Civil Engineering 2024 Paper II 50 marks Calculate

Paper II — Q7

(a) A sewer having a 60 cm diameter (D) is required to flow at 0·4 depth (i.e., a proportional depth d/D = 0·4) on a grade…

(a)

A sewer having a 60 cm diameter (D) is required to flow at 0·4 depth (i.e., a proportional depth d/D = 0·4) on a grade ensuring a degree of self-cleansing equivalent to that obtained at full depth at a velocity of 80 cm/s. Determine the required grade, associated velocities and discharges at full depth and 0·4 depth. The value of Manning's rugosity coefficient (N) = 0·015 may be taken same at all depths of flow. 20 marks

(b)
(i)

Explain the following : Aquitard

(ii)

Specific retention

(iii)

Storage coefficient

(iv)

Coefficient of permeability

(v)

Darcy's Law 15 marks

(c)
(i)

For the gravity dam shown in the following figure, determine I. Factor of safety against sliding II. Factor of safety against overturning [Figure: top width 6 m; total height 30 m with the reservoir water level 3 m below the top (water depth 27 m); upstream face vertical; downstream face vertical for the top 10 m, then sloping at 0·75 H : 1 V over the lower 20 m to the toe; base = 6 m + 15 m; weights W₂ (rectangular part) and W₁ (triangular part) marked.] Take the following data : μ = 0·70, γc = 24 kN/m³ γw = 10 kN/m³ q = 1400 kN/m² 8 marks

(ii)

Explain duty and delta. What is the discharge capacity required of the outlet to irrigate 2200 ha of sugarcane having a Kor depth of 17 cm and a Kor period of 30 days ? 7 marks

हिंदी में प्रश्न पढ़ें

(क) 60 सेमी व्यास (D) वाले सीवर को 0·4 गहराई (यानी आनुपातिक गहराई d/D = 0·4) पर एक प्रवणता पर इस तरह से प्रवाहित होना है कि 80 सेमी प्रति सेकण्ड के वेग पर पूर्ण गहराई पर प्राप्त के तुल्य स्वतः-अपमार्जन की कोटि को सुनिश्चित किया जा सके। पूर्ण गहराई और 0·4 गहराई पर आवश्यक प्रवणता, संबंधित वेगों और निस्सरणों को निर्धारित कीजिए। मैनिंग रगोसिटी गुणांक (N) = 0·015 का मान प्रवाह की सभी गहराइयों पर समान लिया जा सकता है। (20 अंक)

(i)

(ख) निम्नलिखित की व्याख्या कीजिए : स्रावी जलरोधी स्तर (जलरोधक)

(ii)

विशिष्ट धारण

(iii)

संग्रह गुणांक

(iv)

पारगम्यता गुणांक

(v)

डार्सी का नियम (15 अंक)

(ग) (i) निम्नलिखित चित्र में दर्शाए गए भाराश्रित बाँध के लिए, ज्ञात कीजिए : I. सर्पण के विरुद्ध सुरक्षा गुणक II. अपवर्तन के विरुद्ध सुरक्षा गुणक [चित्र: शीर्ष चौड़ाई 6 m; कुल ऊँचाई 30 m, जलाशय का जल-स्तर शीर्ष से 3 m नीचे (जल-गहराई 27 m); प्रतिप्रवाह फलक ऊर्ध्वाधर; अनुप्रवाह फलक ऊपर के 10 m तक ऊर्ध्वाधर, फिर नीचे के 20 m में 0·75 H : 1 V ढाल से टो तक; आधार = 6 m + 15 m; भार W₂ (आयताकार भाग) और W₁ (त्रिभुजाकार भाग) अंकित।] निम्नलिखित आँकड़ों का उपयोग कीजिए : μ = 0·70, γc = 24 किलो न्यूटन प्रति घन मीटर γw = 10 किलो न्यूटन प्रति घन मीटर q = 1400 किलो न्यूटन प्रति वर्ग मीटर (8 अंक)

(ii)

कृति (ड्यूटी) और डेल्टा की व्याख्या कीजिए। 17 सेमी कोर गहराई और 30 दिनों की कोर अवधि वाले 2200 हेक्टेयर गन्ने की सिंचाई के लिए निर्गम (आउटलेट) की आवश्यक निस्सरण क्षमता क्या है ? (7 अंक)

Q7 of the 2024 UPSC Mains Civil Engineering Paper II, as printed
The question as printed in the 2024 Civil Engineering paper

The figure this question refers to, in words

The question paper is a scan and the diagram did not survive as text. This is the figure as read from the original page — every component, value and label — so the question can be worked from the text below.

(c) A cross-sectional diagram of a gravity dam. The dam has a vertical upstream face and a sloped downstream face. The total height of the dam is 27 m. The top of the dam has a width of 6 m. The base of the dam consists of a vertical section of 6 m width and a sloped section extending 15 m horizontally to the toe. The downstream face slopes from the top of the 6 m vertical section down to the toe over a vertical drop of 20 m. The slope of the downstream face is indicated by a triangle with a vertical side of 1.0 and a horizontal side of 0.75. The water level is shown 3 m below the top of the dam. The weight of the dam is divided into two parts: W2 (the rectangular part) and W1 (the triangular part). The toe of the dam is labeled 'Toe'.

Model answer

Drafted with AI by UPSC Answer Check against this question's marking rubric, to the expected length. UPSC does not publish answers for Mains — this is one way to score well, not an official key. How we build rubrics and answers.

(a) Principle. Two flows are equally self-cleansing when the drag (tractive force) they exert on the invert per unit area is the same: γ r s (part-full) = γ R S (full). Because the hydraulic mean depth r at 0.4 depth is smaller than R at full depth, the part-full sewer must be laid steeper: s = S·R/r.

Diagram: Partly full circular sewer at d/D = 0.4 with its hydraulic elements, and forces on the gravity dam with pressure and uplift diagrams

1. Full-bore flow at the reference velocity (Manning's formula)

  • D = 0.60 m and N = 0.015
  • A = π(0.6)²/4 = 0.2827 m², P = π × 0.6 = 1.885 m, R = D/4 = 0.150 m
  • V = (1/N) R^(2/3) S^(1/2), so 0.80 = (1/0.015)(0.150)^(2/3) S^(1/2) = 66.67 × 0.2823 × S^(1/2)
  • S^(1/2) = 0.0425, so S = 0.001807, i.e. 1 in 553
  • Q = 0.2827 × 0.80 = 0.226 m³/s

2. Hydraulic elements at d/D = 0.4

  • Central angle of the wetted arc: cos(α/2) = 1 − 2d/D = 0.2, so α/2 = 78.46° and α = 156.93° (2.739 rad)
  • Area ratio: a/A = (α − sin α)/2π = (2.739 − 0.392)/6.283 = 0.3735, so a = 0.1056 m²
  • Perimeter ratio: p/P = α/360° = 0.4359, so p = 0.822 m
  • Hydraulic mean depth ratio: r/R = 0.3735/0.4359 = 0.857, so r = 0.1285 m

3. Grade for equal self-cleansing

  • s = S × R/r = 0.001807 × 0.150/0.1285 = 0.002109, i.e. 1 in 474
  • Check: tractive force γrs = 9810 × 0.1285 × 0.002109 = 2.66 N/m², the same as γRS for full-bore flow at 1 in 553.

4. Velocities and discharges at the required grade of 1 in 474

  • At 0.4 depth: v = (1/0.015)(0.1285)^(2/3)(0.002109)^(1/2) = 66.67 × 0.2546 × 0.04592 = 0.78 m/s, and q = 0.1056 × 0.78 = 0.082 m³/s (82 L/s)
  • At full depth: V = (1/0.015)(0.150)^(2/3)(0.002109)^(1/2) = 66.67 × 0.2823 × 0.04592 = 0.864 m/s, and Q = 0.2827 × 0.864 = 0.244 m³/s (244 L/s)

The ratios v/V = 0.90 and q/Q = 0.34 agree with the partial-flow curves for constant N. So a 60 cm sewer laid at 1 in 474 and running 0.4 full (0.78 m/s, 82 L/s) is as self-cleansing as the same sewer running full at 0.8 m/s on 1 in 553. Note that at 0.4 depth the velocity is almost the reference value, yet a flatter grade would not be enough, because the drag on deposits depends on r·s and not on velocity alone.

(b)

(i) Aquitard. A saturated bed of low permeability, such as sandy or silty clay. It stores appreciable water but transmits it too slowly to supply a well. It does leak water vertically to the aquifers above or below it, which are then called leaky aquifers. It differs from an aquiclude (e.g. clay), which holds water but transmits practically none, and from an aquifuge (e.g. unfractured granite), which neither holds nor transmits water.

(ii) Specific retention (S_r). The volume of water a saturated soil or rock retains against gravity drainage, as a fraction of its total volume. The water is held as films on grains and in fine pores by molecular attraction and surface tension. Porosity n = S_y + S_r, where S_y is the specific yield. Clays have high S_r and low S_y, and gravels the reverse.

(iii) Storage coefficient (storativity, S). The volume of water an aquifer releases from storage, or takes into storage, per unit surface area per unit change in head. It is dimensionless.

  • Confined aquifer: water is released by expansion of the water and compression of the aquifer skeleton, S = γ_w b(α + nβ), where b is the thickness, α the aquifer compressibility and β the water compressibility. Typical values are 10⁻⁵ to 10⁻³.
  • Unconfined aquifer: the pores actually drain, so S ≈ specific yield, about 0.01 to 0.3.

(iv) Coefficient of permeability (hydraulic conductivity, K). The discharge per unit cross-sectional area under unit hydraulic gradient, i.e. the Darcy velocity when i = 1, in m/s or m/day. It depends on both the medium and the fluid, K = kγ/μ, where k is the intrinsic permeability of the medium. It falls by orders of magnitude from gravel (about 10⁻² m/s) through sand and silt to clay (below 10⁻⁹ m/s).

(v) Darcy's law. For laminar flow through a saturated porous medium, the discharge velocity is proportional to the hydraulic gradient:

V = K i and Q = K i A, where i = −dh/dl

Here V is the apparent velocity over the gross area; the actual seepage velocity through the pores is V/n. The law is valid for laminar flow, with a particle Reynolds number up to about 1 (at most about 10), and it underlies well hydraulics, seepage analysis and pumping tests.

(c)(i) Geometry from the figure: total height 30 m (3 m freeboard and 27 m water depth); top width 6 m; the downstream face is vertical for the top 10 m and then slopes at 0.75 H : 1 V over the lower 20 m, giving a base B = 6 + 15 = 21 m. There is no tailwater.

Assumptions: the question gives no uplift data, so full uplift varying linearly from γ_w h = 10 × 27 = 270 kN/m² at the heel to zero at the toe (no drainage gallery) is taken, and the no-uplift case is also given. q = 1400 kN/m² is the shear strength of the dam–foundation joint, used in the shear-friction factor. γ_c = 24 kN/m³.

Forces per metre length (lever arms from the toe):

  • W₂ (rectangle 6 × 30 m): 6 × 30 × 24 = 4320 kN ↓, arm 15 + 3 = 18 m, resisting moment 77,760 kN·m
  • W₁ (triangle 15 × 20 m): ½ × 15 × 20 × 24 = 3600 kN ↓, arm ⅔ × 15 = 10 m, resisting moment 36,000 kN·m
  • Water pressure P: ½ × 10 × 27² = 3645 kN →, arm 27/3 = 9 m, overturning moment 32,805 kN·m
  • Uplift U: ½ × 270 × 21 = 2835 kN ↑, arm ⅔ × 21 = 14 m, overturning moment 39,690 kN·m

ΣV = 4320 + 3600 − 2835 = 5085 kN and ΣH = 3645 kN

I. Factor of safety against sliding

  • Friction alone: FS = μΣV/ΣH = 0.70 × 5085/3645 = 0.98. This is below 1, so friction alone cannot resist sliding.
  • Shear-friction factor: SFF = (μΣV + Bq)/ΣH = (3559.5 + 21 × 1400)/3645 = 32,959.5/3645 = 9.04. This exceeds the usual minimum of 3 to 5, so the dam is safe against sliding once the shear strength of the joint is counted.

II. Factor of safety against overturning (about the toe)

  • FS = ΣM_R/ΣM_O = 113,760/(32,805 + 39,690) = 113,760/72,495 = 1.57, above the required 1.5, so the dam is safe.
  • The resultant cuts the base at (113,760 − 72,495)/5085 = 8.12 m from the toe, so e = 10.5 − 8.12 = 2.38 m, which is less than B/6 = 3.5 m. The resultant lies in the middle third and there is no tension at the heel.

If uplift is ignored (ΣV = 7920 kN): friction FS = 1.52, SFF = 9.59 and overturning FS = 113,760/32,805 = 3.47. The comparison shows how strongly uplift governs stability, and why drainage galleries and a grout curtain are provided.

(c)(ii) Delta (Δ) is the total depth of water a crop needs over its whole base period, for example about 120 cm for sugarcane. Duty (D) is the area that one cumec of water, flowing continuously for the base period B, can irrigate (ha/cumec). The two are related by:

D = 8.64 B/Δ ha/cumec (B in days, Δ in metres)

The kor period is the critical period of the first watering after sowing, when the demand rate is highest, and the kor depth is the depth applied in it. The outlet capacity is therefore fixed by kor watering, not by the average over the season.

Calculation:

  • D = 8.64 × 30/0.17 = 1524.7 ha/cumec
  • Q = area/duty = 2200/1524.7 = 1.44 m³/s

The outlet must deliver about 1.44 cumecs.

How this answer will be evaluated

What earns full marks: Complete working with all steps, units, and checks; neat sketches; all parts fully addressed

Evaluation rubric

Each sub-part is marked on its own, against the marks and word limit printed on the paper.

  1. (a) Find the grade that makes a 60 cm sewer running 0.4 full as self-cleansing as full-bore flow at 0.8 m/s, and the velocities and discharges at full and 0.4 depth. 20 marks

    calculate— given → formula → substitution → result with units → interpretation

    Must cover

    • Full bore: R = D/4 = 0.15 m; Manning with V = 0.8 m/s gives S = 1 in 553 (Q = 0.226 m³/s)
    • Partial-flow elements at d/D = 0.4: α = 156.9°, a/A = 0.3735, p/P = 0.436, r/R = 0.857 (r = 0.1285 m)
    • Equal self-cleansing = equal tractive force γrs = γRS, so s = S·R/r = 1 in 474
    • At 1 in 474: v = 0.78 m/s, q = 0.082 m³/s (0.4 depth); V = 0.864 m/s, Q = 0.244 m³/s (full)

    Loses marks

    • Using equal velocity instead of equal tractive force without justification
    • Errors in the partial-flow geometry (area or perimeter ratio)

    Earns more

    • Sketch of the part-full section showing d, α and wetted perimeter
    • Check ratios v/V ≈ 0.90 and q/Q ≈ 0.34 against partial-flow curves

    Extra mark

    • Explain why a flatter pipe running part full may deposit solids even at the same velocity
  2. (b) Explain aquitard, specific retention, storage coefficient, coefficient of permeability and Darcy's law. 15 marks

    explain— definition/context → points in order → small example → short close

    Must cover

    • Aquitard: low-permeability saturated bed that leaks water slowly to adjacent aquifers; distinguished from aquiclude and aquifuge
    • Specific retention: water held against gravity per unit volume; porosity = specific yield + specific retention
    • Storage coefficient: water released per unit area per unit decline of head; ~10⁻⁵–10⁻³ confined, ≈ specific yield unconfined
    • Permeability K = discharge per unit area under unit gradient; Darcy's law V = Ki, Q = KiA, valid for laminar flow

    Loses marks

    • Confusing aquitard with aquiclude
    • Stating Darcy's law without its validity limits or units

    Earns more

    • Seepage velocity = V/n distinguished from Darcy velocity
    • K = kγ/μ relating hydraulic conductivity to intrinsic permeability

    Extra mark

    • Typical K ranges from gravel to clay, or Reynolds-number limit of Darcy's law
  3. (c) Find the factors of safety of the given gravity dam against sliding and overturning, and explain duty and delta and the outlet discharge for sugarcane kor watering. 15 marks

    calculate— given → formula → substitution → result with units → interpretation

    Must cover

    • Forces per metre: W₂ = 4320 kN, W₁ = 3600 kN, P = ½ × 10 × 27² = 3645 kN; uplift (if taken) 2835 kN, with assumption stated
    • Sliding: friction FS = μΣV/ΣH = 0.98 (with uplift) and shear-friction factor (μΣV + Bq)/ΣH = 9.04, safe
    • Overturning about toe: 113,760/(32,805 + 39,690) = 1.57 with uplift (3.47 without); resultant within middle third
    • Duty D = 8.64B/Δ = 8.64 × 30/0.17 = 1525 ha/cumec; outlet Q = 2200/1525 = 1.44 m³/s

    Loses marks

    • Wrong centroid of the triangular block or omitting it
    • Using the full crop period instead of the kor period

    Earns more

    • Lever arms taken correctly from the toe (18 m, 10 m, 9 m, 14 m)
    • Define kor period and kor depth and why they govern outlet capacity

    Extra mark

    • Check eccentricity e = 2.38 m < B/6 = 3.5 m (no tension at heel)
What "Calculate" is asking you to do

Apply the standard formula or schedule to data the question has already supplied — a table of readings, cost records, a balance sheet — and produce the number. The method is rarely in doubt; the marks sit in the named intermediate quantities, each of which has to appear as a labelled line.

Structure that answers it

Data as given → formula or standard treatment, named → substitution → each intermediate, labelled → result with units

Where marks are lost

Omitting an intermediate the marking scheme pays for separately, or rounding at an intermediate line so the final figure drifts. In commerce and accountancy, any figure in a statement that no numbered working note supports is treated as unearned.

All UPSC directive words, compared →

Practice this exact question

Write your answer and it is marked point by point against the model answer above — what you covered, what you missed, what you got wrong.

Evaluate my answer →

More from Civil Engineering 2024 Paper II

Write this answer and get it marked in about 20 seconds

Free account: 5 AI evaluations a month, marked against the rubric above.

Start free

Already have an account? Log in