)(ii) Spillways. A spillway is the safety valve of a dam. It passes surplus flood water from the reservoir safely to the river downstream, so that the reservoir never rises above its maximum water level and the dam is not overtopped. It must carry the design flood, and it ends in an energy dissipator (stilling basin, ski-jump bucket or roller bucket) that protects the river bed at the toe.
Spillways at the named dams:
- Bhakra (concrete gravity): controlled overflow (ogee) spillway on the dam body, with four radial crest gates.
- Ramganga, Kalagarh (earth and rock-fill): gated chute spillway built separately from the embankment, with five radial gates, because water cannot be passed over an earth dam.
- Hirakud (composite earth, concrete and masonry): gated ogee overflow spillways in the concrete and masonry sections, with crest gates and under-sluices.
- Rihand (concrete gravity): gated ogee overflow spillway on the dam body.
Forces on a mass-concrete (gravity) dam:
- self-weight;
- water pressure, from the reservoir and the tailwater;
- uplift pressure;
- silt pressure;
- wave pressure;
- ice pressure (in cold regions);
- earthquake forces, both horizontal and vertical, including hydrodynamic pressure of the reservoir.
1. Water pressure. This is the main destabilising force. On a vertical upstream face the pressure rises linearly from zero at the surface to γ_w h at the base, so the resultant is P = ½ γ_w h² per metre run, acting horizontally at h/3 above the base. If the upstream face is battered, the weight of water on the slope adds a vertical, stabilising component. Tailwater pressure acts on the downstream face in the opposite direction.
2. Uplift pressure. Water seeping through the foundation and through joints in the body pushes upward on the base and reduces the effective weight of the dam.
- Without drains, the uplift varies linearly from γ_w h at the heel to γ_w h′ (tailwater head) at the toe, and acts on the full area.
- With a drainage gallery, the intensity at the line of drains is reduced to the tailwater pressure plus one-third of the difference between reservoir and tailwater pressures, which cuts the total uplift sharply.
Uplift lowers the resistance to both sliding and overturning, which is why grout curtains and drainage holes are provided.
(b) Given 100 persons, peak flow 240 L/min and L/B = 2.5.
1. Surface area for sedimentation. 240 L/min is 24 units of 10 L/min: Area = 24 × 0.92 = 22.08 m²
2. Volumes required:
- Sedimentation: 22.08 × 0.3 = 6.62 m³
- Sludge digestion: 0.032 × 100 = 3.20 m³
- Digested-sludge storage for one year: 0.0002 × 100 × 365 = 7.30 m³
- Total liquid capacity = 17.12 m³
3. Plan dimensions: 2.5B² = 22.08, so B = 2.97 m and L = 7.43 m. Provide L = 7.5 m and B = 3.0 m (area 22.5 m²).
4. Depth:
- Liquid depth = 17.12/22.5 = 0.76 m, made up of 0.30 m for sedimentation, 0.14 m for digestion and 0.32 m for sludge storage.
- Adding 0.3 m freeboard gives 1.06 m. Provide 1.1 m overall depth.
Result: a rectangular septic tank 7.5 m × 3.0 m × 1.1 m overall (including 0.3 m freeboard). It should have inlet and outlet tees or baffles dipping below the scum layer, a vent pipe, and be desludged once a year. The effluent goes to a soak pit or dispersion trench.
(c) Data: d = 0.6 mm, φ = 0.85, G = 2.67; bed L = 0.65 m, η = 0.45; expanded η_e = 0.75; ρ = 998.2 kg/m³, μ = 1.002 × 10⁻³ N·s/m².
1. Terminal settling velocity of the grains
v_s = [4g(G − 1)d/(3C_D)]^½, with C_D = 24/Re + 3/√Re + 0.34 and Re = φρv_s d/μ.
Trial v_s = 0.10 m/s gives Re = 0.85 × 998.2 × 0.10 × 0.0006/1.002 × 10⁻³ = 50.8, C_D = 1.23 and v_s = 0.103 m/s. Iterating to convergence gives Re = 53.0 and C_D = 1.205:
v_s = [4 × 9.81 × 1.67 × 0.0006/(3 × 1.205)]^½ = 0.104 m/s
Since 1 < Re < 10⁴, the flow is in the transition range and Stokes' law cannot be used.
2. Backwash velocity for η_e = 0.75
Using the expansion relation η_e = (v_b/v_s)^0.22, so v_b = v_s η_e^(1/0.22) = v_s η_e^4.545:
v_b = 0.1043 × 0.75^4.545 = 0.1043 × 0.2705 = 0.028 m/s (about 28 mm/s or 1.7 m/min)
3. Expanded depth
The volume of sand is unchanged, so L(1 − η) = L_e(1 − η_e):
L_e = 0.65 × (1 − 0.45)/(1 − 0.75) = 1.43 m
4. Head loss through the expanded bed
Once the bed is fluidised, the head loss equals the submerged weight of the grains per unit area:
h_L = L(1 − η)(G − 1) = 0.65 × 0.55 × 1.67 = 0.60 m
The same value follows from the expanded bed: 1.43 × 0.25 × 1.67 = 0.60 m. The bed expands by 120%, the head loss stays constant at about 0.6 m once fluidised, and the wash-water troughs must be set above the 1.43 m expanded level so that no sand is lost.
How this answer will be evaluated
What earns full marks: Complete derivations with correct formulas, units, and final values for all parts.
Evaluation rubric
Each sub-part is marked on its own, against the marks and word limit printed on the paper.
- (a)(i) Define Lacey's silt factor and its standard value, and design a regime canal for Q = 15 m³/s, f = 1.0, side slope ½ : 1. 10 marks
calculate— given → formula → substitution → result with units → interpretation
Must cover
- f = 1.76√d_mm; standard silt f = 1.0 (d ≈ 0.32 mm); f > 1 coarser, f < 1 finer
- V = (Qf²/140)^(1/6) = 0.689 m/s; A = Q/V = 21.77 m²
- R = 5V²/2f = 1.19 m; P = 4.75√Q = 18.40 m; S = f^(5/3)/(3340Q^(1/6)) = 1 in 5245
- Trapezoid with P = B + √5·D and A = BD + D²/2 gives D ≈ 1.36 m, B ≈ 15.4 m
Loses marks
- Using Kennedy's equations instead of Lacey's
- Wrong perimeter term for ½ : 1 slopes (e.g., 2.236 omitted)
Earns more
- Check that A and R of the adopted section match the regime values
- Sketch of the section with FSL, B, D and side slopes
Extra mark
- Mention freeboard/bank widths or limitations of Lacey's theory
- (a)(ii) Define spillways, name the type used at Bhakra, Ramganga, Hirakud and Rihand, list forces on a concrete gravity dam and explain two. 10 marks
describe— define → structure or process in order → labelled diagram → significance
Must cover
- Spillway: structure that safely passes surplus flood water so the reservoir does not overtop the dam
- Bhakra, Hirakud and Rihand: gated overflow (ogee) spillways on the concrete/masonry section; Ramganga (earth-rockfill): gated chute spillway away from the embankment
- Forces: self-weight, water pressure, uplift, silt, wave, ice, earthquake (with hydrodynamic) pressure
- Two forces explained with magnitude and line of action (e.g., P = ½γwh² at h/3; uplift from γwh at heel to tailwater head at toe)
Loses marks
- Calling Ramganga's spillway an ogee on the dam body (it is an embankment dam)
- Listing forces without explaining any
Earns more
- Effect of drainage gallery on uplift, or Zangar/Westergaard hydrodynamic pressure
- Energy dissipator (stilling basin/ski jump) as part of the spillway system
Extra mark
- Ramganga spillway has five radial gates; Bhakra four crest gates
- (b) Design a rectangular septic tank for 100 persons with peak flow 240 L/min, providing for sedimentation, digestion and sludge storage. 15 marks
calculate— given → formula → substitution → result with units → interpretation
Must cover
- Surface area = (240/10) × 0.92 = 22.08 m²
- Volumes: sedimentation 22.08 × 0.3 = 6.62 m³, digestion 0.032 × 100 = 3.2 m³, storage 0.0002 × 100 × 365 = 7.3 m³
- L/B = 2.5: B ≈ 2.97 m, L ≈ 7.43 m, adopt 7.5 m × 3.0 m
- Depth = 17.12/22.5 = 0.76 m liquid + 0.3 m freeboard ≈ 1.1 m overall
Loses marks
- Omitting the annual storage volume
- Forgetting freeboard or the L/B ratio
Earns more
- Sketch showing freeboard, sedimentation, digestion and sludge zones
- Mention inlet/outlet tees or baffles and annual desludging
Extra mark
- Compare with IS 2470 / CPHEEO minimum dimensions
- (c) Find the backwash velocity to expand a 0.65 m uniform sand bed from η = 0.45 to 0.75, the expanded depth and the head loss. 15 marks
calculate— given → formula → substitution → result with units → interpretation
Must cover
- Settling velocity by iteration: Re = φρv_s d/μ ≈ 53, C_D = 24/Re + 3/√Re + 0.34 ≈ 1.21, v_s ≈ 0.104 m/s
- Backwash velocity v_b = v_s·η_e^(1/0.22) ≈ 0.028 m/s (≈ 1.7 m/min)
- Expanded depth L_e = L(1 − η)/(1 − η_e) = 0.65 × 0.55/0.25 = 1.43 m
- Head loss h_L = L(1 − η)(G − 1) = 0.65 × 0.55 × 1.67 = 0.60 m
Loses marks
- Using Stokes' law directly at Re ≈ 50
- Computing head loss by Carman–Kozeny for a fluidised bed
Earns more
- Show that the flow is in the transition range, so the full drag equation is needed
- Note that head loss stays constant once the bed is fluidised
Extra mark
- Link to placing wash-water troughs above the expanded bed level
What "Design" is asking you to do
Produce a specification that meets the given brief and demonstrate that it does. In civil and electrical papers the design is incomplete until it is expressed in buildable numbers — diameter, spacing, section, component value — and checked back against every limit stated.
Structure that answers it
Requirements and permissible values listed → code clause or design basis adopted → proportioning calculations → the specification in final dimensions → check against each requirement → sketch
Where marks are lost
Stopping at a required area or a required value without converting it into the bar size, spacing or component actually provided. The provided-against-required comparison and the serviceability or stability check are separately marked and routinely left out.
Practice this exact question
Write your answer and it is marked point by point against the model answer above — what you covered, what you missed, what you got wrong.
Evaluate my answer →More from Civil Engineering 2024 Paper II
- Q5 (a) What is a flood hydrograph ? The monthly discharge (Q) data of a river at a gauging s…
- Q6 (a) Explain an aquifer. Deduce the expression for discharge (Q) through a well in an unco…
- Q7 (a) A sewer having a 60 cm diameter (D) is required to flow at 0·4 depth (i.e., a proport…
- Q8 (a) (i) What is Lacey's Silt Factor ? What is its value for standard silt ? Design an ear…